The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer
Ratings114
Average rating3.7
I was very excited for this one. Was.
Great premise. Terrible execution.
4 stars! Ooh that ending, but was I the only one that had expected more... paranormal stuff?
I'm so disappointed in this, they were so many aspects of this book that just frustrated me to the point where I could no longer enjoy it.
spoilers! both mara dyer and noah shaw marry me in the end. the reason is because i said so. /j
I absolutely devoured this book. I read it so quickly and it didn't feel like 456 pages at all. I'm so invested and my heart after that ending is woah. I'm really glad I have the second one so I can start it immediately. I'm obsessed. So good! I'm pretty sure this review is not very cohesive. But ultimately what I'm trying to say is I LOVED THIS BOOK. IT WAS SO GOOD!!!
What I hated about this book is that it had an element of randomness to it. And cheesiness. A lot. Although it was written better than most YA books but stillllll.
If I were to describe this book as one thing...it would be weird. But a good weird. I never really knew what was happening, but I certainly enjoyed it.
I love it so much when you discover a book and it appears it's one of that kind where you absolutely CAN'T put the holy thing down. Like literally.
Full review to come (if I'm motivated) (i'll try)
That was FANTASTIC.
HOLY MOTHER OF JESUS CHRIST
I LITERALLY FEEL BLESSED TO HAVE READ THIS BOOK
I MEAN
HOLY SHIT
I WAS EXPECTING SOMETHING GOOD
IT BLEW MY MIND
I CAN'T EVEN MAKE REAL SENTENCES
HOLY MOTHERFUCKING SHIT FUCK CRAP
SO INTENSE
I LOVED EVERY MINUTE
GIVE ME THE NEXT ONE IMMEDIATELY
Spoiler HOW IN THE HELL IS JUDE STILL ALIVE WHAT THE FUCK DID ANYONE SEE THAT COMING BECAUSE I SURE AS HELL DIDN'T.
4.5/5 stars.
I think my brain is broken.
Full review:
I'm a total sucker for unreliable narrators and Unbecoming absolutely takes full advantage of Mara's extremely unreliable narration (and I'm not spoiling anything to say so). I was quoting Mockingjay's “real or not real?” throughout the book, there are twists galore, and the paranormal/supernatural aspect was so perfectly creepy. And I was totally impressed with all of that, and then I reached the end, and now I seriously need the sequels, which I will be buying together. And as an added bonus, I appreciated the incidental diversity integrated into the cast.
My one peeve was more of a writing quirk than anything else: there are a ton of filter phrases, which honestly is something I see all over the place, but I noticed it more than usual for some reason while reading Unbecoming. That said, it in no way ruined the reading experience for me, and it's a super minor flaw that most people probably won't even notice. So.
Unbecoming is twisty, eerie, unintentionally takes advantage of my fear of swamps, and I absolutely enjoyed it. Definitely recommended for those of you who like creepy book with trippy plots that leave you wondering what the hell just happened.
The unbecoming of Mara Dyer was delightfully grim and fascinating. I loved the psychological aspects. The characters often took me off guard in so many unexpected ways, and I loved that about them. I was especially fond of Mara's family and friends. Very well written! I can't wait to read the next installment.
Spoilers:
Can't believe how much I hated Noah at first.
And how wrong I was.
Oops! He ended up rocking!
The way Mara felt herself becoming more and more unstable made me wonder if this will affect me into acting the same way as Mara: Will I start becoming more paranoid? Will I start seeing hallucinations?
Quería leer un libro de misterio...Y la portada en sedujo. Me ha ido ganando poco a poco y me he cagado mucho en el final: porque no acaba. Conclusión: me ha gustado xD
I could not put this down. Even though I figured out a few of the twists before they happened, I was still riveted by the story. Can't wait to see where the series takes us next!
The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer, is an ever twisting road of acid-tripping moments that keep you on the edge of your seat. From the insane hallucinations to the mystery surrounding all the deaths, it leaves a hangover for the reader, but in a good way (I know contradiction since hangovers a a beast! lol)
This is just one of those books that I do believe lived up to the hype. Not everyone would agree, but for myself it did. Not many books can impress nor leave me thinking the way this novel did. I can see this not only being a movie series, but more importantly would rather see this be made into a television series if the rights were ever bought for the book.
Anyway... Noah and Mara have this bizarre chemistry together. From the moment they lock eyes across the quad till the last chapter, you know they belong together; even if you think other wise throughout reading it. I don't know why but there seems to be a trend lately in the books I'm reading of the boys are all broody. And as it was said on Buffy the Vampire Slayer, “he's all Mr. Billowy-coat, king of pain,” something of which Noah easily brings to the table when it comes to his past. The one thing Mara keeps on trying to figure out. Luckily but the end she understand a lot about him and why they are drawn together. It's also very dangerous for them to be together. Something of which I won't reveal, but it's an important aspect in the story.
Now for the insanity that swept the book: Jude. That character really has a pivotal role throughout Mara's journey. Everywhere she goes, when her mind starts to slip, he will almost likely be there. The strange part? He's dead! But at the end something is revealed, BIG spoiler that I won't spill, but it changes everything about Jude, in a creepy way. Something that is sure to be explained in the sequel.
Now there were passages in the book that caught my attention. Not sure if Hodkin was trying to make certain references, but I felt that on page 17, the black crows were foreshadowing the many deaths in Mara's future. This reference has been used in other pop culture situations (i.e. - One Tree Hill's pilot episode. Lucas tells Haley that it's a murder of crows.)
