Evelyn

Beautiful, beautiful children's book. I remember crying about this thinking about my own mom as a kid. I really recommend it to little ones. 

I love the first arc as much as I love the 3rd arc, they're full of lovable characters and stories for me. I think the most I remember from this book in specific is Graystripe, and it's nice to have some focus on him although as a romance-adverse kid I was put off by his storyline, now I can appreciate it.

Terrifying 

Not my favorite but I can't really put my finger on why. Maybe I would've liked more worldbuilding. 

I was obsessed with Hollyleaf and her potential as a character. 

Fun, fast read. 

Very enjoyable book.

Affected me a lot as a kid.

This was boring and a lot of the things that happened in this book where pointless because the thing that went down with Firestar, Sandstorm and Spottedleaf didn't fix the problem and Treeclan is not important or shows up in any of the books I read and like I said it was boring.

Probably the craziest book I've ever read. The amount of things that happen are insane. Also, it made me cry at the end. sometimes the narration put me off, it was very reference humor and also very judgy and sort of hateful. But I guess it was trying to come off as teenage-kid ish.

DNF'd but interested me. 

I think this is one of the nicest super editions. I love Tallstar.

DNF'd

Lovely book, I remember this book fondly reading it as a kid in 4th grade. It was my favorite teacher, and I loved it. It was dark, hopeful, but it had a lot of symbolism that she kept us interested in.

This arc was not my favorite, maybe a bit above the 2nd arc but it's still warrior cats and they have a way of making things interesting, or not depending on the book.

A nice book! Read this as a child

Kate DiCamillo has a way of making things fun to read while every word you read can be depressing, hopeful or both at once. I'm always happy reading her books. And although this book depressed me at turns, having someone like my teachers who pointed out every great thing about the writing is great. 

Loved this book as a kid, and love it now. There's nothing better than reading books about animal companions, and how more often than not it's better to let nature run its course.

I was not very into the premise.

This was a great book. I'm still don't have an idea if it's my favorite book in the series overall.
The characters were great and the Erins did a great job at hiding the fact that Jayfeather is blind. Overall, this is a great opening to the even more fantastic series, “The Power of Three”

This series was not my favorite, but it's still warrior cats and I'm obsessed with it, so it was good enough. 

I enjoyed it very much.

These last two first arc books really kept me on the edge of my seat as a kid. Loved it so much, nothing will replace the memories of reading these books.

Fun childrens book for animal obsessed kids. 

Enjoyable classic.