The Hobbitonian Anthology

Changes to the Fourth, Revised Edition

In his review of The Hobbitonian Anthology in Tolkien Studies No. 7, John D. Rateliff attempts to cast doubt on two statements regarding the linguistic relationship between Welsh and Hebrew, and between Welsh and Egyptian mythology. At the time of editing, it was felt that these statements were so far within the realm of common knowledge that they required no footnoting. Mr. Rateliff's comments, however, show that he is not aware of the requisite literature, therefore, the forthcoming fourth edition will include footnotes with cites to two sample sources each for those who would like to do further reading on these topics.

Those who have already purchased a copy of The Hobbitonian Anthology can read the changes at: http://llyfrawr.com/Hobbitonian/fourth.html