Thrawn: Treason

Best of the series. No Anakin and Padme to distract from Thrawn's character, plenty of battle action, Vanto, the Chiss. Great addition to Thrawn's story

3.5.

This book is alright. It's better than Alliances but way worse than the first book in the series. Thrawn essentially has to share his story here with Eli Vanto. Vanto is a great character and I'm happy to see him return but his lack of interaction with Thrawn is disappointing. Vanto's relationship with the Chiss borders on interesting but I feel like the Chiss are being hyped up with very little tangible information given about them. There's a lot of setup but little pay off.

The overall plot of Thrawn being played by Tarkin and Krennic is interesting and shows how intelligent Thrawn is through his utter dedication to detail and data. However Ronan is a terrible character and mostly acts as the audience who constantly challenges Thrawn for no reason beyond ‘that's not what I would do!”

The space battles are fine but the stakes are so low I feel it doesn't really matter. I don't really care about Chiss girls being enslaved so why should I care about these minor skirmishes? Thrawn versus Savit was a cool battle but ultimately it was inevitable nobody was going to die so the stakes were low and inconsequential.

Zahn wrote a story here that doesn't really matter. So the book as a whole while decently written is irrelevant.

3,5☆
Not my favorite out of the trilogy, but still a very fun Star Wars novel featuring everyone's favorite blue dude! A nice mystery, some cool space battles, and loads of Chiss rep!

Thrawn, no wonder your race was called Chiss, whenever I read any book with Thrawn in it, you have to be ready to analyze everything, or read every paragraph or sentence, because Thrawn seems to derive his ideas from them, like playing chess, no wonder my head aches after each and every Thrawn novel, there is this nagging feeling that you are missing something!!!

A big salute to Mr. Zahn, who brought Thrawn, nurtured, weaned and finally allowed him to walk on his own, I would to see him create a truly chaotic character!!!

Thrawn: Treason another tugging of ideas between the faction of Director Krennik and Grand Moff Tarkin, both who only wish to serve the Empire, what if the Empire was ruled not through fear and backstabbing, would it have been better??? The backstory regarding the Death Star project was truly informative but at the same time anti-climactic, as someone who watched the first trilogy and just read this novel, I kept thinking “so that is how it was brought about, but ultimately it failed”, I am still hoping Disney uses the Star Wars novel canon, because THERE ARE A LOT OF REALLY, REALLY GOOD IDEAS!!!!

This next trilogy is a good one, I am hoping for some new lore, great characters to add, most of all Thrawn with his own race!!! Finally our Admiral has come back home!!! Chiss Ascendancy here we GO!!!!

Who is this book for?
- I am a Star Wars fan who is determined to devour every Star Wars story one can get their hands on, regardless of how good or bad it is. Especially after watching The Mandalorian and having the love of Star Wars rekindled to a brighly burning blaze.
- I am scouring the internet trying to find where to submit their application to the Grand Admiral Thrawn Academy. I think Timothy Zahn has brought a classic view of Thrawn to this novel.
- I am a person who enjoys a space opera with a space Sherlock Holmes. A Sherlock Holmes with blue skin and red eyes from another planet.

Who is this book not for?
- I hate Star Wars. It's a waste of time and I mock everyone who spends anytime watching, reading, or thinking about it. In fact, I hate it so much, I read Star Wars novel reviews to help me remember how much I hate Star Wars.
- I loved the Star Wars I saw when I was a kid and all the others are garbage that should be wiped from the face of the earth. In fact, if you have a few hours, I have worked through what Star Wars should be. Actually, maybe this book is for me, so I can add to my list of where new Star Wars has ruined my childhood fantasy and not given me what I wanted over the years.
- I think space is a great place, I just prefer to stay here on Earth.

This is the Thrawn book I was looking for.

Thrawn is back in his element of grand master chess player in the Imperial fleet. Set in the era of Rogue One, we see the bias against Thrawn in the Empire as a non-human. I thought Zahn was clever in building Zahn's story in such a way that continues his legacy during the time of the original trilogy by creating a narrative as to why we would never meet him in movie episodes IV-VI. It is a really big universe, after all. I find it refreshing that we aren't bumping into the same handful of characters in every corner of the universe.

I borrowed the audiobook read by Marc Thompson. Thompson does an amazing job reading these novels, bringing the characters to life with his impersonations and accents, which is a known factor after listening to him read a number of SW novels.

4 stars, because Ronan would have given only 1. @#$& you Ronan.

