Empire

Writing-wise, Empire was good. The prose is smooth, the characters generally interesting. The beginning chapter is (as so often) a bit rocky, but once we settle in to following our hero Reza, things go more smoothly. There are occasional and sometimes unheralded point of view shifts, but nothing really problematic. The real story is about the characters, and up until the end, that was quite good. I read the story with interest and a desire to see what happened next.

Content-wise, I had more trouble. The story, a heavily military SF novel, has a bit of an Ender's Game feeling at points, but probably leans more heavily towards Jerry Pournelle. Unfortunately, with a good deal more reverence for the military (from whom all blessings flow). Once Reza heads off to live with the Kreelan, the story turns even more towards combat. Granted, the Kreelan are a culture based around a military order, but I found it difficult to stomach the mystical attitude towards combat.

There were other flaws in the setting. The Kreelan are a high-tech species, yet live a very low-tech lifestyle. Hicks explains how that happens, but never why. An annoying tendency to use Yoda-speak have they also.

Much more troubling is the human physical similarity with Kreelan - not only food, air, temperature, vision and auditory range, but they're sexually compatible. If you're going to have your hero make love to an alien, you have to emphasize physical similarity from the start. I'm not talking makeshift sex - I mean part A fits part B, all the mechanics work fine, everybody enjoys it. Because it wasn't signposted, I found this highly non-credible.

Story-wise, the major flaw was that Reza's action at the end of the book is completely unsupported, and therefore not credible. I also found it disturbing how easily he slid into a Stockholm syndrome love for his captors, but a) perhaps that changes in later books, and b) just being disturbing doesn't make it bad.

There's nothing really new in this book, but it's a good read. While it starts out SF, it shifts heavily into seeming fantasy by the end. I personally will not be going on to following books because of the sudden and unsubstantiated ending. A less demanding reader, or one more excited about military stories might find this worth checking out.

wow

Somewhat reminiscent of Enemy Mine, this first book was a fast paced, fun read. If you like your sci-fi to have aliens, fighting, and a lone human trapped in the middle of it all, you've come to the right place.