If Only I Had Told Her

Genuinely one of the best but saddest books I've ever read! I love it so much!!

4.8! ⭐️

3.75!! i enjoyed the first more, but this was nice for closure!

I didn't want to read this book because I was still heartbroken about Finn. I'm so glad someone told me it will heal that. I laughed and cried but felt I was better able to mourn him. It wrapped up a story I didn't realize needed to be finished. Finny will still live in my heart forever. ❤️

This felt like 3 different short stories by following three different characters. Finn's part was fine, it took me a minute to determine where we were in the storyline. For some reason I thought this book would mirror book 1 and follow Finn instead of Autumn. I didn't realize it picks up almost at the end of book 1 and just finishes up the story. I didn't like Jack's part that much, nor did I really feel like it was necessary. It was surprising that he was included, I think Sylvie may have made more sense, but I would have liked this more if it was just a Finn/Autumn split. Autumn's part was my favorite. though I wish I would have gotten closure on what happens to the baby. Of course the baby would have a hole in her heart, Autumn's story was tragic. this book felt more fast paced than book 1, there was a clear divide between the three different POVs

While this book wasn't near as perfect as the first, it was an overall good book. I just wish it was a 2 pov where Finny was the most prominent character.

3.5 stars!