3 stars, Metaphorosis Reviews

Summary
Admiral Thrawn of the Empire finds his Tie Defender budget challenged by a rival Admiral building a massive weapon. For reasons of his own, he accepts an unlikely bet that he can solve the rivals long-standing problem with a space-pest infestation, and discovers far more than minor depradations.

Review
I've never ready a Timothy Zahn book before, though I've had plenty of opportunity. The plots have just never attracted me.

I've only read one Star Wars book before: Splinter of the Mind's Eye, by Alan Dean Foster – possibly the first non-film Star Wars book. It was mildly interesting, but didn't sell me on Star Wars in book form.

Reading this book addresses both issues. Unfortunately, it doesn't really lead to any change in results. The book is mildly interesting, but didn't sell me either on Zahn or Star Wars. Granted, this is just one book in a sub-series of a larger series built on a series of films. I've seen the major films, but otherwise, there's a whole lot I don't know.

The characters, and particularly Thrawn himself, are interesting, though Thrawn is a bit of a stock character – bright, cold, cerebral, a little magical. The plot, though, seemed to me to have pretty substantial holes in it in all sorts of ways. I can't be sure, but it didn't seem to me that they were forced by the series canon, or at least by the George Lucas elements that I know. Beyond that, it just all seems very cinematic, and not in a good way, but in a ‘this is written to be filmed' way.

Overall, competent and likely interesting to fans of Admiral Thrawn, but not likely to attract converts.

I received this book for free in exchange for an honest review.

A return to form! My second favorite of this trilogy, probably. And I just really like Eli Vanto.

Thrawn remains an interesting character, but it still remains to be seen how interested I'm going to be for his other upcoming trilogy. He does need interesting side characters for it to work, otherwise it's just getting stale.

This one was, aside from Rebels, also very intertwined with Rogue One and the Death Start project. And therefore also featured a lot of inner Empire and their politics which I find fun to read about.

Much like the previous Thrawn novel, this one never really hooked me in any meaningful way. The first book in the trilogy chronicled Thrawn's rise up the ranks in the Empire and that narrative momentum was stalled in the second and third books. Though, I was happy to have Thrawn and Eli Vanto back together matching wits and seeing the Chiss Ascendency in action gives me hope for the prequel trilogy that is coming in 2020. Either way, I'm glad to have read this series, even if I was let down by the final two books. Thrawn is a great character and I'd be interested in seeing more of him, either in Star Wars Rebels or in Zahn's non-canonical Star Wars books.

See this review and others at The Speculative Shelf.

Executive Summary: I enjoyed this far more than the last book, but probably not quite as much as the first one.

Audiobook: Another fantastic audio book as always. Marc Thompson is a one man Star Wars universe and this is one of the few books where I don't mind music or sound effects.

Full Review
I don't do a lot of Star Wars books and before listening to the original Thrawn trilogy, I wasn't particularly interested in reading any to begin with. Thrawn is an intriguing character. In most cases he's been a villain but in this series it's more ambiguous.

He's still working for the Empire, but as he's fighting the rebels it's far easier to like and cheer for him and his crew. I'm not really sure how many Thrawn books this series is supposed to be, but this didn't really feel like an ending. Maybe that's because his story picks up in Star Wars Rebels, but I'm not sure this left off where that starts either.

Instead it both continues on the series and mostly feels like a stand alone story. We get more details on the Chiss Ascendancy, and get some background on well known Star Wars events.

Overall I found this an enjoyable story and I'd happily read another Thrawn book, but it adds little to the movies or TV. Like most of the books I've read it offers some back story to things you see on screen, but they are never going to put critical details that would leave those who don't read the books in the dark.

Thrawn is very interesting. Unfortunately, it seems hard to place him in a story where he's challenged or forced to develop. Instead, everyone around him is a bit of an idiot or an eventual follower who comes to appreciate his deductive genius. It gets boring, especially the third time around.

There is a moment early in the book, Thrawn's Imperials encountering the Chiss, when it looks like Zahn is setting up a genuinely engaging conflict. Instead, both sides are just following the same forgettable third-party threat.

It's a waste. This could easily have setup up a true crucible for Thrawn by placing him opposite a Chiss threat to the Death Star. A plot actually worthy of the book's title. Surprisingly little of note happens despite this being the third novel attempting to develop Thrawn in the new EU. What's weird is that Zahn is capable of a more engaging plot. Perhaps this area of canon is still too constrained by new movies and TV to allow for a more meaningful story?