The Girl Who Takes an Eye for an Eye
Ratings63
Average rating3.4
Long mystery and thriller series are hard for me to stay invested in. At some point, it starts to feel like the same material is being recycled. The characters have already grown as much as they are going to, the plot becomes familiar, and the overall story starts to feel stale. For me, this book was the point where the series lost all of its momentum.
I know the characters are deep and nuanced from the earlier books, but that doesn’t come through here. They feel mostly one-dimensional. The journalism angle that added so much to the earlier novels is almost entirely absent. Lisbeth feels flat. Blomkvist’s personality barely comes through. There are also elements from Larsson’s original trilogy that seem to have been intentionally downplayed or ignored. One example is Berger’s relationship with Blomkvist. Her role had already been reduced in the previous book, but here it is virtually nonexistent until the final pages. Even then, her brief appearance seems to exist only to create conflict around her relationship with Blomkvist, potentially so it ends. That could have been fine if it were given proper attention, but instead, it is rushed and doesn’t quite fit with what we know about these characters.
In the earlier books, the first two-thirds were usually solid, but it was the final third where everything came to a head that really pulled me in. That section always made me want to keep turning pages, no matter the time or whatever else I needed to be doing. Unfortunately, that did not happen with this one. I found the story predictable, at times unbelievable, and ultimately not very engaging. Even the climax failed to hold my interest, missing the 'thrill' in thriller. Suffice to say I think this is the point I'll be stopping with this series
Long mystery and thriller series are hard for me to stay invested in. At some point, it starts to feel like the same material is being recycled. The characters have already grown as much as they are going to, the plot becomes familiar, and the overall story starts to feel stale. For me, this book was the point where the series lost all of its momentum.
I know the characters are deep and nuanced from the earlier books, but that doesn’t come through here. They feel mostly one-dimensional. The journalism angle that added so much to the earlier novels is almost entirely absent. Lisbeth feels flat. Blomkvist’s personality barely comes through. There are also elements from Larsson’s original trilogy that seem to have been intentionally downplayed or ignored. One example is Berger’s relationship with Blomkvist. Her role had already been reduced in the previous book, but here it is virtually nonexistent until the final pages. Even then, her brief appearance seems to exist only to create conflict around her relationship with Blomkvist, potentially so it ends. That could have been fine if it were given proper attention, but instead, it is rushed and doesn’t quite fit with what we know about these characters.
In the earlier books, the first two-thirds were usually solid, but it was the final third where everything came to a head that really pulled me in. That section always made me want to keep turning pages, no matter the time or whatever else I needed to be doing. Unfortunately, that did not happen with this one. I found the story predictable, at times unbelievable, and ultimately not very engaging. Even the climax failed to hold my interest, missing the 'thrill' in thriller. Suffice to say I think this is the point I'll be stopping with this series
Added to listMysterywith 11 books.
Added to listThrillerwith 9 books.
The book is a little “smaller” in scope than the previous books. A smaller story with smaller characters and smaller organizations. Yet all the ingredients are still there and they make for a quick, enjoyable read.
Maybe the characters are showing some “fatigue”. I'll definitely read the next book, but I'll keep my expectations in check.
The book is a little “smaller” in scope than the previous books. A smaller story with smaller characters and smaller organizations. Yet all the ingredients are still there and they make for a quick, enjoyable read.
Maybe the characters are showing some “fatigue”. I'll definitely read the next book, but I'll keep my expectations in check.
The book is a little “smaller” in scope than the previous books. A smaller story with smaller characters and smaller organizations. Yet all the ingredients are still there and they make for a quick, enjoyable read.
Maybe the characters are showing some “fatigue”. I'll definitely read the next book, but I'll keep my expectations in check.
The book is a little “smaller” in scope than the previous books. A smaller story with smaller characters and smaller organizations. Yet all the ingredients are still there and they make for a quick, enjoyable read.
Maybe the characters are showing some “fatigue”. I'll definitely read the next book, but I'll keep my expectations in check.
