A Scatter of Light

It was nice to read this after reading a short run of somewhat didactic middle grade books. Like wow the complexity! The messiness! The characters fucking up and not having clear-cut paths forward! chef's kissthat said, did I like it as much as I liked [b:Last Night at the Telegraph Club 35224992 Last Night at the Telegraph Club Malinda Lo https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1593457992l/35224992.SY75.jpg 56568979]? No but that was a top tier perhaps career best book. This one was still very good. (Also it's billed as a “companion” to Telegraph Club but really it's just a tiny cameo, but still, good to see them again!!) also I'm marking it historical fiction because it's specifically set in 2013, which is not that long ago but also distinct defined era shrug

I enjoyed this coming of age story a lot. On some ways, I feel like it suffers in comparison to Last Night at the Telegraph Club but I think that is because it's SO good almost anything would feel like a let down.

A few days later and pieces of this novel are still sticking with me. There were many loose ends not tied up ??? but I think that???s a good thing, because not everything can be neatly squared away in real life either. We never find out whether Aria reconnects with Steph, whether she connects with any particular queer label, and I think that???s a good thing. So much of Aria???s experiences are just presented to us without a lens or agenda toward a certain interpretation. I keep coming back to think about ways that ???illusion??? can apply to different aspects of the book, characters, plot, and finding more every time I return to the idea. The relationships between characters are complex, if sometimes not as fleshed out as they could be. I wanted this book to be longer, to learn more about the deeply interesting people who populate Aria???s life, but perhaps part of the coming-of-age genre is the solipsism: the focus on the narrator. Or: the illusion of the self as center of the world.

Definitely a coming-of-age book: The summer where Aria is literally caught between two selves. It recalled a lot of that exciting uncertainty for me. I loved the Lily and Kath cameos, too, even though they felt a little forced at times.

I did expect a little more engagement with questions of class and privilege, given that the book???s synopsis discussed Aria???s experience befriending ???a community of working-class queer folks???. The class discrepancies were touched on, occasionally prodded, but often by characters who weren???t Aria. Aria noted the class differences, but didn???t really engage with them beyond observation. She seemed too busy wrestling with her emerging queerness and her emergence as a nascent artist, as an inheritor of her family???s talents and downfalls, to also engage with the implications of class that separated her from Steph as well. And maybe that???s part of the point: she is no perfect person by any means, and still has growing up to do.

4.5 really.

After really loving Last Night at Telegraph Club, I was anyways interested to read what the author was gonna write next, but I definitely couldn't resist this book at all because it's kinda set in the same universe. And this turned out to be everything and nothing like I thought it would be.

Firstly, I was definitely expecting this to be a romance, just like Telegraph Club, and I think I should clarify right at the beginning that it is not. This is more of a coming of age story, finding out the truths about yourself, and figuring out your future. It's about connections and honesty and dreams and art and so much more. It's a slice of life story about family and friendships, so it moves at a sedate pace, taking us on a dreamy journey. We also get interludes philosophizing about art and artistic expression and music and astronomy and more, and I absolutely devoured it all. But there was something about it that left me a bit unsatisfied and I don't know how to put a finger on it.

Aria is the sole POV that we get to read here but I felt like we were at a remove from her, and I never got to know her properly. She felt things deeply but also seemed completely detached at times, and I wasn't sure how to understand this dichotomy. I also feel like I get to understand my own asexuality better when I'm reading a book like this, where the character is figuring out her own sexuality and I can see how I felt at that age was so different. I could also definitely empathize with her wanting to understand herself better and also trying to live on the edge between her past and her future.

Through Aria, we also get to know the people who influence her. Her artist grandmother Joan becomes a source of inspiration for Aria in this summer before college, making her want to explore her artistic side before going to study for a science major. Her mom and dad also make small appearances though they have very different kind of relationships with Aria. Joan's genderqueer gardener/musician Steph evokes a spark in Aria, completely changing her perspective about what she could be. Their connection is immediate and intense and they had some of the most evocative and bittersweet moments in the story. Through Steph, we also get to meet her other queer friends and see Aria discover the queer community and the solidarity that exists, against the backdrop of the overturning of Prop 8 by the Supreme Court.

I thought this book works great in contrast to Telegraph Club. In that book, every gathering of the people of the queer community was an act of defiance and even acknowledging one's sexuality felt almost impossible - it was amazing to see how much California has changed in the intervening 5-6 decades, the amount of visibility the queer community has, and the heartwarming solidarity that is depicted through the Dyke March and the Queer Music Festival. It shows that things have changed for the better, maybe not everywhere and not for everyone, but they are better.

Overall, this is a beautifully written story that moved with its stunning prose. While I may have liked a bit more depth in character relationships, it works very well as a bittersweet tale of first love, loss, grief, sexual awakening, finding your dreams and holding onto them. It will transport you to its tranquil California setting and make you wanna get lost in it. I definitely feel like I wanna visit this side of SFO - who knows when that'll happen - but hopefully I'll get to read Malinda Lo's next before that.