Moonlight on Butternut Lake

This was my least favorite of the three (at least so far) Butternut Lake novels. The plot was entirely predictable, a mix of “Sleeping with the Enemy” and “Me After You.” The characters were flat, especially compared to Caroline, Jack, Daisy and Will from Butternut Summer. Maybe McNear tried to write too many novels too quickly, but this one was paint-by-numbers women's fiction.