Lens of the World

3.5 Originally posted at FanLit
http://www.fantasyliterature.com/reviews/lens-of-the-world/

Nazhuret was an ugly half-breed orphan when he started life at an exclusive military school, but now he???s someone important. So important, in fact, that the king has asked him to write his autobiography. Who is this man who has fascinated a king, what is he now, and how did he come so far in the world?

Lens of the World, published in 1990, is the first book in R.A. MacAvoy???s LENS OF THE WORLD trilogy. It???s a coming-of-age story which reminds me of several fantasy epics I???ve read, especially Ursula K. Le Guin???s EARTHSEA series, Robin Hobb???s FARSEER saga and, more recently, Patrick Rothfuss???s KINGKILLER CHRONICLE.

Those are some big names I???ve used as comparison. Can MacAvoy really stand up to that? Mostly yes. Nazhuret is not quite as likable as FitzChivalry Farseer and not quite as interesting as Kvothe, but he???s an appealing hero, as are a couple of the other main characters such as Nazhuret???s enigmatic teacher, Powl, who lives in a strange round building and teaches Nazhuret to sit still, think, speak several languages, dance, fight, and appreciate optics, linguistics and other academic subjects. Then there???s a girl named Charlin who Nazhuret thinks he loves, though he???s not sure. (Sexuality is confusing to Nazhuret since he was raped by his schoolmasters when he was a boy.) And finally there???s Arlen, a thief who remembers Nazhuret from his school days, and the red-headed King whom Nazhuret meets later in the story and to whom we assume he???s writing.

Plot-wise, Nazhuret???s story is always interesting and I often found it absorbing, but I wouldn???t say that it quite reaches the level of ???exciting.??? For nearly half of the book he???s being educated before he sets off on his own and works odd jobs such as farm hand, janitor, and bouncer. He encounters bar fights, murderers, a wedding, a werewolf, a dragon, and makes friends with a dog. All this time, of course, we???re aware that he???s casually addressing the king as he writes his autobiography, so this makes us realize with anticipation that something important is going to happen. Toward the end we find out why his teacher is so interested in him, and learn that perhaps Nazhuret has a destiny. Other revelations about Powl and Arlen made me want to read on.

This doesn???t sound too much different from many other coming-of-age fantasy novels I???ve read, but what makes Lens of the World stand out is R.A. MacAvoy???s style, and this is why I???ve compared her to Hobb and Le Guin. Like those authors, MacAvoy???s prose is both beautiful and succinct ??? something that I truly admire but rarely experience.

I listened to Audible Frontier???s audio version of Lens of the World which was narrated by Jeremy Arthur, who did a perfect job with voices and cadence. It was the lovely thoughtful prose and the excellent narration that really carried me through this story, letting me just sit back and enjoy a beautifully told tale. I???m looking forward to the next book, King of the Dead.

5 stars, Metaphorosis Reviews

Summary
Nazhuret, ugly boy of uncertain parentage, has been in Sordaling School for as long as he can remember. But eventually he must leave, and on the eve of his departure, a distant, brutal teacher takes him in to teach him things for which he has no use.

Review
Sometimes, you go back to a much-loved book and find it's just not as good as you recall, no matter how you try to keep that golden haze of memory wrapped around it. Much less frequently, as in this case, you go back to a well-regarded book and find out just how much better it is than you remember.

I came to R. A. MacAvoy via the Damiano trilogy, which struck as technically competent, but dry, with a setting I found uninteresting, and too much religion for my taste. I felt much the same about Tea With the Black Dragon and its sequel, Twisting the Rope. Yet, thanks to MacAvoy's technical skill, I kept on, and I was amply rewarded with Lens of the World.

I remember being struck by Lens – and, to a lesser extent, its sequels – but, re-reading it now, I'm not sure I got as much out of it as I should have. Despite an unprepossessing format – no chapters, a long, nominally epistolary format, and little really speculative about it – this is a masterful piece of work. Nazhuret's character is so engaging, MacAvoy's prose so precise, that the story draws you in regardless, and repays in full. It has just the right balance of subtlety and confidence in the reader, of emotion and exposition. I liked it a lot the first time around. This time, I loved it.

For once, this is a book deserving all the accolades from authors and critics printed in the front and back. And yet, after this trilogy, MacAvoy seemed to disappear. I see now in ISFdb that she had a 2011 title I'll have to look up. There should be more.