The Children of Hurin
Ratings134
Average rating3.9
Children of Húrin is a tale compiled and told to us from some of Tolkien's extended writings. In this book Tolkien strives to emulate some of the myths that inspired much of his work. Here we predominantly follow Túrin, a figure from the First Age, who due to things outside of his control is cursed by the luciferian Morgthoth to suffer unto his death. Those familiar with Sigurd or Kulervo will quickly see the resemblance in the overall choices and trajectory this story takes. Túrin spends most of his time trying to avoid his doom, even taking the name Turambar or "Master of Doom" in a futile attempt to reclaim or take ownership of his fate. The more he tries to resist or avoid his fate the worse things get for him and those around him. Although if Túrin had believed his whole life that he was doomed from the start then his actions make a bit more sense. Often when we're told something as children whether good or bad it often follows us into adulthood, in this case turning this curse into a self fulfilling prophecy. This also goes to show how much our outlook can determine our fate. He starts off as an Aragorn like figure, with noble bearing and wisdom, taking solace within an elven kingdom and yet thru his actions and his untempered passions his life takes a very drastic turn. Although this tale mostly serves to fulfill Tolkien's love for European myth I think it slots in thematically with the rest of his Middle-Earth writings. Darkness prevails only when goodness is absent and it is up to each individual to kindle that within themselves if we wish to have a brighter tomorrow.
Overall i would recommend this to fans of mythology or those who want to explore some of Tolkien's extended writings on Middle-Earth but found the Silmarillion unappealing. The plot is fragmented giving it a loose or flimsy feeling which left me wishing Tolkien could've finished this great tale himself.
Children of Húrin is a tale compiled and told to us from some of Tolkien's extended writings. In this book Tolkien strives to emulate some of the myths that inspired much of his work. Here we predominantly follow Túrin, a figure from the First Age, who due to things outside of his control is cursed by the luciferian Morgthoth to suffer unto his death. Those familiar with Sigurd or Kulervo will quickly see the resemblance in the overall choices and trajectory this story takes. Túrin spends most of his time trying to avoid his doom, even taking the name Turambar or "Master of Doom" in a futile attempt to reclaim or take ownership of his fate. The more he tries to resist or avoid his fate the worse things get for him and those around him. Although if Túrin had believed his whole life that he was doomed from the start then his actions make a bit more sense. Often when we're told something as children whether good or bad it often follows us into adulthood, in this case turning this curse into a self fulfilling prophecy. This also goes to show how much our outlook can determine our fate. He starts off as an Aragorn like figure, with noble bearing and wisdom, taking solace within an elven kingdom and yet thru his actions and his untempered passions his life takes a very drastic turn. Although this tale mostly serves to fulfill Tolkien's love for European myth I think it slots in thematically with the rest of his Middle-Earth writings. Darkness prevails only when goodness is absent and it is up to each individual to kindle that within themselves if we wish to have a brighter tomorrow.
Overall i would recommend this to fans of mythology or those who want to explore some of Tolkien's extended writings on Middle-Earth but found the Silmarillion unappealing. The plot is fragmented giving it a loose or flimsy feeling which left me wishing Tolkien could've finished this great tale himself.
Despite being a self admitted Tolkien fanboy I always begin reading one of his works with the thought "well surely this one won't live up to the hype. All of his works can't be that good" and once again I'm forced to admit it is that good. I would recommend this to lovers of mythology or those who have an interest in Tolkien's extended writings but found the Silmarillion unappealing.
In this work Tolkien succeeds at emulating the very myths and legends that inspired much of his writing. With this one pulling from the doomed heroes of European mythology, specifically Sigurd and Kulervo, from the Volsung and the Kalevala respectively.
The story is told in an overview style, as if it were being recounted. At times this can be grating as it fragments the narrative, giving you the information piece meal over the course of several years. However in this instance its somewhat diagetic in that it puts the reader in the same situation as Húrin, trapped on the peak of Thangorodrim, bearing witness to the doom of his kin yet unable to intervene.
Tolkien scholars have often debated to what extent could Morgoth's curse effect Húrin and his kin. It's feasible that Morgoth commanded the orcs to raid and pillage the region and the easterling occupation of a major settlement. As well as the unleashing of Glaurung on Beleriand. Beyond that, all the misery that befell Túrin was by his own hand. He has his mother's pride and his father's passion without any temperance. You could say that its Túrin's belief in his doom that makes it so. It raises an interesting question. How much does our outlook dictate our fate? If Túrin had kept a positive outlook he would have had faith in King Thingol, who up until that point had treated him as his own son, instead of going into self imposed exile before even facing judgement. He chose to only see the world for all its misery and none of its beauty, turning his curse into a self fulfilling prophecy. This ties back into one of the greater themes of Tolkien's works. Although there will always be darkness we must not despair. If we live with hope in our hearts and believe in the goodness of the world we can have a brighter tomorrow.
Despite being a self admitted Tolkien fanboy I always begin reading one of his works with the thought "well surely this one won't live up to the hype. All of his works can't be that good" and once again I'm forced to admit it is that good. I would recommend this to lovers of mythology or those who have an interest in Tolkien's extended writings but found the Silmarillion unappealing.
In this work Tolkien succeeds at emulating the very myths and legends that inspired much of his writing. With this one pulling from the doomed heroes of European mythology, specifically Sigurd and Kulervo, from the Volsung and the Kalevala respectively.
The story is told in an overview style, as if it were being recounted. At times this can be grating as it fragments the narrative, giving you the information piece meal over the course of several years. However in this instance its somewhat diagetic in that it puts the reader in the same situation as Húrin, trapped on the peak of Thangorodrim, bearing witness to the doom of his kin yet unable to intervene.
Tolkien scholars have often debated to what extent could Morgoth's curse effect Húrin and his kin. It's feasible that Morgoth commanded the orcs to raid and pillage the region and the easterling occupation of a major settlement. As well as the unleashing of Glaurung on Beleriand. Beyond that, all the misery that befell Túrin was by his own hand. He has his mother's pride and his father's passion without any temperance. You could say that its Túrin's belief in his doom that makes it so. It raises an interesting question. How much does our outlook dictate our fate? If Túrin had kept a positive outlook he would have had faith in King Thingol, who up until that point had treated him as his own son, instead of going into self imposed exile before even facing judgement. He chose to only see the world for all its misery and none of its beauty, turning his curse into a self fulfilling prophecy. This ties back into one of the greater themes of Tolkien's works. Although there will always be darkness we must not despair. If we live with hope in our hearts and believe in the goodness of the world we can have a brighter tomorrow.
Well, that was cheery. This is very much tell don’t show, so your enjoyment will depend on your tolerance for “And in X did Y slay Z” declamations. Personally, my tolerance has obviously dropped way off since the days when I had the patience to slog through The Silmarillion. At least it was relatively short. One for the completionists.
Well, that was cheery. This is very much tell don’t show, so your enjoyment will depend on your tolerance for “And in X did Y slay Z” declamations. Personally, my tolerance has obviously dropped way off since the days when I had the patience to slog through The Silmarillion. At least it was relatively short. One for the completionists.
