The Freeze-Frame Revolution
Ratings60
Average rating3.9
The general plot makes no sense and the world built as well..
The author had a nice idea - but very poorly executed :(
Great stuff from Watts as always. This one is tough to rate because The Island, a short story set farther in the future in the same storyline, with Sunday also as the narrator, is much much better. It’s incredible. It won the Hugo. Because I read The Island first, FFR felt like a prequel to me, and I’m not the biggest fan of prequels.
That being said, FFR has great characters (although admittedly I lost track of who was who a bit by the end). Lian is fantastic. Sunday is a little boring but has great development. Again, she is even better in The Island. Shout out to having multiple characters with neopronouns. And shout out to batshit superintelligent women.
I changed my rating halfway through writing this because I remembered how good the worldbuilding is. It’s such a good concept and it’s executed in a style that mushed my brain around in the best way. The eighth note gimmick was fun, although not groundbreaking. I am eagerly looking forward to reading the rest of the series.
Although this was my first read from this author and there are other books in this series, this was great hard-sci-fi. It doesn't lend well to following along on audiobook and there were many times I had to pause and rewind. I believe for this book a print/e copy would have been better to truly absorb everything.
I enjoyed the suspense and the mutiny of the whole CHIMP situation. It really kept my attention through this short read. It had a bit of Annihilation meets Leviathan Wakes with the ‘spaceship AI' character who may be a puppet, or may be pulling the strings itself.
Completely unique POV (at least to me) made this a wonderful read. I will be seeking out the other tales in the Sunflower series! (Note to author and/or publisher: please consider releasing Freeze-Frame Revolution and the related stories as a single omnibus publication!) The sense of wonder in this book combined with the extremely well-constructed human tensions make it an easy recommendation for those inclined toward “hard” science fiction stories. Reminded me a lot of Alastair Reynold's works in the “Revelation Space” universe, but different enough to not seem derivative in any way.
Originally posted on bluchickenninja.com
This particular book is the second in a series of short stories written by Watts called the Sunflower Cycle. The other short stories have been written over the last 10 years and can be found for free on Watt's website. The correct reading order for the series is Hotshot, The Freeze-Frame Revolution, The Island and Giants. However you could quite easily jump in at this second book and not miss anything.
The conflict in The Freeze-Frame Revolution mainly comes from the differing politics between the humans and AI. The humans spend most of their time in stasis, waking every thousand years if the CHIMP needs help creating a wormhole gate. This is a job they have been doing for millions of years, and will seemingly continue on to the heat death of the universe. Unless they are given some sort of sign telling them to stop. Even though they have already been working long past the mission's original end time.
If you would like a modern comparison think of Curiosity, alone, exploring the surface of Mars. NASA engineer's thought it would have broken down long ago, but it continues to run, meaning it continues to send back data. This is similar to the crew of the Eriophora. However so much time has now passed that it may be impossible for humans, or whatever humans have evolved into, to send a signal ending their mission. However the AI doesn't quite see these things the same way.
Peter Watts has done a brilliant job of making this book feel dark. Time is an important factor to the plot and Watts makes you feel like time is passing, this isn't an easy task, especially when nothing on the ship is really changing. Sunday has a regular job, except when she sleeps 1000 years go by. But Watts puts it into perspective by comparing the time that has passed to how far into the past that represents. A few hundred years, a few thousand and then long before the time of the dinosaurs.
I think there is an element of horror to this book, and it's not because the plot. It comes from putting time in perspective. The big bang was a very long time ago, Sunday spends even more time on the Eriophora, millions and millions of years, and they aren't even half way to the heat death of the universe. Time is long and human lives are short.