We Are The Dead
Ratings31
Average rating3.9
3.5. It's a great start but not perfect. I think the 3rd act is pretty great overall and we do get some nice and surprising character developments.
I think this might actually be the first time I enjoyed a grimdark story. The grimness of it in this actually feels earned and not just miserable for the sake of doing so or to be edgy. At times it gets very dark, like... I was in shock they went there haha.
Characters were great, in theory, as in the writing they kind of beat you over the head with their treats. Tinnstra is a coward and we have to hear that multiple times in all of her chapters. Dren is very angry. The villain is... well, very villain-y. It's very not subtle as you know those are what their character developments throughout the book are going to be about. It wasn't bad, and especially in the later chapters it's not an issue, but especially at the start it is something you might roll your eyes at :D I'm at least surprised how much development all characters were able to go through in just eight days and it not feeling too forced.
Writing wise it was very easy to read. It's not overly flowery, but also not overly simplistic.
Kinda curious about the sequels!
A difficult book to rate. There are many fundamental flaws with this one - the characters are unlikable, the prose is somewhat naïve and clunky, and there is a lot of telling going on. The first half the book was a real struggle with this. The book follows multiple POVs, but the dominant one is probably Tynnstra. The idea of a coward as lead character in this style of fantasy (which btw is at grimdarkest end of grimdark) is a nice idea, but the constant statements that she is a coward without really developing the whats and the whys of it just ends up deeply annoying. Cowards can be written well (Flashman and Rincewind are two examples that come to mind) and it is possible to write them in ways where it is possible to relate and understand their cowardice. Tynnstra is just a coward, with no ulterior motives explored at all.
The one dimensionality of the other characters is also there. The villains are evil for no apparent reason except to be evil. The noble soldiers are also not really explored in their motivations. The shallowness of the characters is offset dramatically against the viciousness of the world they live in. A conquered country with an invading force that cares little for their new subjects is a vivid setting that really is brutal.
The saving grace for the novel is its second half. Here the pace picks up, the action picks up, the characters start to show some better development and suddenly the story becomes alive. The prose is still clunky at times but the tension and the stakes become more exciting, the telling is reduced and the whole thing is much more readable.
This is very grim and very dark. There are plenty of triggers in the text. It is also not the best prose. But there is enough excitement to help provide some good entertainment.
When you think of a rollercoaster it's fast, frenetic and a little bit scary, which is what you'll get from We Are the Dead without having to queue for two hours first. WATD is the debut novel from Mike Shackle in his grimdark series The Last War, following its characters through the dark and deadly life in an occupied territory as they try to resist the enemy and take back their country, Jia. The book's main storyline takes place over a span of eight days, which adds to the fast-paced nature of it, and follows five main points of view: Tinnstra, Jax, Dren, Yas and Darus.
Tinnstra is a young woman consumed by fear and a desperate desire to live but not necessarily the courage to fight for it until she gets caught up in an escape attempt that could give all of Jia hope for a future of freedom. While the blurb on the reverse of the book only specifically mentions Tinnstra, she is not the sole focus of the story; nevertheless her arc presents a refreshingly honest take on violence and war. After all, if you look within yourself, would you really have the courage to fight an unwinnable war knowing it would cause your certain death? Or, would you be petrified and forced to run and hide?
Dren's story - aside from Tinnstra's - shows some of the most growth. From a reckless, rebellious teenager, hellbent on killing the enemy no matter the cost, to a young man who can see the bigger picture and the part he has to play in it. The character development across the board is excellent and Dren's is possibly my favourite.
There is plenty of dark, grim and gritty content here too. Everyone suffers some sort of familial loss, even if in one case it's a twistedly happy affair. There is death on a mass scale, betrayal, failure, torture and the ever-present looming darkness of fear. This is still a tale of rebellion and resistance despite all the odds going against our Jian friends and a brilliant read that is more than it seems.
> Some TW/CW for the book: suicidal ideation, sexual assault, mentions of and attempted r*pe, torture <
We are the Dead - by Mike Shackle
If I could liken a book to a song, then I would liken ???We are the Dead??? to ???Bleed??? by Messhuggah. Hard, uncompromising and totally bloody brilliant. This is the first book in Mike Shackle???s ???The Last War??? Trilogy and I don???t know what to say. This book is something else.
The usual path for a fantasy book is to culminate in that final climactic battle. However, Mike Shackle takes a totally different view and thinks it is a good idea to start the book with the ultimate battle, and in this world the Evil Empire wins. They don???t just win, but they pulverise the good guys and then rout the rest of the country.
