Waking Up: A Guide to Spirituality Without Religion

A bit too meandering in getting to its point

I actually disliked the majority of this book. But by the final chapter and conclusion, I began to see some of Sam's points come into focus. This is a challenging book to read, and one I do not recommend unless you have a great interest in the mind and science.

It was an interesting read, and then at chapter 5 it kind of took a big hit when the author spent a very long time talking about this guy he holds a grudge against... It felt very petty and I was glad the end of the book was this close, else I may not have finished it.

(Note that I agree with his opinion, I'm just not interested in hearing about their quarrels for too long)

Sam Harris covers a lot of ground in this book. At times, I was nodding along; at others, I was absorbing new ideas; and a few times, I was completely lost.

I enjoyed the thesis - that being aware of our present and taking steps to be better at being aware of our present is objectively good for us. Most of the book seems to strongly support this thesis. This is especially true of the beginning of the book and parts where Sam discusses research.

I disagree with what appears to be an antagonism towards religion. While I see the many harms from dogma, I also know and see people who benefit themselves and those around them by their religious faith. I do not see religious faith as antithetical to good life. Not a religious person myself, I am not making this claim of my view from a defensive posture.

While I did not altogether follow the discussion of different spiritual teachers and their successes and failures, I did enjoy the very personal aspect that Sam brings to those narratives - having met and seen some of the people, he has a different perspective than I could get elsewhere. On that same topic, I appreciated his cautionary words about how difficult it is to identify a real guru/teacher on spiritual matters. In addition to the caution, he gives specific examples of things that are probably red flags.

Recommended to me when I asked for books about starting meditation that don't have a religious angle. Going to assume the person who recommended this hasn't actually read it. Maybe two minutes was spent on actual instructions on how to meditate. That's not the reason for the two-star rating, but I'm trying not to do negative reviews in general here, so I'll end it there. This book wasn't for me.If anyone's looking for a book on secular meditation, I found [b:Meditation for Fidgety Skeptics: A 10% Happier How-To Book 34962306 Meditation for Fidgety Skeptics A 10% Happier How-To Book Dan Harris https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1509153842l/34962306.SY75.jpg 56237226] to be more helpful, personally.

Disappointed. I am an atheist interested in the power of mindfulness and the whole world of so-called spirituality, so naturally, I am the ideal audience that Sam Harris is looking for. But it disappointed in almost every domain that I had expectations in. Using deep-sounding difficult words and wrapping them in an almost mythical aura of “Consciousness”, this one was a huge letdown. The irony is that I've been following his mindfulness meditation course and it's been the opposite experience there - in fact, his meditation course itself was what motivated me to pick up this book.

Save yourself the trouble of reading on why to meditate and instead dive into doing the practice itself and judge for yourself.

For me, this is one of those books that change your view of the world and offer additional tools to experience existence in a richer and more contemplative way.

Sam Harris is a rationalist that constantly uses his understanding of the scientific method to derive new meaning and understanding. This is the key aspect that drew me to his ideas from the very beginning of the book. Consider this: we are talking about spirituality here, and in the way Sam frames it, science is not a contradiction but a complement.

The premise of the book is that consciousness and its contents is all there is. From this premise he proceeds to ask, given that all of our experience of life is about the subjective experience of consciousness and the variety of contents that can be drawn upon it, why not to explore them directly? - Through meditation and a contemplative framework.

This book is for those who want to explore the ideas behind meditation and are curious about what to make of it. Sam is a truth seeker, honestly looking for a deeper understanding of life, he is a good guide. Totally recommend this book and also the companion app, WakingUp.

Many remarkable sections, a few too dense for me. Surprisingly, a good amount of information and perspectives that were new to me. Worthwhile.

meditation is good. there. now you don't have to read the book.

Recently, I had a brief online exchange with a former student who questioned by use of the word “spiritual” outside of a religious context. Certainly, many people do refer to religious experiences when they use the term, but increasingly the term has come to mean other forms of inward exploration, including efforts to seek an understanding of one's position in the universe–relationships with the environment and with others...
Review of Waking Up