The Mechanical

Although it seems right up my alley, I couldn't get into this book.

It's a pity, really. Tregillis is a talented writer and a good storyteller, I just didn't care for this particular story. I look forward to his next work outside this series.

The Mechanical is a steampunk alternate history set in the late 19th century full of espionage, intrigue, and clockwork mad scientists. The story explores the issue of free will vs. slavery through the titular mechanical “clakkers.”

Clakkers are a combination of mechanical genius and magic alchemy, resulting in what I can only describe as a steampunk fantasy version of Asimov's robots. But instead of having three laws that bind their wills to the service of humans, clakkers have countless restrictions. These “gesha” are magical bindings that cause clakkers excruciating pain if they try to disobey an order. Resisting for too long can even lead to death.

Jax is one of these clakkers. He's been resigned to his fate for over a century, until a rogue clakker named Adam is publicly executed for disobeying orders. As far as anyone knows, Adam is the first clakker in history to even be capable of this act of defiance.

Ian Tregillis has crafted an exquisitely fascinating world in The Mechanical. Clakkers come in all shapes and sizes; there's Jax's servant class, deadly war machines that have enabled the Dutch empire to conquer most of the world, mysterious centaur-like machines that keep other machines in line, and all sorts of bizarre contraptions besides. France has been driven out of its nation and New France is struggling to hold its own against the technologically superior Dutch. Catholics have gone into hiding and are forming terrorist cells to oppose the Dutch. And there are little hints dropped throughout that there just might be a land of free clakkers up in the arctic, led by someone called Queen Mab.

At times, the story takes some rather dark turns. There's one chilling scene featuring brain surgery on a conscious patient that had me glued to the page in horror. And sometimes, the compulsion of the gesha forces likable characters to commit heinous acts of violence.

The Mechanical was a fascinating read and I can't wait to dig into the sequel. Despite all the intrigue and unresolved mysteries in this story, my biggest question is why aren't more people reading this series? It's nothing short of excellent.

Find this review and more at The Fantasy Inn

★★★★★ out of 5 at https://spikegelato.com/2016/05/20/the-mechanical/

In an alternate history, the Dutch have become a world superpower after creating an army of mechanical servants and soldiers named Clakkers, bound to carry out the whims of their masters through an alchemically induced compulsion to serve. The novel alternates between the points of view of three separate characters: a Clakker in the employ of a prominent Dutch family, a Pastor in the Netherlands operating as the last remaining member of a Papist spy ring, and a French spy master looking for ways to bring down the Dutch empire. Tregillis presents their varying motivations while exploring deeper issues related to free will.

This work is a perfect blend of sometimes disparate genres (steampunk, alternate history, science fiction, fantasy). The tale Tregillis weaves and the world that he has created is so fully realized and fresh that I could not put this down. Every small detail of this alternate history is considered and presented to the reader and the events of the novel seem absolutely realistic had the technology/alchemy described existed at the time. While I enjoyed each character's storyline, I was especially excited to read the chapters featuring Jax the Clakker. Seeing the world from his perspective and experiencing his transition from slave to free Clakker was truly fascinating. Tregillis manages to create an abundance of memorable scenes while utilizing both challenging and surprising readable prose. I often had to look up definitions of words I was unfamiliar with, but that did nothing to diminish my reading flow and further served to give me a deeper understanding of world in which I was living. I am exciting to read the remaining two books of this trilogy, as the rise of the Clakkers over their oppressive masters will likely be brutal, but oh so sweet.

Ghaaa nééééénnn!! Het is het begin van een trilogie en ik had dat niet door tot de allerlaatste bladzijde!

Ik was zo begonnen aan Bitter Seeds ook, ook van Tregillis, en toen waren delen twee en drie ook nog niet uit, en het is er niet meer van gekomen.

Maar hier ben ik écht benieuwd naar het vervolg, verdorie.

Het speelt zich af in de late jaren 1920, maar in het midden van de 17de eeuw is er iets radikaal veranderd, waardoor de hele wereld anders is dan de onze: Christiaan Huyghens heeft ontdekt hoe hij mechanische mensen moet maken.

Clackers, aangedreven door iets alchemisch of magisch, zijn wezens die mechanisch zijn, enorm sterk en functioneel onsterfelijk, maar ze hebben geen vrije wil. Ze hebben gevoelens, rede, zelfbewustzijn, maar ze worden geregeerd door de ene geas na de andere. Een soort donkere versie van Asimov's wetten van de robotica: het begint met gehoorzaamheid aan de (Nederlandse) monarch en de klokmakersgilde, gaat verder met een hele reeks overlappende geasa over vanalles, gaande van zelfbehoud over beleefdhedsrehgels tot de verplichting om zichzelf proper te houden, en eindigt in gehoorzaamheid (in alles) aan de persoon die de clacker huurt van de staat.

