The Trouble with Physics

I got recommendation of this book after i read Cixin Liu's Remembrance of Earth's Past novel series. For people who love the first book, i believe will appreciate this book. It has eerily resemblance with one of the important plot of The Three Body Problem: the progress of fundamental physic is stuck and physicists are in panic.

Absolutely love this book. The author starts with the great problems of fundamental physics and describe the mystery why we can't find a theory that describe them, we basically stuck and there is no revolutionary progress till now.

Then he goes into details, explaining the leading theory, String Theory. He explains the reason why it still can't describe the nature of our reality. Finally, the last part, he explains the plausible explanation of why this phenomena emerged, which he argued it was because of how our science work.

Some part are quite though, especially the second part, when the author explains String Theory in depth. I am sure I miss some core explanations. Will reread again one day to complete my understanding.

This is possibly the best physics book I've ever read. Most physics books acknowledge that there are certain unknowns such as dark matter or certain aspects of string theory, but they all cleverly hide the real, and somewhat desperate, situation with contemporary physics. It's rare to find someone in any field who is willing to say “despite appearances, we don't know really what's up.” Smolin does exactly that. He argues that we are in the slowest period of innovation in physics of at least the last 100 years.

String theory, super-symmetry, superstring theory, M theory and all related theories are far, very far, from being proven, disproven or even potentially provable by any known experiments. The Large Hadron Collider, which could possibly lend some actual evidence for super-string theory, hasn't done it yet, and more importantly, will never be able to take us much closer to knowing if string theory is anything more than elegant math. In fact, we can't conceive of any experiment that would. Yet crazily, despite it's tenuous position as a real scientific theory, string theory remains hugely influential and is often couched in the same language of consensus as other, much better proven theories.

Smolin argues that if we can't make observations that could prove or disprove string theory or, at minimum, come close in either direction, and we've been working on it for over 25 years without any sign of a solution, it might be time to start looking elsewhere. It's tough to do that though since the theory is so entrenched in the elite corridors of academia. In other words, there are huge sociological barriers that must be crossed before physics can begin to be “healed.”

The Trouble With Physics is a rollercoaster. Smolin sets up string theory as a beautiful and elegant theory that seems so easy to accept, then, once you've started to really appreciate it, he systematically tears it down. The book feels honest, insightful and sincere. It has completely changed the way I think and read about not only physics, but any science where there is a consensus that lacks the characteristics of historically successful theories.