Strangely addictive, and me being an atheist to boot. There is addictiveness in the ongoing cycle of emotional highs and lows, and the soothing wisdom of the old character Geesje. Cleverly interwoven storylines. It’s christian propaganda, it’s about an astoundingly Good set of christian people - in short it’s a soorhing fairytale.
Although I liked Brooklyn and Long Island better, still I think this a very good book. A quiet book, about rebuilding a life after a husband died. In a family where not everyone talks enough. I still can’t explain why, but I love Toibin’s very simple and sometimes barren style. And I can’t stop reading, even when little happens, like in this wisow’s life.
Just discovered Toibin. Fascinating. God knows why. The writing is unadorned. It is all about personal decisions all the time. Very strong plots that keep you reading. This book particularly starts with a stunning dilemma.
I like how Brooklyn and this book are mirror images. I like the characters. And how life is a mess.
Howcome I missed this book when it came out? What absolute joy! So witty and charming, such interesting characters, and the feminist theme so lovingly wrapped in story. Elizabeth is a bit of an anachronism, although we have known women who put their career/intellectual pursuits first in the 1950s. The Elizabeth-Mad-Harriet combo is also really good. They all learn from each other - well except daughter Mad, who is perfect from birth ;-)
Its beginning is the best. Of course it loses some steam later on. Regardless, I could not put it down, needing to know its ending. Needing to know how these nice people will fare.
A wonderful fairy tale, with nerdism or autism thrown in but in a good way. Elizabeth turns out to have been right all along - and is helped by mainly women.
As a former rower, that theme was also hilarious.