Ratings1
Average rating4
Winner, American Library Association Booklist’s Top of the List, 2019 Adult Nonfiction Acclaimed writer Marie Arana delivers a cultural history of Latin America and the three driving forces that have shaped the character of the region: exploitation (silver), violence (sword), and religion (stone). “Meticulously researched, [this] book’s greatest strengths are the power of its epic narrative, the beauty of its prose, and its rich portrayals of character…Marvelous” (The Washington Post). Leonor Gonzales lives in a tiny community perched 18,000 feet above sea level in the Andean cordillera of Peru, the highest human habitation on earth. Like her late husband, she works the gold mines much as the Indians were forced to do at the time of the Spanish Conquest. Illiteracy, malnutrition, and disease reign as they did five hundred years ago. And now, just as then, a miner’s survival depends on a vast global market whose fluctuations are controlled in faraway places. Carlos Buergos is a Cuban who fought in the civil war in Angola and now lives in a quiet community outside New Orleans. He was among hundreds of criminals Cuba expelled to the US in 1980. His story echoes the violence that has coursed through the Americas since before Columbus to the crushing savagery of the Spanish Conquest, and from 19th- and 20th-century wars and revolutions to the military crackdowns that convulse Latin America to this day. Xavier Albó is a Jesuit priest from Barcelona who emigrated to Bolivia, where he works among the indigenous people. He considers himself an Indian in head and heart and, for this, is well known in his adopted country. Although his aim is to learn rather than proselytize, he is an inheritor of a checkered past, where priests marched alongside conquistadors, converting the natives to Christianity, often forcibly, in the effort to win the New World. Ever since, the Catholic Church has played a central role in the political life of Latin America—sometimes for good, sometimes not. In this “timely and excellent volume” (NPR) Marie Arana seamlessly weaves these stories with the history of the past millennium to explain three enduring themes that have defined Latin America since pre-Columbian times: the foreign greed for its mineral riches, an ingrained propensity to violence, and the abiding power of religion. Silver, Sword, and Stone combines “learned historical analysis with in-depth reporting and political commentary...[and] an informed and authoritative voice, one that deserves a wide audience” (The New York Times Book Review).
Reviews with the most likes.
This book is an excellent run-down of Latin American history. The author presents Latin America history through three themes. The first is silver-wealth, plunder, and spoils. The sword represents the violence that has shaped and molded Latin America. The Stone is religious thought, faith, and worship. As the author weaves between different tales and narratives, jumping from the past to the present and back again, she presents the reader with ancestors and descendants of those molded by the silver, sword, and stone.
The only aspect of the book that left a lot to be desired was her emphasis on Latin America's history and culture of violence. At times, it seems like the author explains current and previous atrocities by way of Latin America's violent empires. I would have loved to see her bring her analysis of underdevelopment and exploitation to bare more closely on the matter of violence. That isn't to say she doesn't talk about these problems, but it sometimes seems that the author feels that Latin America's culture and history of violence is to blame for its current state of violence and bloodshed.
All things considered, I'd say this is a great read for anyone interested in Latin American history, culture, and politics. I can't end the review without praising the inclusion, attention, and emphasis placed on the role of native peoples and cultures. The author's analysis of the Incan and Aztec empires were, for me, one of the great highlights of the book.