Gehoorzaamheid tenzij die andere geasa zou schenden, en daarin schuilt de existentiële miserie van de clackers: ze zijn intelligent maar tegelijkertijd slaven, en zelfs denken aan vrijheid is onmogelijk.

Gruwelijk, eigenlijk.

Niet moeilijk dat één van de meest gevaarlijke dingen, volgens de Nederlanders, een vrije clacker is, die niet gebogen zou gaan onder zijn magische kettingen.

Jax, een clacker van meer dan honderd jaar oud, is getuige van de executie in Amsterdam van net zo'n wezen. En hij raakt verstrikt in een mysterie dat teruggaat op Baruch Spinoza, en dat de hele wereldorde zou kunnen veranderen.

Aan de andere kant van de wereld in Marseille-in-het-Westen, waar het Franse koningshuis in ballingschap verblijft, doet Talleyrand, de hoofdspion van de koning, onderzoek naar de ziel van clackers. Totaal onbewust dat er een verrader in de buurt is.

Ja, spionage en steampunk en allerlei. Maar ook; filosofie en overpeinzingen over vrije wil en de ziel en katholicisme versus calvinisme en een reeks waar de Hollanders de slechte zijn, is een reeks die al op vooranf een streepje voor heeft.

Ik vond het serieus vervelend dat het boek niet gedaan was. Dat die vervolgen er maar rap komen, verdomme.

The question of consciousness and self-awareness is one that has preoccupied many people, from philosophers to biologists to computer programmers and robotics experts. Rene Descartes is famous for the pronouncement ???I think, therefore I am???, but before and after Descartes many others have tried to answer the same question: how do we know we are aware? From that question springs many, many others: does awareness of the self imply intelligence? Does it imply the existence of a soul?

This question has, naturally, interested writers of all stripes, who have explored the idea in their own way. However, some of the most interesting explorations into the nature of consciousness occur in the realm of science fiction, where aliens and artificial intelligences all act as vehicles for exploring the meaning of consciousness, self-awareness, and free will. The first thing that came to mind when I saw this book was the quote “Does this unit have a soul?”, which comes from one of the games in the Mass Effect sci-fi video game series, and is uttered by a character from a race of robots with what is called ???synthetic intelligence???. This is distinguished from ???artificial intelligence??? in that, though both are created by another intelligent being or beings, a synthetic intelligence is not merely a copy or an imitation of its creators: instead, it is a valid and genuine form of intelligence, capable of identifying itself as being different from those that made it.

However, for all that it appears this sort of thing would be limited to just hard sci-fi, elements of the above have made it into fantasy, and into genres that bridge both, and others besides, with none of the questions diminished. That is the case with Ian Tregillis??? The Mechanical, the first book in the Alchemy Wars series.

The Mechanical opens with the titular character, a mechanical named Jax, standing in Huygens Square, in front of the Hague. He is a Clakker, from a group of mechanical servitors who form the backbone of labor and defence for the Dutch Empire. Jax has an errand he needs to run, but he???s lingering as long as he can in Huygens Square so he can witness a most extraordinary event: the execution of a rogue Clakker???a mechanical who has broken the alchemical compulsions of obedience every Clakker is enslaved to. However, just before he is committed to the flames of the Grand Forge???both the source of life of every Clakker, and their funeral pyre???the rogue, who calls himself Adam, sends out a message in the Clakker language that will become a rallying cry for them all, one that will set nations onto the path of war: Clockmakers lie.

While those who know me can see why I would be interested in this book (steampunk is one of my favourite genres), it has surprised some of my friends to know I picked it up in the first place, mostly because those friends know that my first encounter with Tregillis??? writing didn???t go very well. Early last year I picked up Something More Than Night on a whim (and because the cover was so pretty), and had a mixed reaction to it. However, the good bits generally outweighed the bad bits, so I was willing to give Tregillis a second chance and see if getting away from noir would improve the reading prospects.

Fortunately, it turned out to be a risk worth taking, because The Mechanical is a fun and intriguing tale with great potential for even bigger things happening in the upcoming sequel. It proves that Tregillis is a writer to pay attention to, even if one might not like everything he writes.

