Legacy of Ash

This is classic, epic fantasy at every level. Good battle scenes, interesting magic, with a side of political intrigue. It only gets 3 stars because there was just too much going on that it made it difficult to really engage with any one part. Viktor is a strong character but I wish this had been more focused on him and maybe one or two others rather than there being 20 different narrators. I checked the cast list at least once a chapter for probably the first 500 pages. That being said, it’s a fun, fast read in an interesting world and I’ll consider continuing the series.

Liked: Malachi, Viktor, all twists and turns and intrigues.

Didn't like: Melanna, romance.

It's strange but I think this book should be longer. Too much characters and so many events and I needed more substance and breather episodes.

3.75

“Just because something's inevitable, doesn't mean it can't wait. Otherwise, why get out of bed? Why do anything at all?”

A very solid fantasy book, with great characters and very interesting magic! My interest dropped off in the middle a touch but I think that was more me than the book itself.

Will definitely be moving onto Legacy of Steel soon

Very well written, but both the MCs and dialogues felt too YA for me, and the setting too bland typical epic fantasy.

Another fantasy debut and this one is a good one! Epic in scope with a sprawling mythos and mythology backing some fantastic world building and character development. Multiple POVs give this doorstop of a novel the chance to bounce around different parts of a country, with political machinations in the capital, invasion in the South and the release of some ancient evil.

The dominant part of the story is set in a province of an empire that has recently had a failed rebellion. The people here are beaten and repressed, held under the thumb of some particularly obnoxious officialdom. The ruling family is somewhat disgraced, but the son and daughter of the rebel leader still live on as figureheads, even if they are both searching for their own ways out.

In between this we have a ruling council that are largely ruthless, cunning and narcistic. One particularly ruthless member is trying to manipulate events to gain absolute control. The ‘good' part of the council recognise the dangers to the realm with invasion of the troubled Duchy and do what they can to assist.

These different elements weave in and out with plenty of moral ambiguity on some characters actions.

Overall I was very impressed with how Matthew Ward wove these elements all together. My main gripe here is that there is just so much thrown at you as a reader. this could probably have been broken down into more manageable chunks - the size of the book shows that there is probably more than one books worth of material in here! However, the frenetic pace is kept up throughout and interest in the story maintained. A fun read and well worth the time devotion required.

I'm left confused...

this book is the Bi-polar of the Fantasy Genre. one moment it's dull and boring, then next there a bit more interest, then it falls flat and boring again. Honestly, It was like I was riding a roller coaster with no emotional investment.

first off, the book could have done without half the cast of characters, some who appeared only to die a scene later. it provided nothing to the story. second, the fluff at the beginning could have been shortened by 300 pages. it would have made a better book.

the story was okay. as a debut, it wasn't John Gwynne blow-your-mind debut, but it was fine. okay.
it did feel like a slog most of the way through. and I read a lot of high fantasy, so it's not the genre or the length of the book.

the characters fell a bit flat. Victor, Malichai and Anastasia were fleshed out enough, but to the point that I didn't really care if they lived or died. Kurkas on the other hand, I loved. I didn't mind Calenne, but I don't think we needed a POV from her. or half the others. I think that was one of the major problems with this book. The author took on too big a cast than he could handle.

one of the good things from this story, is Joseri's arc and Melenna's story. now SHE was an interesting character. and I loved Malitriant. I know I shouldn't, but as it always happens in a lot of stories, the villain's are better characters and it was true here.

some people have said this is like game of thrones and I don't find that at all. apart from the multi POV and the politics, its nothing like game of thrones. there's no real big war, no high stakes.


I can't put a finger on it, but it didn't engage me.


the ending was one of the good bits and I read the last 200 pages in one stint. and the confusion throughout the book, when I finally decided on what this book was actually about, as the small war between the southshires and the Hadri didn't feel like the ‘real' plot, but a cover up, fell so far down the cliff it's still rolling.


like. WHAT?


I'm left with more questions than I have answers. it seemed the author has tried to accomplish a plot twist, but failed as I don't understand what the twist is. some of his descriptions and way of explaining things just didn't sink into my brain, but, maybe I'm just an odd one.

