In Other Lands

Such a cute story. Great narration

adding this like 5 years after i first read (i think i fucked up my read dates? whatever i first read this forever ago) to say this is probs one of my favorite YA novels of all time. every time i read i notice something new that makes me giggle. truly just SUCH a romp

I'm torn on this one. It started out so strong—hilarious and compelling. Unfortunately, the middle really dragged for me. Everything gets bogged down with angst and failure to communicate. The tropez (ha) get heavy-handed and tangled up. The ending was better than the middle, but I still think the book loses momentum over time.

I did like the ambivalence in characters. Elliot is hurt by people physically, but hurts people verbally. He's committed to diplomacy, but highly abrasive. Luke is an idolized jock, but also a withdrawn bookworm. Serene spends the whole book puzzled by the logic of patriarchy in contrast to elvin culture's intense matriarchy.
This added dimension, though I wish Brennan had allowed her characters to challenge their worldviews earlier on, and more substantially. Elliot was needlessly antagonistic...the whole time. Serene was patronizing...the whole time. Luke should probably have remembered Myra and Peter by some point. That's all I'm saying.

I think fantasy as a genre provides opportunity to explore culture and identity in really expansive ways. And in some ways, Brennan does that. Serene's matriarchal culture of origin shows how contrived gender stereotypes are. Elliot refuses to accept that interactions with those different than or unfamiliar to us have to be violent. Brennan uses several characters to normalize both queerness and its acceptance by peers and family.

Here's the but: talk about prejudices against dwarves and mermaids sits atop a background sorely lacking racial diversity. And then Serene's superlative beauty is repeatedly and explicitly tied to her pale skin. This is an issue in SFF as a whole, but it feels more obvious when a book is nuanced enough to tackle biphobia across several species and realms, but every human just happens to be white.

A few smaller gripes: on two separate occasions, adult characters pursue characters they know to be underage (because they ask), both times responding with some variation of “close enough!” I don't like that. A 20 year-old man was 16 year-old Elliot's first romantic experience with a guy. I don't like that. ALSO, the on-and-off again hyperbolic “I might not come back next year” from Elliot. That misery just doesn't make sense in conjunction with his misery over having absolutely nothing in the human world. I think Brennan was going for a “he feels caught between worlds and doesn't know whether he can belong or be loved anywhere,” but I had trouble buying it.

To end on a good note: I loved Elliot sneaking massive bags of technology to school every year, despite it immediately smoking, Luke saying he looks like “a snail that's about to explode.” I loved Luke and Elliot yelling at one another as Luke comes out in class while Dale holds his hand up for his turn to come out and Serene holds her hand up to ask a question pertinent to the actual lesson.

In all, this would surely be more enjoyable for someone who doesn't care as much about the things I care about. But I'm me, so here we are. I loved some of it, but it's not a favorite.

This is the first review I've ever written on goodreads and I decided I needed to write it because this book deserves so much more love then it gets. Elliott Shafer is one of my favorite protagonists I've ever read. He's so sweet and funny that I actually laughed out loud at points. And the character development he and his two friends go through is cathartic and genuine. It's about friendship, young love and learning to accept yourself all set in a unique and interesting world behind a stone wall.

I didn't want this book to end. I've enjoyed it immensely. It's funny, witty, and original. A big social and human criticism written in an accessible and youthful way, with a super sarcastic and charismatic main character that I couldn't avoid but adore.

An easy read, no complicated battles or too detailed descriptions, just emotions and consequences.

Loved it, really. So entertaining.

I know this was originally published serially on the author's website, and I wonder how much editing was done between website->book? It felt like...maybe not that much, and like maybe....there was some filler that could have gotten cut out.

I debated between 3 and 4 stars for this–I love the concept and this kind of wry portal fantasy; I didn't love the aformentioned lengthiness. Ultimately it had enough clever touches that I rounded up. I also think teens especially will enjoy the elf culture here–it's a matriarchy that basically has reverse gender roles of American society, where women need to protect emotional, fragile men. it's funny but also could definitely be a penny drop moment for some readers who maybe haven't thought about things in quite those terms before. Also bonus points for a bi character who IDs as bi.

It started off wonderfully, then about halfway through, it tanked & never recovered.

The “I'm snarky because stupid people can't tell me what to do” MC became rude. The friendships dropped nearly out of the picture. His desire to see the world turned into an obsession with mermaids (and such a letdown when he found one). His attempts to make the diplomatic corp once again as important as the warriors turned into “I'm coming along just because I think you're incompetent.” His friend's double-track enrollment died to “I'm really a warrior,” without any decent explanation. The hilarious dialogue & writing became flat and/or vicious.

The MG/YA rating jumped to adult. His charming devotion to his intended girlfriend turned into “I'm bisexual & will sleep with anyone” (without prior hints, mind you). His admirable goal of world peace dropped to a sexfest.

I haven't covered everything, but you get the idea. It was a huge disappointment.