Dragonfly in Amber
Ratings231
Average rating4
I was going to rate it 3 stars, but I felt bad. Did I like the book? Hell, no. Do I think it's bad? Absolutely not. It's just not my thing. So, if I was going to rate from the gut, 2.75 rounded up to 3. But I can objectively see its qualities, so here, take the 4th star.
(a letter to myself and Diana Gabaldon, I guess)
Dear Lauren,
I regret to inform you that no matter how much you think you like this series or how much you really want to like this series, the evidence shows that you do not. You can't make it through five pages without getting tired or completely spacing out. You have tried. You slogged through the first book over several months YEARS ago. Then you picked this one up off and on for the next couple of years. And I know you're thinking about trying again. But really... I think it's time to move on. Sometimes, the TV series is actually enough. (Because that shit is fire). We wouldn't have that without the book, so thank you Diana Gabaldon. And I'm really really sorry that I watched the series first and now feel like the most terrible reader on the face of the earth.
Sincerely,
I tried.
DNF @ 64% (27hrs audio)
There's a good story in here but I just can't get on with many, many casual threats and mentions of rape and assault. It's been years since I read the first book so I'd clearly forgotten how bad it is, but its so jarring each and every time it comes up, which is a lot. And for this to be written by a woman is even worse.
I just can't get into this one. It's slow, and boring, and enough with the beatings and justifications for them already, Gabaldon. I'll be content to just Google the plot synopsis to figure out my one burning question–why the eff Claire didn't try to get back to Jamie for over 20 years.
I thought some sensitive issues were gonna be glossed over so I was prepared to give a lower rating, but there's no way a book with 800+ pages wouldn't come full circle. The good, the bad, I enjoyed every page of it.
this book was so fucking long jesus christ it was so fucking long. that said it did fuck though. slightly less than outlander fucked but it did fuck.
I really found myself dragging through this book at times. Diana is fantastic at showing, rather than telling the plot, and there's just a ton of things going on/a ton of characters to keep track of. As such, I keep a OneNote going of everything I've read through in a previous chapter. I find this read took up a lot of brain space which is what caused me to drag through it at times.
As much as it is boring, it's also...not my taste. Jamie is.... questionable and I definitely like what the show made of him instead of Gabaldon. Stopped at around 300, skipped forward and saw problematic things, then closed it. Good choice, espy. I would give it one star, but the writing is too good not to consider with the rating. Yeah, would not pick this one up again.
When it's good it's great. It's it's not so good it's dragging and over detailed.
I think I might like this better than the first. More threads appearing and resolving themselves before the ending.
Quite good as a development of the story of Claire and Jaimie. Although in places this story doesn't sound very believable, it's fun reading. In my opinion, this second book does a pretty good in job bringing the story to its logical and expected ending and doesn't really need to be continued in further installments. However, I will probably go on reading the following books out of simple curiosity but I doubt that I will get as far as book 8 unless the characters develop further and story deepens rather than just continue to list adventure after adventure.
Aunque el primer libro es mucho más original que esta segunda parte, se nota una evolución en los fallos, a nivel de personajes, que le encontré a Forastera.
Engancha muchísimo y te mantiene pegada a él. Sólo diré que los días que he tenido que cargarlo en mi bolso han valido la pena.
Para el próximo sólo pido más Escocia y más highlanders.
I wanted to like this book, but expected not to due to previous experiences with sequences of great novels. It is clear the author tried, and some of the aspects I liked in the first book are here.
Two things I did not like and a third failed to impress me:
1) The book started with romance. It took about half the book or more in Outlander for the romance to begin to take place. This book feels like the author received the feedback that “sex sells” from her first book and went with it.
It felt forced, and I was willing to let this go as background noise for the rest of what could be a great plot, but...
2) The prose is too full of descriptions. The author takes too long to transmit an idea. She seems to master the written language very well, but I do not care if there is nothing interesting going on. First sell me on the plot and characters, the prose is a bonus. But hey, the amazing time-traveling, intricate plot was just about sweep me out of my feet, so I could bear this a little longer but...
3) The plot failed to impress me. Jamie and Claire had fled to France and are looking to make themselves useful. They set as their goal to prevent the Scottish rebellion led by the exiled Prince Charles to take place, because it would fail miserably, and lead to the massacred of thousands of Scots and keep the clans under a brutal oppression for two hundred years.
So far so good. But this is developed too slowly. Jamie is trying to get close to Prince Charles and have secured a job as a wine merchant. Claire so far has only managed to make a mortal enemy because of some careless thing she said out loud.
In the midst of some dinners where Claire job is to play the part of a charming hostess, I stopped reading. The first book managed to create an intriguing mystery when she traveled to the past and you were left to wonder what would happen to her. On this one, you already know what happens, because she is telling the story from memory, as she sits safe and sound by the side or her daughter.
The first book was full of characters with unknown motives, a protagonist that doesn't quite know how to behave at that time period, living in an open doors prison where the distance from civilization was her only cell.
