Fire and Ice
Ratings47
Average rating3.7
I'd rate this book 3.5 if I could since I enjoyed it slightly more than the first novel. The only reason I didn't rate it higher is because this book was filled with too much drama! The worse being Fireheart and Graystripe arguing over a she-cat. My boys took the entire book to reconcile!
Fireheart is right to be concerned over Graystripe's romance, but he has no right to question his friend's loyalty to Thunderclan. It's pretty ironic that he does so when you consider how the clan (especially Tigerclaw) is always questioning FH's loyalty. He should know first-paw that it doesn't feel nice. That and he's meeting with his sister so.....
I can forgive FH for being immature and clueless about romance though. In time, maybe he will learn that the heart is a complicated matter. I still love this character dearly; he's so good and brave.
I'd have to say that the beginning of the book was my favorite. The mission to bring Windclan home was wonderful, and we got to see just how special FH is.
The ending was better this time around. The pacing was great and the major problem (i.e., the boy's fighting) was resolved. Definitely a better book. Looking forward to the next one!
I'd rate this book 3.5 if I could since I enjoyed it slightly more than the first novel. The only reason I didn't rate it higher is because this book was filled with too much drama! The worse being Fireheart and Graystripe arguing over a she-cat. My boys took the entire book to reconcile!
Fireheart is right to be concerned over Graystripe's romance, but he has no right to question his friend's loyalty to Thunderclan. It's pretty ironic that he does so when you consider how the clan (especially Tigerclaw) is always questioning FH's loyalty. He should know first-paw that it doesn't feel nice. That and he's meeting with his sister so.....
I can forgive FH for being immature and clueless about romance though. In time, maybe he will learn that the heart is a complicated matter. I still love this character dearly; he's so good and brave.
I'd have to say that the beginning of the book was my favorite. The mission to bring Windclan home was wonderful, and we got to see just how special FH is.
The ending was better this time around. The pacing was great and the major problem (i.e., the boy's fighting) was resolved. Definitely a better book. Looking forward to the next one!
I'd rate this book 3.5 if I could since I enjoyed it slightly more than the first novel. The only reason I didn't rate it higher is because this book was filled with too much drama! The worse being Fireheart and Graystripe arguing over a she-cat. My boys took the entire book to reconcile!
Fireheart is right to be concerned over Graystripe's romance, but he has no right to question his friend's loyalty to Thunderclan. It's pretty ironic that he does so when you consider how the clan (especially Tigerclaw) is always questioning FH's loyalty. He should know first-paw that it doesn't feel nice. That and he's meeting with his sister so.....
I can forgive FH for being immature and clueless about romance though. In time, maybe he will learn that the heart is a complicated matter. I still love this character dearly; he's so good and brave.
I'd have to say that the beginning of the book was my favorite. The mission to bring Windclan home was wonderful, and we got to see just how special FH is.
The ending was better this time around. The pacing was great and the major problem (i.e., the boy's fighting) was resolved. Definitely a better book. Looking forward to the next one!
I'd rate this book 3.5 if I could since I enjoyed it slightly more than the first novel. The only reason I didn't rate it higher is because this book was filled with too much drama! The worse being Fireheart and Graystripe arguing over a she-cat. My boys took the entire book to reconcile!
Fireheart is right to be concerned over Graystripe's romance, but he has no right to question his friend's loyalty to Thunderclan. It's pretty ironic that he does so when you consider how the clan (especially Tigerclaw) is always questioning FH's loyalty. He should know first-paw that it doesn't feel nice. That and he's meeting with his sister so.....
I can forgive FH for being immature and clueless about romance though. In time, maybe he will learn that the heart is a complicated matter. I still love this character dearly; he's so good and brave.
I'd have to say that the beginning of the book was my favorite. The mission to bring Windclan home was wonderful, and we got to see just how special FH is.
The ending was better this time around. The pacing was great and the major problem (i.e., the boy's fighting) was resolved. Definitely a better book. Looking forward to the next one!
