The Women's War

I voluntarily read and reviewed an ARC of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

DNF @ 5%

This book and I totally didn't click. The way things were going, I thought it was going to be too heavy handed with it's feminism themes and whenever this seems to happen, I tend not to agree with how it is done.

I'm not a fan of how it is written either as everything felt so drawn out. I prefer a bit more speed to my books. 5% in and I noticed I was skimming already, which wasn't a good sign.

It is an interesting concept though and people who like more details and explanations, might enjoy this one.

I got this as an ARC ages ago and decided to give it a read in my quest to actually read the books on my shelves. I enjoyed the political intrigue and magic system, but there was something in the writing that just didn't connect with me, and the ending brought it from a book I mostly enjoyed to a book that just annoyed me. First off, if I'm going to invest in over 500 pages of a book, even if it's part of a trilogy, I prefer it to be a complete story in itself which this most definitely is not. It's more of a really lengthy prologue. Secondly, vague it ends with the kind of random character death popularized by GoT that now feels more narratively unfulfilling and stupid than shocking or intriguing.

The Women's War is set in a time when a woman's only importance is to produce an heir. Men are the magic users. Men have all the power.

Three women decide to change that. Even if means their deaths.

I loved this book. I went back and forth between 4 and 5 stars, but even if I'm in the minority, I felt it deserved the 5. A fantasy where the women rise up and take a stand? I'm in! I love political intrigue in fantasy, and this book has plenty. I thought the magic system was unique and interesting. And I loved the characters! Quite a few trigger warnings, but it makes their fight even more important.

I am excited to read more in this series.

I received a copy from Net Galley. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

When I first read the premise of this book, I was blown away and I was so sure I was gonna fall in love with it. And when I actually got approved for the ARC, my joy had no bounds. However, I'm quite unsure about how the experience turned out to be. So, let me share my thoughts.

I definitely went into this book expecting a very fiery feminist fantasy world where the women are finally ready to take down the patriarchy, but I got was a very understated version of it - which is not necessarily a bad thing. This is a highly misogynistic world where women have very few rights and there are levels of apathy towards women based on the kingdom where they live. So, when women finally gain the power of conception/fertility due to a devastating spell, it's not a dramatic shift of power. The men are nowhere near ready to give up everything they've grown accustomed to and most of the women still need to outgrow everything that they've been taught since their birth. What we see happening is a group of women who slowly realize the other magical powers they can access now, and how to navigate this new world. This is a very slow process and they rely a lot on other men in their lives to get what they want. While it was wonderful to see a couple of men in this sexist world truly support the women in their quest for power, I think it would have been more effective as a story if the women were more independent thinking - they certainly are very capable. The pacing is also consistently slow throughout, there is more of the day to day lives of the characters and lots of political intrigue, but hardly any action at all. There is also no diversity at all in the book (or the author deliberately leaves the descriptions very vague) and despite many women going through deep trauma due to rape and assault, we never get to explore how they are affected or their stories of survival. While all the characters were quite good, Ellin is the one I felt most fascinated by and I think she has some of the best and important scenes in the book. Jinnel is also such a thoughtful and selfless young woman and I would have liked to see so much more of her.

While this book was not what I really expected, it has a well realized world and magic system that I really liked. I would still recommend this book if you don't mind a slow paced book with more intrigue and no action and which felt more like a setup for the sequel. I enjoyed it enough that I might be interested to know what happens next.