Overall, TUMD (aka - The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer), left me feeling baffled by the cliffhanger and desperate for the next installment of Mara's world. This isn't for everyone, but it's worth a go at least once, especially with Halloween just around the corner.
(Review originally posted at Fictionally Inclined.)
I fully intended to review at least one the books I read earlier in the month that are due back at the library. Instead, I am reviewing this book. Because I just...need to. I got The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer from the library on January 26 (this past Thursday). I was in the middle of another book right then, but I knew that I was going to want to discuss Mara with someone when I was finished. So I gave it to my friend Lynne. She flew threw it, and the next thing I knew, she was at my door later that afternoon, telling me I needed to read it ASAP. I was going to read it over this weekend, but I heeded her and picked it up that night. And finished it a little after 2 in the morning, much do my dismay. I was right. I DID need someone to discuss it with, but everyone was asleep. So, after sending a lamenting text to Twitter, I switched off my reading lamp and went to bed. Only problem was that this book? Isn't exactly conducive to sleep. I tossed and turned, mind wide awake and still spinning with possibilities, until giving up and sticking my well-used DVD of Two Weeks Notice into my laptop, plugging in headphones, and watching my tied-for-absolute-favorite movie until I fell asleep. Thankfully, the next morning, Lynne and I were able to debrief and exchange theories and just talk about everything pertaining to Mara. It was a great (and much needed) talk. I just love talking about books, particularly with people who love them as much as I do. ♥
Lots and lots of spoilers ahead. Proceed at your own risk.
The first word that comes to mind when I start to describe this book is somewhat less than appropriate. So, we'll just call it a mind...warp. Yes. Mindwarp.
I don't do thrillers. I might watch an action/adventure or mystery movie with just a hint of thriller and suspense mixed in, but I don't do thriller/horror stuff. I don't enjoy scaring myself; I simply don't see the point of it. So this book pushed my boundaries a little. But it was so fascinating because you didn't know what was simply Mara's PTSD and what was...something else. The scene where she comes back to the empty house and the water turns itself off and her earrings were at the bottom of the tub? Holy crap, I am pretty sure I barely breathed. It was just so thrillingly creepy. I'm glad that was as creepy as it got, though, because I am not sure I would have finished it otherwise. But! I will say that Hodkin masterfully crafted this book, because I would be tingling from nerves one second and laughing out loud the next. It was a great balance of suspense, intrigue, humor, and romance. This book also induced a lot of gasps. I'm not entirely sure why that happened, because I'm not a gasping person. I was just so on-edge for the entire book that every little thing set me off.
I find it interesting that all the names of the main characters are Biblical. Mara, Daniel, Jude, Noah, Joseph. It's interesting, and I wonder if that will be at all relevant later.
Speaking of Mara, Daniel (whom I loved and would love to see featured in a spin-off), and Joseph, I loved their sibling relationship. I was touched by the affection and protection between them, and their exchanges cracked me up. They were just so realistic and made the siblings believable.
❝Your level of neuroses will only find love in a made-for-TV movie.❞
❝It's too early to be such an asshat.❞
not
Lolita
Do you know what's it's like to have your sense of reality questioned? To face such trauma that after a while, you ask yourself, “Am I dreaming or awake right now?” Honestly, that was the feeling I felt as I was reading The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer. It's one of those books that you think is going to be kept hush, hush so everyone in the world can read it and not be spoiled. So everyone in the world can individually have their minds blown without any preparation as to what the contents in this book will do to them. I understand why the synopsis is so brief, they–being publishers–want to draw you in, peak your interest just enough so you could start the book. Then the author takes it from there. Hodkin puts this spell on you as you're reading, just a taste of one to keep you entranced, and as you're sinking deeper into the depth of the pages...you're tested. Your mind is tested and you will ask yourself once you've finished, “Am I dreaming or awake right now?”
First of all, the relationship between Mara and Noah doesn't start as anything unique. Mind you, we have another rich boy, man-whore taking an interest in the new girl and you know they're going to end up together. But my goodness, the scathing remarks these two throw at each other was just wonderful to witness. I felt like I needed to keep a mental scoreboard just to keep up with who was ahead in the insult department.If I wasn't doing this review on an ARC of this book, I'd tell you every single one that stood out for me. They got so entangled into each other, emotionally and mentally, it was a definite thrill to see their connection become stronger and more meaningful as the story went on. I also had three other favorite characters that I could not get enough of: Daniel, Joseph and Jamie. Out of all three Jamie had to be the most rounded because he had his sense of style, of being that I wasn't able to ignore, an in-your-face personality.
Another element I must mention, is that using my hometown as the setting for this book was absolutely brilliant. I am saying this somewhat subjectively but in the end, I thought it worked best to put a girl who grew up with snow and public schools in the polar opposite of an environment and see how she fared. Hodkin's writing style was what made the book's plot so addicting to read, so spell-binding that I had to lock myself in my room for hours on end till I was finished.
It starts as just another contemporary novel with a tragic twist that ends up turning the protagonist's life upside down. It didn't feel slow-going even though it was only after the first 270 or so pages that I started to get the feeling, no matter how many predictions I made I would never figure this book out until I read it the whole way through. I'd feel like my assumptions were set in stone, like there was no way I wrong about what was going on–because I'm smart like that–and the book would just taunt me with every surprise at every corner. In itself, those first 270 pages could have been the first book of the series and all that followed after it, book 2. Those first pages were well-developed and I would not have hesitated to buy the next book, but you don't know how ecstatic and a little insane I felt reading the last third of the thick book. Overall, The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer made me feel crazy because seriously, what a cliffhanger.
Grade: A-