In short, the first book captivated me from the start. This one has managed to do little for me in the 6 hours I spent listening to it.
Read 6:15/77:49 8%
[161031] Getting back into this with the tv show in mind made it much more bearable and rather enjoyable once I got to the end. Hopefully the third in the series will be more consistent throughout!
[150329] DNF @ 65%
I'm giving up on this. It is soooo boring and this scene is making my stomach turn, I can't get through it.
I found this volume a bit more meandering, even with some dry spells that took a bit for me to trudge through, but when all is said and done, the final reveals and push toward the end make up for it. The mystery, romance and detail to history is all on fine display and Claire and Jamie's roller coaster relationship that feels both real and genuine is certainly the highlight that keeps you going through the draggy bits. In the final pages setting things up for interesting things to come in the future, leaves the readers reassured that the story won't stop here, but neither will the struggle, heartache, tears and mystery. Looking forward to it in future volumes though.
Diana Gabaldon - curse you for creating a character such as James Alexander Malcolm Mackenzie Fraser. For engaging me so fully in your novels that I'd happily spend all night long reading just to see what happens next to our hero and the wonderful heroine Claire.
This is the second book in Gabaldon's Outlander series and begins in 1968 in Inverness with Claire Randall and her daughter Brianna coming to Scotland to find out the fate of a group of men who are suspected to have died in the battle of Culloden.
Seeking the help off the adopted son of her old friend she appears to hold many secrets and Roger soon begins to wonder how she seems to know so much about the battle and the men she seeks to trace.
Stumbling across the grave of a James Fraser in a small churchyard far from the battlefield of Culloden she breaks down and tells her daughter that the grave if this highlander is that of her father, a man she believes dies in the battle of Culloden over 300 years before.
the rest of the book sweeps is back to the time when Outlander book one ended with Jamie and Claire in France setting out to try desperately to stop the advance of Bonnie Prince Harlie Nd the eventual battle he will lead his dates troops to at Culloden. sweeping through the court of King Louis of France and the Palace of Versailles. It sweeps from France back to the shores of Scotland as we follow Jamie and Claire as they desperately try to thwart the advices of Charles army.
This was a wonderful novel, taking place initially in a very different place setting to that of book one we get to see James and Claire as they mingle in the upper echelons of Paris society, but that doesn't mean it is filled with any less danger or superstition than the Scottish Highlands.
Many of the amazing characters from the first book feature again and perhaps I may be alone in letting out a little whoop of joy when characters such as Dougal and Collum Mackenzie made their appearances, so engaging were they. Also returning in this book is the villain Jack Randall, although maybe I am alone in beginning to find something a little endearing about the man.
gabaldon has done a quite wonderful thing, she has created a book based on the concept of time travel and made it into a sweeping and wonderful love story. I was utterly engaged with this book immediately and found it really nice to read about the battles which took place right next to where I myself live in Falkirk. Reading about the stationing of English troops in Callendar House, our closest sizeable historic manor and park.
I am most likely not the only person who would rather love the prospect of finding themselves wishing for the opportunity to escape through a circle of standing stones into the arms of a hunky, sexy Scottish red head dressed in full highland dress. I live in Scotland and even I'd go for that, a visit to find out if Craig Na Dun exists is high on my agenda.
Of course this book again ended on a cliffhanger just trying desperately to draw us into the next book. I am so very tempted to dive straight in but am going to force myself to take a break for fear that any more heroics from one Mr Fraser may drive me to Inverness post haste in search of those standing stones.
While not as exciting as the first book (I don't care for France or French history, both of which is favoured heavily in this narrative), it was quite a page-turner and answered more than a few questions raised by the first novel in the series. I quite liked the shocking ending. The only main problems I had with this book is the weird Geillis Duncan sub-plot (Claire seems really obsessed by her and her death, though I can't imagine it's important except that it proved to Brianna that Claire was telling the truth?) that featured in the last part of the book, and Claire seemed a bit dull throughout the book - there were more than a few times I wanted to throw the book across the room because of something Claire said or did that was completely idiotic. Overall, a fun ride and I'll definitely be continuing on in the series, though it was hit or miss for a good chunk in the middle. Slug your way through that and the battle narrative back in Scotland for the last few parts of the book will key up your interest again.
Still a sucker for romantic historic fiction, and am loving the Outlander series on Starz!
I know I said I was going to wait a while before starting the sequels to “Outlander”, but I lied. I have to admit, I was curious how this series was going to last, because from the start, this book takes place 20 years after the last one ended — and Claire is back in her own time. So I was super worried that the storyline with her hot Scottish husband was over, but I really shouldn't have worried. It was still a good book, though it kind of messed with the plot of the original and I didn't like that. Also, this book was over 700 pages, so now I really feel like I need a break. I think I would still like to continue the series, but I don't feel quite as compelled to jump right into the next one, since I figured out how this one ended fairly early on. I had time to make my peace with it. :)