G

Great start, excellent build up. Drops the ball on what's supposed to be the crescendo: Atlantis itself just to setup the plot twist. The twist itself is fun, but I still felt robbed somewhat.

Excellent book! The codas at the end are too long though.

Overall a good book. The imperial era is where it shines. The clone wars era, especially Padme's parts feel shoehorned into fitting this into the new canon. My only other dislike was they only use Vader's breathing once or twice. I get that it keeps the audiobook clean, but would've added immersion.

Good, but not as good as Krampus

hated part 1, but it sets up part 2