Evelyn

I love the first arc as much as I love the 3rd arc, they're full of lovable characters and stories for me. I think the most I remember from this book in specific is Graystripe, and it's nice to have some focus on him although as a romance-adverse kid I was put off by his storyline, now I can appreciate it.

Beautiful, beautiful children's book. I remember crying about this thinking about my own mom as a kid. I really recommend it to little ones. 

Terrifying 

Not my favorite but I can't really put my finger on why. Maybe I would've liked more worldbuilding. 

As a kid, there was nothing better than reading Warrior Cats, so when I got my hands on a guide I was really excited, it's good for a warriors fan of course, but the characters of Warrior cats can be so far and between that adding more past cats to the roster can be a bit uninteresting, if this included cats in the main series and how they dealt with the warrior code or even how they tell the legends of the clans, I think I would find it even more interesting.