Empire State: A Love Story

In my newbie-ness, it took me a while to understand that when the drawings where in the shades of red it meant that it was in the past, like flashbacks, and that the blue was in the present. I was really confused at first, but once I figured it out, I was in love with the writing and drawing styles!

Even though the art is really simple, I thought it represented really well the geekiness of their world. The text/illustration ration was, in my opinion, really well balanced; it was definitely a great first graphic novel read!

I certainly recommend it to all the geeky graphic novel lovers and I can't wait to get my hands on Meanwhile, Shiga's first book.

Full Review Over @: The Hungry Bookster

I read this twice and loved it more after my second read. The art is simple and the story is simple. There isn't a real “climax” to the story – the main character tries to create one, but it is completely deflated.

What I really loved about this book is that it's less a story about a boy who follows a girl who is his friend to New York in an attempt to confess his love for her. It's more about a guy who's trying to love somewhere other than home. The character has never left Oakland and has all these romantic ideas about traveling across the country in a Greyhound and meeting his friend at the Empire State Building, just like in Sleepless in Seattle. He has a website, but soon learns that he's completely behind the times in terms of web design; he doesn't know how to work a cell phone. He thinks he needs a passport to fly in a plane. He chooses to send his friend a letter confessing his love to her, rather than call her or, even, email her. He lives with his mom, and his job is binding books at the public library. He lives in a world that is still very tactile and concerned with experiencing all sensations of being alive in the world. He's very much a romantic and idealist, where his friend is more of an intellectual and an academic, sarcastic and dry.

For me, “Empire State” is absolutely a love story for Oakland, for home. I'm a sucker for those. There really is no place like home, whether it's the Bay Area, New York or the desert. Read this one through twice.

A mordern unrequited love story. Simple, yet bittersweet.

I really enjoyed the artwork and coloring of the book, but the story just didn't do it for me. At various times the story is a little bit funny, a little bit sad, or a little bit heartwarming. But it never really goes on past that little bit. Maybe it's just that the main character is named Jimmy, but I couldn't help comparing this book to Jimmy Corrigan, and it certainly doesn't hold up to that standard.

I really enjoyed the artwork and coloring of the book, but the story just didn't do it for me. At various times the story is a little bit funny, a little bit sad, or a little bit heartwarming. But it never really goes on past that little bit. Maybe it's just that the main character is named Jimmy, but I couldn't help comparing this book to Jimmy Corrigan, and it certainly doesn't hold up to that standard.