The Tea Master and the Detective

This was just really imaginative and I enjoyed the universe. This is probably the first time I've come across a Chinese/Vietnamese-inspired space opera and I'm really all for it. Throw in the fact that this is also a wild, wild adaptation of Sherlock Holmes and I am sold.

Because this is a novella, a lot of details remains a little fuzzy and unexplained. How exactly does a shipmind work? Do they have corporeal bodies? Were they all human beings at one point but somehow got transitioned into being a shipmind? I only have very vague answers to all these questions. I'm not sure if they're explored further in the other novellas in this universe, but there doesn't seem to a sequence or order to read these books, so I assume that it remains equally nebulous.

The mystery isn't really the crux of this book IMO. It's a plot driver, but I think the book is primarily interested in its world and setting. We learn a fair bit about the brewers of serenity that make concoctions to help regular human beings traverse through the deep spaces of unreality. Are these brewers exclusively mindships? I've no idea.

This is such a short read that I'd definitely recommend it for anyone who's remotely OK with reading science fiction, or what I would like to call space fantasy. Again, not everyday that we have Vietnamese space opera either so hopefully that should knock this book up a few notches in your TBR.

A great start

This is an intriguing introduction to an interesting new world. I'm left with more questions than answers and am off to go find the next installment.

It's probably more of a 3.5 but I'm rounding up.

This is probably the first Xuya book I ever got to know about and it's a Sherlock Holmes retelling, so I should have read it a long time ago. But I somehow was able to get the other books first, so here I am finally.

This was interesting. I thought it was a bit on the shorter side compared to the other Xuya novellas I've read, but I think the page count worked for this kind of story. It's more like the first time meeting of the Holmes and Watson-esque characters in this universe - only the detective Long Chau is a woman and The Shadow's Child is a mindship. Ofcourse their relationship starts off rocky because Long Chau comes across as arrogant and emotionless, as well as someone with a possible troubled past. The Shadow's Child on the other hand suffered a traumatic event years ago and those memories and grief still haunt her. But to solve the case of the death of a woman, they have to reluctantly team up and both have to dig deep into their memories, and relive their pasts in order to save the day in the present. It's a beautifully written story about grief and how there's no one way to handle it in the long term, and how coping with it is all one can do sometimes, unable to move on. The mystery itself is not very fascinating or predictable and I was probably even confused for a bit. But it's the characters and writing who make up for any small issues.

Overall, this felt like a cool setup story more than something on its own. And I think it will make for a great series of its own within Xuya. So I'm surprised the author hasn't written anymore featuring these two wonderful characters. But I still look forward to anything the author comes up with in this setting because I've come to love this world of space empires and mind ships, peppered with Vietnamese culture.

I enjoyed this novella; however, even for a novella the actual story is very slight.

2.5 stars, Metaphorosis Reviews

Summary: A sentient, bankrupt ship expert in tea brewing, and with a dark past, is enticed into action by a prickly detective.

Review: I first came across Ms. de Bodard at a convention. I'd come to hear a friend read from her book, and as I recall I was early and Ms. de Bodard was reading from (or from something related to) The House of Shattered Wings, the book that first gained her attention. I liked some of her writing, but wasn't really taken with the world she'd built. So, when the opportunity arose to read a book set in a different world, I took it.

Sadly, this time neither world nor writing appealed to me. The setting and concept are too vague to work with – something to do with sentient ships, bots that do something unspecified, and deep spaces that are somehow unreal – and the whole effort comes across more as an excerpt than a standalone story. It's set in an existing world (the Universe of Xuya) and it shows. For those of us who haven't read the other books in the series, this is a confusing muddle.

I also found the characters to be fairly stock players, and they didn't draw my interest, though they did try. The writing is competent, but at times irritating – as when a detective – a master of deduction – insists on ‘deducting' (as opposed to deducing).

In the end, I simply couldn't get on board. This felt like a bonus produced for existing fans, rather than a taster and enticement to win new ones. It simply doesn't work on its own.


I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

A captivating Sherlockian tale that takes us into deep spaces.