How the Word Is Passed

Skimmed. I read the sections on Monticello and New York City. Interesting story about the Statue of Liberty. Otherwise, an easy to read travel log sort of book an important point about American monuments and race.

Beautiful and terrible at the same time. You can tell the Clint Smith writes poetry as the stories flowed so smoothly, even while highlighting the horrific things that our countries has done over time.

3.5 stars.

This book should be added to high school history curriculums across the United States.

Clint Smith takes us on a journey through parts of American history that are not taught or known by most Americans. From Monticello to the Whitney Plantation to the Blandford Cemetary, the author talks about stories of the enslaved people and the awful legacy of treatment of black and brown Americans. He also include the study of his grandfather and how this journey impacted him personally.

Clint Smith is also a tremendously talented author, blending solid journalistic techniques with poetry and soaring language. Next, I'd like to read his poetry and Atlantic articles. He also narrates the audiobook version, which I found even more compelling.

Clint Smith visits cemeteries, museums, plantations, and other places associated with slavery and he attends events associated with slavery. He observes carefully and thoughtfully and he questions others visiting the places and attending the events.

The result is this book, one of the best books I've ever read about the history of slavery in America as well as one of the best books I've read this year.

I've read a lot about slavery in America, but this book greatly added to my understanding and is a reminder that in we're still living with the consequences.

This book is so important!

4.5

This book is Clint Smith's recounting of different historical places he visited around the world that had a connection to American slavery. He describes what he sees, who he meets, and the personal impacts these places had on him.

This book was harrowing. While I knew a lot of the horrors that happened during slavery, Smith had a way of wording things that made me really confront what that must have been like, instead of seeing it through the lens of time. These places are so important to our past, yet I had only heard of one of them. This in and of itself highlights how much the American education system leaves out from our teachings. Growing up in Texas, we were only vaguely taught about slavery. I knew it happened and I knew it was bad. It's been through my own research that I've truly discovered how disgusting it was. At the end of the day, Americans owned other humans. This book also shows that the North was not the savior of enslaved people. One of the places Clint Smith visits is NYC, where he showcases how prevalent slavery was even up North.

I think this book should be required reading in schools. I recommend and implore everyone to pick this up.

I don't think I've read any of the author's poems before but as soon as I saw the cover of this book for the first time last year, I knew I had to read it. And while I went in not knowing much about what the book was going to be - expect that it was related to the history of slavery - I was totally floored by the way the author approached this painful past.

I have visited one plantation in the US till now, which is Mt. Vernon - but this was a few years ago and I hadn't yet started reading up on American politics or it's history - so I didn't even realize that the place symbolized more than just being George Washington's estate, it was also built and maintained by hundreds of people he had enslaved. I have come to regret my trip a lot, now that I know a bit more about the estate's history, but the author here brought more light onto the lives of the enslaved people by visiting Jefferson's Monticello plantation and also the privately owned Whitney plantation. As I was listening to the audiobook narrated by the author himself, it was pretty evident how the author was feeling during these research visits of his.

While the author comes to know a bit about the work both the plantations are doing to recognize and present their true history without whitewashing the slavery part of the story, it is still not enough. The tour guides and administrators also mention how difficult it is to tell the true history of the place while not being completely negative about it, because there are always white visitors who are not ready to confront the ugly truths about their historical heroes. This felt like a small microcosm of our current reality where more and more Republican politicians and voters want to curb the teaching of the country's racist history, while also being completely ignorant (or maybe willfully so) about what CRT entails but using it as a scapegoat to pass censorship laws.

But these chapters were probably the easiest to listen to. Because once the author changed his location to the Angola maximum security prison in Louisiana and Blandford cemetery in Virginia, it was very tough to continue to listen to how the administrators of these places try so hard to whitewash their horrific past, especially in Angola prison whose history of extreme violence towards numerous prisoners in solitary confinement is unimaginable. And the caretakers of the biggest mass grave of confederate soldiers in Blandford just want to continue to perpetuate the lost cause myth and how the civil war was about state's rights - not that they ever try to complete that sentence and say that it was about “state's rights to keep slaves”.

I however, felt inspired by the story of Galveston and Juneteenth (it was particularly poignant coz it's 2 days away) and how the declaration of the end of slavery was such a significant event - even if ultimately, it didn't pan out that way in reality. While it took many many decades of violence by white supremacists and activism of courageous Black people to achieve some semblance of civil rights legislation, we are only now realizing how it's extremely important not to forget all that history, because forgetting what happened will only result in history repeating itself.

But ultimately it was the chapter about New York City's history that was eye opening. Because while the north maybe praised as a paragon of liberalism, NYC itself is full of forgotten markers of its own racist past - like being a major trading hub for all the raw materials that were produced by the enslaved people in the southern plantations; being the headquarters for all the major banks which used to accept enslaved people as collateral just like any property; or even how the beautiful Central Park is built upon land owned by free Black people who were forced out of their homes by the NYC government using eminent domain to build the park. And all this business created by the toil of the enslaved people is what built the economy of the country - not that anyone seems to want to acknowledge that while teaching history.

With this brilliant book full of visits to historical places, interviews with scholars and references to primary sources, and also stories told by his own grandparents whose grandparents were themselves enslaved, the author tries to give us a new approach of understanding history. It is painful and emotional to listen to, but it is also unflinching in its honesty, and in its earnestness that we should examine our own biases and not be defensive when confronted with uncomfortable truths. It is a huge responsibility to reckon with the country's past and but only when we acknowledge it that we can move forward and strive for a better future, and make sure that the history will never repeat again. I highly recommend this book to anyone interested in the topic, but I particularly think this would be a good resource for students, despite its tough material.