Well, that took me by surprise, I must say! Where on earth do we go from there? Urm, I???m not sure. It???s a good job that Mike Shackle does.
We are the Dead is a book about oppression, rebellion and survival. It???s about how normal people survive in extreme circumstances and the choices they make when placed in an impossible situation.
I really enjoyed this book. It is a gripping narrative that has you guessing what on earth is going to happen next.
I have got to say that Mike Shackle has done something different with We are the Dead and I loved every minute of the ride that he took me on.From beginning to end, this book never lets up.
The book starts with a student, Tinnstra on the verge of completing suicide due to her disgracing herself in some way for an unknown misdemeanour. We learn that she is at military school in the country of Jia, training to be an elite soldier called The Shulka, just like her father.
We then cut to the north of the country, where the army of Shulka are prepared to meet the Egril, an undisciplined, barbarian army. As we learn, the country of Jia was the home of magic and the Jians overcame the Egril at some point in the past. However, the magic disappeared long ago and now the Shulka, a set of elite warriors, protect the country from invasion..
What happens next, nobody is prepared for. Jax, the leader of the Shulka, believes that this is going to be an easy battle. However, the best laid plans and all that. Subsequently,the Jians learn the Egril are not what they seem. They are a highly organised machine that have magic, monsters and weapons that can destroy the Shulka with no chance of fighting back..
Believe it or not, that is the first forty pages, the first forty pages. Whaaat?
What comes next is a tale of oppression and fear. All the heroes of the land of Jia have been decimated and there is no one left to fight for the people. The Egril are cruel and rule with a hand of terror.
The Egril have got to be the best set of fantasy villains that I have read. They are truly horrible and Mike Shackle writes so well that the feeling of oppression is palpable. They dehumanise the people that they rule and treat them worse than animals. They have no qualms about killing anyone for the slightest thing and regularly do. As you read the book you can almost smell the fear that the inhabitants of Jia live with every day.The Egril are brutal and use this brutality with great abandon.
As we move through the story we are introduced to the characters. Now don???t be expecting heroic magic and sword wielding heroes that will ride in on a white charger and save everyone, coz it ain???t gunna happen. In this book, most of the characters are unlikeable or have a fault running through them so wide the sea would be swallowed.
We meet Tinnstra in the first instance as she is preparing to end her life. And it is at that point we realise that Tinnstra is so consumed with fear that she is willing to withdraw from everything, even life. We have Dren, a bombastic teenager who is willing to send anyone to their deaths without a thought. Dren has no care, and we see this early on when he coerces a young mother to be a suicide bomber and kill a load of people that he believes are collaborators with the enemy. He has no regard for life at all.
There are other characters, like Jax, the leader of the Hanran, who was broken in the first assault by the Egril and has arm cut off, and then there is Yas, a single mother whose husband was killed horrifically by the Egril, leaving her to bring their child into the world.
Throughout the book. The characters develop in many ways and experience life changing events. They all go on their journey and all change in ways they cannot imagine. I found this to be a strength to the narrative in that whilst you may not like the characters initially, your relationship with each individual character changes throughout the book.
The pacing of the narrative is supersonic. Mike Shackle writes with a clipped prose that does not waste a word. HIs descriptive prowess is brilliant. Sometimes a little too brilliant, particularly when we get to a scene with Jax and Darus (an Egril Chosen who has been imbued with power, and the fifth pov in the book). This made me squirm, really squirm as the violence that Darus meters out on Jax is gut wrenching.
The other thing is that Mike Shackle writes action scenes that are so cinematic it is like having a TV in your head.He is totally unflinching in describing the violence of the situation, describing each sword stroke and the damage that results. At times, it reminded me of something from a Wachowski brothers film.
He does not fluff the brutality that the oppressors meter out to the citizens of Jia. Nor does he make any judgements on the lengths the characters will go to, to get their freedom. And this is something that struck me throughout the story. Our ???so called??? heroes do some nasty stuff, and I mean the types of things that a war crimes committee would have a field day with. However, the character???s are not held to account for the actions that they take and you understand the decisions that they make.
Despite it being a war torn country, Mike Shackle builds a rich world. Whenever the book moves to the different cities in the country of Jia you get a distinct difference in the environments that the characters inhabit. Shackle describes a world with a rich history, giving you all the background you need to picture the environment and the people that inhabit it.
As I have said before, Mike Shackle???s books have placed themselves firmly in my all time fantasy favorites and this series deserves all the praise that it gets.