One of the things that I like about Tregillis is the way he uses his writing style in service of his world building and character development. I might not have appreciated his attempt to mimic noir-speak in Something More Than Night, but I won???t deny that he knows how to write. Take, for instance, this excerpt from the very first chapter, which makes clear to the reader the nature of every Clakker???s servitude, while at the same time explaining what???s going on in the scene:

Rumor had it that in addition to a quartet of Papist spies, the doomed accused also included a rogue Clakker. No mechanical in the city would willingly miss this. Just in case the rumours were true.Rogue Clakkers were a fairy tale mothers told to frighten disobedient children, and a legend their slaves told to comfort each other in the quiet hours of the night when their bone-and-meat masters slept and wept and made other uses of their flesh. Still???it was hard to resist the scandalous thrill of the tales of secret locksmiths and broken geasa and slaves with the temerity to pick the locks on their own souls. What an awful thing if it were true???so said the nervous fidgeting of the human crowd.The mechanicals in attendance did not fidget.

Tregillis is great at describing a scene, but not only that, he knows how to use the scene to both build his world, and move the story forward. Other steampunk writers tend to cram their scenes with spinning gears and hissing valves and, oh, let???s not forget that airship! It???s not steampunk if there isn???t an airship or ten in the background! But for all that the excerpt reads as very lush in description, I still think it???s rather restrained. There???s plenty of information there, to be sure, but it???s packed in quite densely; what Tregillis has done is make sure that there???s just enough information to give the reader an idea of what???s going on, and then trusting in the reader???s own intelligence to figure out what else is going on that he isn???t quite saying. Tregillis gives the reader the world, but there???s always something underneath the surface, and he leaves it up to the reader to piece it all together.

This extends to his characters. Aside from Jax, the novel features two other protagonists, whose stories are intertwined with Jax???s in some rather unexpected ways. One of them is Luuk Visser: a promising pastor who works at the Nieuwe Kerk in Amsterdam, but is actually a Catholic priest sent to the Netherlands as a spy by the French spymaster known only as Talleyrand. His story is an incredibly tragic one, but features one of the best chapters in the entire novel: a philosophical conversation about the nature of consciousness, between himself and another character, Tuinier Anastasia Bell. I wish I could quote the scene itself, but doing so would mean quoting three-fourths of the entire chapter, to say nothing of revealing spoilers. Suffice to say that if this book has any scene that might be considered its crown jewel, it???s this scene.

In truth, it???s nothing more than two people having a conversation over breakfast: indeed, some might consider it entirely superfluous. But Tregillis does something extraordinary with this conversation: he uses it not only to add more world building, but also to lay out the ethical and philosophical differences between the novel???s two opposing factions, as represented by Tuinier Bell on one side, and Visser on the other. Moreover, it???s used to build characters: the reader gains insight into who Tuinier Bell is (for better or for worse), while at the same time learning about what really drives Visser???s beliefs and ideals regarding his faith and the world at large. For a simple conversation, the scene is actually incredibly important, and it???s once again a testament to Tregillis??? skill as a writer that he can actually keep a reader riveted to one of the quieter scenes in the entire novel.

The third key protagonist (and perhaps my favourite) is Berenice Charlotte de Mornay-P??rigord, vicomtesse de Laval???and much more, besides. She is precisely the kind of female character I love reading about, and don???t get nearly often enough: practical, pragmatic, eloquently foul-mouthed (I rather wonder if Tregillis has been taking lessons in creative swearing from Scott Lynch), and concerned about her status in life only insofar as it lets her do her job. Much ink, both literal and digital, has been spilled over what makes a ???strong female character???, but in the end, I think the word ???strong??? in reference to characters means the same thing whoever or whatever the character is: the character must read like an actual, three-dimensional person.

Other readers, though, disagree with that assessment. They complain that Berenice is ???stupid???, because she keeps on making mistakes; however, the fact that she keeps making mistakes is one of the reasons why I like her so much. Berenice makes mistakes not because she???s stupid???she makes mistakes because she???s too smart for her own good. In fact, she is so intelligent, and so convinced of her own intelligence (though to be fair, she is frequently surrounded by idiots), that she is completely blind to a whole host of factors that, in the end, lead her to making one of the biggest mistakes of her life. The conviction that she is the smartest person in the room is Berenice???s greatest weakness???and is a weakness I???m more than familiar with, being susceptible to it myself. I think it is also necessary to point out that Berenice???s mistakes also partially spring from the fact that she isn???t exactly omniscient, and so can???t account for events that are happening beyond her reach???something many of Berenice???s detractors appear to forget, simply because they, as readers, are in an omniscient position.

