Haven

A strange book - I thought it might be in a vein as Matrix, but it ended up being much more austere with a long, slow meander to the climax. Glad I read it though.

Not recommended for vegans or people who are squeamish.

Emma Donoghue always tackles the most difficult of topics with grace and nuance most of us struggle to even imagine being capable of. 

It's such a weird read but a rewarding one.

As much as I love Emma Donoghue, I can't say I enjoyed this one at all. It read like a how-to manual on survival (or slow death) on a rocky, bird-infested, shit hole of an island with an obtuse, over zealous, infuriating monk. I really struggled with all the nature writing (it's not really my bag) and while I actually really liked the other main characters - it wasn't enough to keep me invested. Very disappointed - but I'm sure this book will find its audience with the more literary set. I just wasn't in the mood unfortunately.

I wanted to read this solely because of the author (and the mysterious, vaguely sinister cover art!). I've really enjoyed Emma Donoghue's books, especially The Pull of the Stars and Frog Music. Had Haven been written by almost anyone else, I probably wouldn't have considered it - a tale of three monks living in the early middle ages is far from my typical choice. That said, I'm very glad I did. I didn't necessarily love this book, but I found myself completely absorbed in it - I HAD to talk about it as I was reading it (to the point that my husband, not a huge reader, is eager to read it when it's available).

It's very much about religion, but it's also about the struggle to reconcile what you feel in your deepest self to be true about the world with what your ‘superior' is insisting is incontrovertible fact. While I couldn't relate directly to many of the things depicted in the book - from the devoutly religious, like vowing chastity, poverty, humility, and (most important to the plot) obedience, to the day-to-day of the monks' isolated existence, like writing on calfskin vellum and trying to carve out a garden from unforgiving rock - it reminded me in some strange but strong ways of Silicon Valley in the 21st century and the cult of tech leadership we buy into out of some combination of hope and willful delusion (e.g., Theranos). The power dynamics were easily the most fascinating part of the story for me. I also find myself coming back to the haunting implications - even back in the 600s, and exponentially so today - of the belief that everything on earth was put there by God for humans to use.

Overall, a really unusual and well-written meditation on what it means to be a ‘leader' and how to do right in the world. Recommend!

Thanks to NetGalley and Little, Brown and Company for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.

Artt has a dream.. A real dream that tells him to leave the sins of the world behind. He takes two monks with him on his adventures and they all row down the river shannon, looking for a place to build a monastery.
The island they found isn't exactly what they had in mind but they make this work? Can the survive the place to do Gods work?

It wasn't as good as I was hoping it would be. It was really slow in places and it lost my interest a few times. Dpon't get me wrong, it was worth getting to the end but I just didn't love it as much as I wanted to.

3 stars