Existence

One I will have to re-read and assess after sometime has passed. Brin never fails to engage the mind.Ideas flow thick and fast.Characters playing out their lives in plausible future environments and events. However perhaps too many,too quick. For some reason I keep thinking of an interactive video game rather than a novel. This may be unfair because I cant articulate why. I didnt make much of an emotional connection with any of the characters.As I reached the end I didnt care about what happened to anybody although I did about what would happen to our species. Brin made me care about chatterbox individual dolphins in the past [so much so i wish he'd get back to them] so probably my expectations arent that high. He's clearly doing a “Brunner” and I applaud him for that as its a style worth keeping alive. Earth was a book of ideas and the characters plus the ideas and events drove the plot.
But I need to re read maybe the ideas just overpowered the story and second time around I'll find it a more enjoying read.

Story: 5 / 10
Characters: 7
Setting: 8
Prose: 7

Strong concept, but too many irrelevant story threads results in a largely unintelligible book.

Big book. Big ideas. Unexpected directions.

David Brin's Existence is both very interesting and somewhat irritating. The book has eight parts. The first six parts tell an engaging and interesting story which follows the adventures of several protagonists during a time of first contact. At that point I surmise that Brin decided that he just wouldn't be able to finish the book if he continued that way (at least not in a single volume). Anyway, he radically changed the style in parts seven and eight. In those two sections we no longer see the protagonists meeting challenges as events unfold. Instead, the story takes great leaps forward in time, pushing to story forward. Some foreshadowed adventures and events that I was anticipating were told only in hindsight. This let Brin finish the story in one (big) book, but at some cost to the storytelling.
Existence is chock full of interesting and provocative ideas about what the future may bring. Whether it is technical, scientific, social, economic, or you name it, the book touches on most everything related to, yes, existence. Brin's imagination is rather amazing. The book is worth reading just for that. And, the first contact idea in Existence doesn't fit any of the standard SF tropes that I know of. It is quite an unusual and interesting idea.
Conclusion: While Existence doesn't tell as good a story as some of Brin's earlier books (for example, Startide Rising and The Uplift War), it is still a good read, especially for those who like hard SF.

A fun read. Brin never fails me. A little frantic for some I expect, but I like the feel and breadth of the story. My only complaint is the dolphins seem to get left hanging.

David Brin is an icon in science fiction, and for good reasons. Brin's imagination gave us works like the Kiln People, the Postman, and of course, the seminal Uplift War saga in all of its glory. In his latest novel, Existence, Brin takes us to the near future, a world where mankind has continued to make mistakes, but has also made attempts at progress. We start by meeting Gerald Livingston, an orbital garbage collector. For a hundred years, people have abandoned things in space, and someone has to clean it up. But there's something spinning a little bit higher than he expects, something that isn't on the decades' old orbital maps. An hour after he grabs it and brings it in, rumors fill Earth's infomesh about an “alien artifact.”

Thrown into the maelstrom of worldwide shared experience, the Artifact is a game-changer. A message in a bottle; an alien capsule that wants to communicate. The world reacts as humans always do: with fear and hope and selfishness and love and violence. And insatiable curiosity. (end blurb)
The difficulty I have with describing or even assessing this book is that it felt to me like it was written in three different mindsets. The first 25% of the book falls into that class of science fiction that deals with world crisis - you may recognize the formula. The setting - near future. The cast - someone in power, someone outside of the corridors of power, and a reporter of some kind. Additional cast optional. The crisis - something outside of our control threatens the way of life globally - flood, solar flares, alien incursion, etc.. The artifact is uncovered, ripples reach out, and we see how these dozen or so lives of our cast are affected, in some ways interacting.

Then the book takes a shift.

I'm glossing over, because I'm trying to avoid any spoilers, but the next chunk of the book (@50%) left me growing impatient for something to actually happen. That isn't to say that there isn't action or progress, but the middle seemed to stretch on and on without any satisfaction of resolution. Towards the end of this chunck we get a lot of tantalyzing clues and suggestions about our place in the universe, answers to the Fermi paradox, etc.. I would classify this portion of the book as less sci-fi disaster novel and back down into the near future thriller genre.

Then came the last 25%. Neither crisis novel nor thriller, this part of the book was pure speculative space opera, which if we're talking science fiction, is known to be my preference. It'll be no suprise that I wish the writing in the last 25% of the book had actually been more like 75%.

Brin is very much in touch with modern technology, and it shows in this book. Our near future citizens aren't that displaced from today. The gadgets are shinier and smaller, but the concepts are the same, or at least taken to their next few logical steps. Its only after reading the Afterword, where Brin explains himself and the novel a little more, that we learn that a lof of that first 25% of the book was previously written material that was worked in. Although I enjoyed those bits - especially the homage to uplift - I didn't feel like they were satisfactorily given a conclusion. The same happened later in the book, where we were led along certain paths and then never saw the characters involved again, leaving those subplots just dangling.

Don't be discouraged. Existence was still a good read by a great author, just be prepared to do a little work to get there.

Thanks to NetGalley and Tor/Forge for an advance copy of the novel.