Overwritten in the best possible way.

Incredibly unlike any alt-history I've read before, and not in a good way.

This was 75 percent exactly the book I thought it was going to be and then 25 percent something much more affecting that I was totally unprepared for. So different than the Old Man's War books but in a way that turned out great.

Occasionally this book bogs down in just a little too much detail about an operation or patrol. But the rest of the time it's among the best writing on war and morality I've ever read.

Really fun. The sensibility is very Heinlein but the writing is better than that.

Really informative with lots of interesting reporting from places around the world, but went on far too long.

Really enjoyed the premise and plot, but some occasionally yikes writing.

This book builds a great world and a great thriller plot and then mostly fills it with terrible writing. But still a fun read.

I can't believe he took the time to write this and not an actual book.

Stunningly written and fascinating, as with all his other books

Starts off stronger than it ends; the more abstract the empire gets, the less revelatory it is. But at least half of this book has some stunning thing on every page that we all should have learned in middle school.

A lot more scattered than most other Michael Lewis books, but it's worth reading to get a sense of just how colossally some critical functions are being fucked up by the Trump administration.

Uneven, as you'd probably expect of a collection of articles. One or two that are truly incredible, though.

Whatever small informational value there is in this book is not even close to worth slogging through the writing.

Just incredibly well-written and devastating to read. The perfect introduction to just how brutal and nakedly treasonous Reconstruction was, should be required school reading.

Good but uneven. Was hoping it would end up like a short primer on the war. It's not quite that, but there are a few really good essays in here.

Information literally every American should know and absorb, but a dense read even for a short book. I'm kind of hoping someone uses this as the basis for a bigger history book.

This may be a little real for the current moment.

Soul crushing and incredible.

Read this and then make everyone you know read it and then read it again.