Why She Left

Solid Family Drama With Some Mystery. Reading through the Goodreads reviews (as I do before writing my own), a lot of the more negative reviews (anything less than 4* is considered by Goodreads/ Amazon to be negative, fwiw) tended to center around complaints that this book wasn't a suspense/ thriller. And yet looking around through the description and other materials available, I find no claims from the publisher that this is a suspense or a thriller. The closest claim is that it is a “suspenseful family drama”, which is 100% accurate. There was an event years ago that caused one daughter to flee, and there are a few different events in the present day that build a decent amount of suspense (for a family drama, which is truly what this is, anyway). Yes, the years-ago event becomes rather obvious rather quickly - hopefully Mercer intended that. But there are many more wrinkles here that aren't so obvious, and even my usually fairly perceptive reading didn't actually catch some of the bigger reveals until they were actually revealed. Indeed, arguably the one true weakness here I can think of isn't actually one anyone else has cited - it is never truly established just how bad the situation the returning daughter is fleeing from now actually was. Still, for what this tale actually is, and seems to actually be being marketed as, this is actually a fairly solid story that will trigger some in a variety of ways but which is a truly solid story for most everyone else. Very much recommended.