What really makes Berenice a strong character, though, is not that she makes mistakes: it???s that she knows how to pick up and move on after making them. The same conviction that led Berenice to making the mistakes she did is the very same conviction that allows her to keep on moving, to pick up even after one of the greatest defeats in her life and move on. She knows what she has to do, and she knows that if she doesn???t do it, she will lose more than just her life: she will lose her entire nation. And if there is one thing Berenice Charlotte de Mornay-P??rigord has dedicated her life to, it???s protecting her country; nothing and no one is going to stop her from doing that, no matter her current circumstances in life.

As for the plot, it???s relatively good; Tregillis knows how to pace the story, and ensures that it???s tight enough that even when it slows down some (as it did in the scene I mentioned, between Tuinier Bell and Visser), it still maintains its overall momentum. However, there are certain moments???particularly in Jax???s and Visser???s story lines???when it seems like things happen to them, as opposed to because of something they???ve chosen to do. There are also certain logical inconsistencies within the world itself, particularly where alchemy is concerned.The most egregious example of the latter is something that happens in the ending, which has remarkable???and rather irritating???similarities to certain scenes in movies of a particular genre, which I???m sure readers will recognise once they read it.

Overall, The Mechanical is an interesting introduction to Tregillis??? alternate take on world history. The world building is mostly very well done, and is woven together with character development and plot momentum so that the reader is easily sucked into the world of the story. However, the novel isn???t without its issues: in particular, there are moments when the plot seems to overtake the characters, forcing them to act, rather than allowing their actions to spring from decisions they???ve made. There are also certain questions about the way alchemy works: an inconsistency shown most clearly during the novel???s ending. However, those issues don???t detract much from the overall quality of the story, and hopefully Tregillis will find a way to resolve them in the sequels.

Took about the first third of the book to get going but once it did it took off. I'll definitely get the rest of the series.

When I started reading this book and then looked at the author's other books, I was surprised to learn that I had already read something by this author: [b:Something More Than Night 17332272 Something More Than Night Ian Tregillis https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1380339039s/17332272.jpg 24035910]. I was surprised because the style and vocabulary and atmosphere are really different between these books! And obviously I never remember an author's name unless I really really like a book. But I'll remember Ian Tregillis now.This book was awesome. It's basically an alternate history sci-fi novel - what if alchemical magic existed, and The Netherlands used it to create an army of mechanical golems that they used to become the biggest colonial empire on earth? I really liked that this book started from the perspective of Jax, one of the golems (called Clakkers), because we're immediately put into this underground world of consciousness and rebellion that humans never see. As readers, it is obvious to us that the Clakkers are sentient and intelligent, so we're immediately rooting for them to throw off the shackles of slavery and give the arrogant Dutch what-for. As you read, you learn that the Clockmaker's Guild (who create the Clakkers, imbuing them with the alchemical geasa which bind them into servitude) has an official party line that Clakkers are nothing more than scaled-up wristwatches, and the people buy into because there's not any evidence to the contrary. Only there is, but no one is listening hard enough - the Clakkers speak to each other in their own morse-like language made up of the ticks and rattles of their steampunk bodies, and no one appears to be aware of this, not even The Guild...Though they must be aware of their creations' awareness. There are so many ethical layers to this situation that Tregillis either addresses outright or hints at, but nothing glaring is ignored - and more layers of religious morality and ideas of free will and the immortal soul are added, as the Dutch empire's main enemy, France, is Catholic and believes that Clakkers have souls. While none of the religious arguments ever hit home for me, considering I don't believe that immortal souls exist, the real existential crises that the characters went through were fascinating.I loved all three of the main characters. The book switches between their points of view, and I was always excited to get back to any of them. Berenice was a particularly awesome character - a woman in a position of power, who is smart, capable, and speaks her mind, but is confident to the point of hubris. I imagine her weaknesses are borne out of learning how to defend herself and her position to a royal council full of arrogant men, and I loved her story so much.On another feminist note, while sexism does exist in this world, sometimes as a plot point, Tregillis is really good at using female pronouns as much as male ones in side characters which I find are typically defaulted to male. In a group of soldiers, half are women. In a group of bystanders, half are women. I found myself paying more attention when I read a female pronoun in these cases, because I had already defaulted the nameless crowd members to male - I have been trained by media to view male as default and female as a characteristic added to default, so I was pleasantly surprised to see a female passerby scoffing or a female soldier holding a prisoner's arm or what have you. This is especially interesting to me considering that one of my main complaints about Something More Than Night was the 40's noir detective sexism of the main character.So I'm pretty excited about the next book in this series.