The Way I Used to Be
Ratings47
Average rating4.1
i read this almost in one sitting. i listened while i read along physically & wow. i understand why some people didn't like this but i personally loved it. i felt very seen with edy. it hit so unbelievably close to home but in a way that wasn't triggering which is... so weird? i'm definitely going to read book 2 because i am rooting for edy to get justice. i also hope josh is in it. i want to put him in my pocket & protect him all the time.
TRIGGER WARNINGS:
bullying, slt shaming, sxual asault, graphic rpe recounts, acohol & dug consumptions, strong themes of trauma
censoring tw's so goodreads doesn't hate me
I don't know what to think about this book.....It made me uncomfortable towards the ending that I could barely bring myself to read anymore but at the same time I couldn't stop reading. And I think that's the point. It's not meant to be comfortable.
I don't know what to rate this to be honest because I feel like books like this deserve way more than being on a rating scale but I'll rate it 4/5 for the sake of simplicity.
just finished and im speechless
the writing is amazing, so true, so honest, so real
I read this based on a teen therapy client's request. They strongly identify with Eden, the protagonist, unfortunately due to similar experiences, and of course I'm grateful they found something that resonates with their experience! This is a totally serviceable book for any teen book collection, and Smith deals with the aftermath of rape (not a spoiler; that's page 1) generally sensitively. I did have some fairly significant quibbles. First, Smith wrote all the characters as racially ambiguous, and I suppose I see the intention (while noting what certain roads are paved with), and shout out to someone who wrote a great article for their high school news site about why racially ambiguous characters aren't actually helpful: https://conantcrier.com/voices/opinions/young-adult-literature-needs-more-representation/. My other quibbles are that some of the supportive characters are pretty one-dimensional, and I really think the 3rd quarter of the book documenting Eden's struggles with self-neglect could have been shortened while still getting the same point across. To end on a positive, though, since I am glad this is out there for teens, Smith resists the urge to tie things up too prettily with a bow at the end, which certainly rings true to life.
this book was beautiful. it hurt at times and I cried a little bit. it was in no way easy to read. at times I wanted to just stop reading. it wasn't enjoyable at all, but it was a necessary read.
I do NOT recommend this book if you are a victim of SA unless you've done a LOT of processing and are willing to get punched in the stomach emotionally. This book wasn't even close to my experience but the way things are described will get you. On to the review.....
On one hand, this book was vivid enough to trigger a visceral reaction in me. I cried the last 2 chapters. On the other hand, it really doesn't have much plot besides a downward spiral, and I felt that it could have done better at portraying key moments in Edy's story. Very emotional, but lacking substance.
I finished this book 24 hours after starting it. I don't even know what to say as I'm still processing it. I was completely hooked by every single page. Amber Smith highlights the fact that rape often happens by those we least expect in the places we least expect. She illustrates why victims of rape usually don't come out right away to tell someone about what they experienced. She shows how easy it is to defend someone accused of rape if they just don't “seem like the kind of person to do such a t
Writing- 4.5
Plot: 5
Characters: 4
Enjoyment: 4.5
Overall: 4.5
-
!TRIGGER WARNING!
-rape and slut shaming-
-
“maybe” could just be another word for hope.
-
This book follows Eden throughout her four years in high school. It starts off from the day she was raped by her brothers best friend Kevin. And it continues on showing how this changes her life from that day on.
Writing: I really liked amber smiths writing. I also liked that she was brave enough to write about a really tough subject and execute it so well.
I do recommend y'all to try to look for a review from a rape victim because it is important.
Plot: I really liked following Eden trough her four years of high school. I thought it was unique and really interesting seeing her development as the years went by.
Characters: I really liked the characters yes they were frustrating at points but I feel like even them being frustrating was important in the development of the story. There were a lot of slut shaming characters and that kinda pissed me off but again I knew that it was important for the storyline. Eden did frustrate me at some parts but then in others I just wanted to hug her and be there for her.
Enjoyment: If you haven't noticed yet, I really enjoyed this book. I cried so much, there's a few pages that have some tear stains.
I do recommend y'all to read it if you're not triggered by the sensitive topics. It's very important and I thank amber for writing such an amazing novel.
Writing- 4.5
Plot: 5
Characters: 4
Enjoyment: 4.5
Overall: 4.5
-
!TRIGGER WARNING!
-rape and slut shaming-
-
“maybe” could just be another word for hope.
-
This book follows Eden throughout her four years in high school. It starts off from the day she was raped by her brothers best friend Kevin. And it continues on showing how this changes her life from that day on.
Writing: I really liked amber smiths writing. I also liked that she was brave enough to write about a really tough subject and execute it so well.
I do recommend y'all to try to look for a review from a rape victim because it is important.
Plot: I really liked following Eden trough her four years of high school. I thought it was unique and really interesting seeing her development as the years went by.
Characters: I really liked the characters yes they were frustrating at points but I feel like even them being frustrating was important in the development of the story. There were a lot of slut shaming characters and that kinda pissed me off but again I knew that it was important for the storyline. Eden did frustrate me at some parts but then in others I just wanted to hug her and be there for her.
Enjoyment: If you haven't noticed yet, I really enjoyed this book. I cried so much, there's a few pages that have some tear stains.
I do recommend y'all to read it if you're not triggered by the sensitive topics. It's very important and I thank amber for writing such an amazing novel.
Terlalu berharap banyak pada buku ini. Blurb nya menjanjikan, mengenai seorang remaja yg diperkosa oleh teman kakaknya, bahkan bisa dibilang mereka tumbuh besar bersama. Namun ternyata aku kecewa.
Sepanjang buku hasratku hanya ingin memukulkan kepala Eden ke tembok. Dari dia mengacaukan hubungan manisnya dgn Josh hingga berantakannya hubungan diaq dgn org2 yg benar2 peduli padanya. Dan begitu susahnya dia membuka diri, membiarkan org lain untuk menolongnya.
Setidaknya ak menyukai manisnya interaksi Eden & Josh, ketika mereka dekat. walau tdk lama kemudian semua berantakan. Ketika Eden siap mengakui segalanya pada Josh, sdh bertahun2 berlalu & tdk ada pengulangan krn semua sdh melanjutkan hidup.