Will I read the next instalment? maybe. but, I suggest the Author works a little more on his next book, and tries not to make it such a big cast with useless characters, and shortens the book.

I was going to give this a 3.5 but, on more thought, it's a 3*

Wow!!!

As a newbie to adult fantasy, well fantasy anything. This story blew my mind. I am so excited for the next book in the series, but before it comes, a re-read is definitely in order.

Matthew Ward???s debut novel is a grand sweeping affair that whilst being expansive, is a tightly knit story that weaves war, rebellion, magic, political intrigue and legacy into a compelling drama that is unputdownable.

The Tressian Republic stands at the centre of the world, yet it???s might is being tested. Rebellion threatens in the Southshires and Josiri Trelan, the son of the rebel Katya Trelan and now imprisoned in his own home, is gathering his forces so that he can lead the rebellion started by his mother 15 years ago and free his people from Tressia???s harsh rule.

Meanwhile, the Hadari Empire is rising, ready to overwhelm the empire and become the leading power in the world bringing war and death

However, underneath the waves of military upheaval, a dark power is stirring. Gods walk the world, choosing their champions and setting in motion their own plans.
Ward???s tale is magnificent in its scale. The scope is an entire world, and yet, he can seamlessly change his focus to the smallest aspects of his tale and concentrate on the minutest aspects of the drama, like Revekaah and Kurka???s tale in the woods during the titanic battle against the Hadari, or Calenne???s story under the battlefield as she discovers terrible secrets.

The cast of characters is impressive, although at times this can become confusing, and sometimes if I took my brain off the plot for a second, I was left wondering what was happening and had to go back a page or two to reconnect. However, the book demands your attention and concentration, and if you feed the story well with these two things, you will be richly rewarded.

The characters themselves are excellently written, with the Lady Ebigail being a standout of scheming and general maleficence. However, she never once falls into parody as she joyfully plots and weaves webs of intrigue, murdering, blackmailing and manipulating anyone who gets in her way.

The other players in this book are Viktor Akadra, the champion of the Tressian council. A knight who gains this title after he kills Josiri and Calenne???s mother, Katya. Viktor is an interesting character, portrayed as a stoical villain initially, yet as the story progresses, his character is explored more, and we learn that his character is more faceted than we originally thought, and Ward plays with these facets to great effect. An especially touching aspect, is his relationship with Calenne, who originally believing him to be the monster who killed her mother and haunts her nightmares, forms an unlikely friendship and even allies with him to save the Southshires after she learns the truth of her mother???s death. In fact, far from being the monster and killing machine that he is believed to be, Viktor is a thoughtful, socially anxious man that is afraid of his own shadow (that part will become clear!)

Calenne, is the other prominent figure of the story. At first, she is portrayed spoilt brat of a child that generally mopes around her prison, dreaming of a way out, even if it is by dying. She is afraid of the legacy that her mother, the hero of Southshires has left her, and yet when the need arises, she wears this persona to motivate others around her. Again, Calenne is a rounded individual that has flaws, and at times shows that she can be as manipulative as Lady Ebigail, in order to get what she wants.

And then there???s Josiri, an ineffectual leader who dreams of freeing his family from the past. At times, Josiri can be the strong leader that is needed. However, other times he can be impulsive and not recognise the consequences of his behaviour. But, as with Viktor, Ward brings him to life showing us that his character has more sides than a twenty - sided dice.

Additionally, the main characters are bolstered by equally memorable side characters, like Anastacia, either an angel or a demon, depending on which characters point of view. And, the gods themselves, with some memorable cameo roles by the God of Death, known as the Raven, who reminds me in some parts of Baron Samedi crossed with old Father Time, a Herne the Hunter type figure who makes an infrequent appearance in the story and the capricious, Ashana

Don???t be put off by the fact that this is a weighty book and the fact that the plot simmers for the first part of the book. When the gears are turned up, the story explodes and gallops along at full speed.

As with every other aspect of this book, Ward skilfully manoeuvres his cast of characters around the chessboard of his plot, carefully placing them where they need to be so that we reach the finale of the story. He carefully weaves plot, pace and characters, all the while building a richly complex world, magic system and mythology that will surely delight fans of epic fantasy.