Revenant Gun

The best and most heartbreaking book I've read in years, and that's saying something. Reading the other two before it is crucial to understand everything happening here. There's nothing I can say about this except that it's a masterwork of characterization and plotting, making an impossible premise work in a seemingly effortless fashion.

“You're not supposed to spend on frivolous shit, but what good is life without some frivolous shit?”

Here we are, the end of a trilogy I greatly enjoyed. It's a testament to how intriguing I found the series that I finished all three books within a span of six months, because I never read series books back-to-back. This was a wild ride, and on the other side I'm still not sure I could explain some of the concepts going on, but I still really enjoyed it.

I won't go into story details, because basically anything I can say about the plot would be spoilers for this book and the series as a whole. Suffice it to say that things get a bit weird(er?), there's new POVs introduced for this book, and some are more endearing than others. If Hemiola could get her own spinoff series, I'd be super happy, thanks. I'm slightly disappointed in the ending, but I guess I can see how things wrapped up.

I do feel like, as tight and clean as the second book felt in terms of plot and progression, this third book felt like a bit of a regression. The story is a bit fragmented for large chunks of the book, and it's hard to see initially how things are supposed to fit. The ending felt a bit rushed and blended together to get everything to work, which felt a bit different than the endings of the other two books.

I still would recommend this series to anyone willing to take on a bit of a challenge in terms of sci-fi terminology and concepts. Jedao is a delight and a treasure.

Well, I finally finished it. Honestly, I don't know what I think about it. I mean, I read it to finish the series but, I'm not sure how much I really enjoyed reading this book. Sure, there's been a lot of stuff going on for me this last week and I've been busy, and I knew going into it that this is not the kind of book I could read only a couple pages of, or read while I was distracted.

But, pure enjoyment? My stomach was a knot of nerves for like eight-five percent of this book. So, on a level of how attached I got to characters, this series did amazing. Mostly thanks to the first book, because I fell in love with the Jedao of Ninefox Gambit and started to quite adore Cheris as well. Though, I will add, I wound up, upon a reread of Raven Stratagem, really liking Brezan, too. And because of my liking of certain characters (Jedao) I had problems (understatement!) at times reading this book and I'm somewhat dissatisfied with the direction of certain things - and the ending.

At the same time, I really, really want a sequel because I have become invested in this world and there were some earthshaking events in this book that never get a chance to breathe. And, also, certain implications are not dealt with and would love to know what certain people that we don't get to check in with after the battle are doing now.

On the other hand, this book didn't grab me with the characters the way the first - or even the second - one did. I felt very removed from Cheris and... well, Jedao's whole thing is something I don't know what to do with.

I might enjoy this book more on a reread (like I did with Ninefox Gambit) or I might like it less (like I did with Raven Stratagem) because then I would know at least the ending and could maybe read without feeling a sense of dread and stressing out about what's going to happen next. But, also, I'm not sure with the way this book has emotionally gutted me, that I'll ever want to reread it.

In short, I still don't know what to do with this book. Four stars is too high, three stars is too low and I am ready to go weep. Goodnight everyone.

These three books were great, set in a strange universe of calendrical warfare. I still can't explain what that is, but that doesn't matter. Just remember Clarke's Law. What made this book extra challenging was the fact that the protagonist exists twice, and at least at the start, is referred to by the same name, no matter which one of them the story currently focuses on. Once again, it all netaly comes together in the end, and makes for a good “final” book.

A satisfying conclusion to the somewhat bizarre trilogy.

adssdfsdasdl;kj OH MY GOD

maybe i will review this for real later but i just finished it and I AM DESTROYED it was so good and haunting on every possible level

Executive Summary: A satisfying conclusion to a pretty enjoyable series.Audiobook: Emily Woo Zeller does another great job with the narration. She reads at a good pace with good inflections and volume. I will say this is one of the more difficult series I've done in audio. There are parts I find confusing where I'd probably have reread them if I was doing the text instead of the audio. I think if you're a seasoned audiobook listener you'll be fine, but I'd probably recommend against the audio for the more casual listeners.Full ReviewI feel like this series is one of those people either absolutely love, or simply get put off by all the strange calendar/math stuff. I'm somewhere in the middle. I struggled a lot with the calendar thing and “formation instinct”, until I decided to forgo caring much about it. I basically just treat it like magic or a plot device. At its core this series is a space opera about a struggle for freedom from an oppressive government. Once I focused on that, I enjoyed it a lot more.Of course I decided that two books ago, or I wouldn't be here writing a review of the third book. I don't remember when I read [b:Raven Stratagem 32927239 Raven Stratagem (The Machineries of Empire, #2) Yoon Ha Lee https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1478799108s/32927239.jpg 51237351], but it felt like forever ago because I was REALLY lost for the first day or so of listening. Eventually I got my bearings (and realized that some of my confusion was due to some plot developments) and I really enjoyed the book overall.Three books in, there isn't much I can say without getting into spoiler territory. I'll say that I felt like things were resolved pretty well and that most of the questions I had were answered to my satisfaction. I'd probably read another book in the series if he decided to do a spin-off/sequel series but I don't feel it's necessary either. I will definitely be on the lookout to see what Yoon Ha Lee does next.

Let's be clear, there is no point reading this concluding volume if you haven't read the previous two books. It throws you in at the deep end, with little recapping or concessions to new readers. But if you have read them, you can rest assured that this is a worthwhile conclusion to one of the most different and interesting SF series in a long time. If you ever wanted a set of books full of esoteric blood drenched mathematics, calendars that affect reality, and eldritch technology, I've got good news for you....