Dietrich Bonhoeffer
Ratings2
Average rating4.3
Summary: Despite its age, this is still one of the best biographies of Dietrich Bonhoeffer. Bethge was one of Bonhoeffer's students at Finkenwalde, and became his closest friend and he was the one responsible for compiling Letters and Papers from Prison, the book that made Bonhoeffer a widely known theologian.
It took me almost two months to finish, but Eberhard Bethge's biography of Dietrich Bonhoeffer, despite being over 50 years old, is still well worth reading. I read the first edition, published in English in 1970 because that was the edition my library had. But I would recommend picking up the 2000 edition from Fortress Press because the first edition was slightly abridged at only 867 pages, compared to 1068 pages in the revised edition.
If you are new to Bonhoeffer, I think Charles Marsh's biography is the best introduction, but Bethge's is the most complete. That makes sense because it is the longest by quite a bit. Marsh's biography is 528 pages, Metaxes biography (which I do not recommend) is 640 pages, Schlingensiepen's biography is 470. It isn't just that this biography is longer, although that is part of it, but this biography is just more comprehensive of areas that the others just do not get to.
Bethge was friend and student of Bonhoeffer's. He was conscripted into the German army for a time, and later was also imprisoned because of his connection to the Bonhoeffer family. (He married Bonhoeffer's niece and her father was part of the resistance movement that Bonhoeffer was also connected to.) I think that Marsh handle's Bonhoeffer's childhood and early development better than Bethge, but especially from 1932 on, Bethge is much more detailed, and much more focused on the way that German church's response to Hitler influenced Bonhoeffer's life. Other biographies hit the major developments and life events, but Bethge talks about ways church politics and especially the politics of the global ecumenical movement worked in a level of detail and nuance that was helpful to me to understand the particulars. But I also think that level of detail is probably too much for those who are new to Bonhoeffer.
My rough evaluation of a biography is that if a biography makes me want to read more by or about a figure, then it is doing its job. After finishing Bethge's biography, I am going to read a biography of Bethge and a biography of Bishop Bell that I have. I also want to read the complete Letters and Papers from Prison. I have read portions, but not all. And the edition that I have is 614 pages compared to the earlier editions that were around 400 pages. There is the Bonhoeffer's Works edition that is 776 pages as well.
Part of what inspired me to pick up Bethge's biography now is reading Mark Nation's book on the legacy of Bonhoeffer. Nation believes that Bethge got some aspect of Bonhoeffer wrong, especially the way that Bethge frames the theological changes over time and his perspectives on pacifism. Having read Bethge after Nation, I think Nation has a point. Bethge was writing about Bonhoeffer at a time when even though there was a condemnation of Hitler and Nazism, there was still come resistance to seeing the resistance movement as an appropriate response. Nation suggests that Bonhoeffer continued to be a pacifist and wasn't involved in the actual plots to kill Hitler, only the efforts to communicate to the outside world that there was a movement to remove Hitler. I think Nation has a point, but I am not sure that the evidence is strong enough to make that point too strongly. I think Bethge does show that the initial resistance movement was attempting to stage a coupe and arrest Hitler for various human rights violations and war crimes. But once the senior military leaders who were involve in the resistance movement were removed from their positions, that option was lost. A coupe was no longer possible and assassination was the only option. I have not read Bonhoeffer the Assassin? which directly addresses this point and it is edited by Mark Nation, but it is an earlier book to Discipleship in a World Full of Nazi's so I am not sure that there will be more evidence there.
I do think that Nation is right that the main reason Bonhoeffer was arrested was because of his use of his role in the Abwehr as a means of avoiding conscription. Being a pacifist and/or refusing to fight was punished by death. As a secondary offense, Bonhoeffer helped to get some Jewish people out of Germany, which was really the excuse used by take down Admiral Canaris, the head of Abwehr as a separate military intelligence agency and to subsume it into the SS intelligence agency. Bonhoeffer was a minor figure in that, but after the discovery of several diaries that recorded – in great detail, and in Admiral Canaris’ handwriting – the activities of the anti-Nazi movement since the 1930s, Canaris, Bonhoeffer, several other members of Bonhoeffer's family and many others were executed just before the end of the war. Bethge and Nation have the same basic facts but they understand some of those facts differently. That is in part why reading multiple biographies matters because there are often different ways to evaluate what is known, especially in cases like Bonhoeffer where there is controversy.
One of the biggest weaknesses of Metaxes's biography was his lack of understanding of Germany's political and church politics. Bethge was not an outsider. He was intimately involved and has that level of detail and understanding matters to understanding the context of why Bonhoeffer continues to be an interesting and important figure today. Books like Haynes' Battle for Bonhoeffer are helpful to look at how Bonhoeffer has been misused, but reading the original biographies not just the evaluation of those biographies, is really helpful.
I also agree with Reggie William's contention in Bonhoeffer's Black Jesus, that Bethge and most other biographers do not adequately address how Bonhoeffer's theology and ecclesiology were influenced by his time in Harlem. So even at over 1000 pages, there are areas where I think this biography could be expanded. I have been listening to Homebrewed Christinaity's Rise of Bonhoeffer podcast documentary and one of the interviews mentioned that there was interest in another revision of Bethge's biography to add in details that have been discovered in the years since Bethge's death. That project did not happen, but there are holes here.
The revised version of Bethge's biography is only available in paperback. And it is expensive, $80 from the publisher and over $50 from most booksellers. There is no ebook or audiobook versions. And even at that high price, multiple book sellers I looked at did not have it available to order.
This was originally posted on my blog at https://bookwi.se/dietrich-bonhoeffer/
Originally posted at bookwi.se.
Summary: Despite its age, this is still one of the best biographies of Dietrich Bonhoeffer. Bethge was one of Bonhoeffer's students at Finkenwalde, and became his closest friend and he was the one responsible for compiling Letters and Papers from Prison, the book that made Bonhoeffer a widely known theologian.
It took me almost two months to finish, but Eberhard Bethge's biography of Dietrich Bonhoeffer, despite being over 50 years old, is still well worth reading. I read the first edition, published in English in 1970 because that was the edition my library had. But I would recommend picking up the 2000 edition from Fortress Press because the first edition was slightly abridged at only 867 pages, compared to 1068 pages in the revised edition.
If you are new to Bonhoeffer, I think Charles Marsh's biography is the best introduction, but Bethge's is the most complete. That makes sense because it is the longest by quite a bit. Marsh's biography is 528 pages, Metaxes biography (which I do not recommend) is 640 pages, Schlingensiepen's biography is 470. It isn't just that this biography is longer, although that is part of it, but this biography is just more comprehensive of areas that the others just do not get to.
Bethge was friend and student of Bonhoeffer's. He was conscripted into the German army for a time, and later was also imprisoned because of his connection to the Bonhoeffer family. (He married Bonhoeffer's niece and her father was part of the resistance movement that Bonhoeffer was also connected to.) I think that Marsh handle's Bonhoeffer's childhood and early development better than Bethge, but especially from 1932 on, Bethge is much more detailed, and much more focused on the way that German church's response to Hitler influenced Bonhoeffer's life. Other biographies hit the major developments and life events, but Bethge talks about ways church politics and especially the politics of the global ecumenical movement worked in a level of detail and nuance that was helpful to me to understand the particulars. But I also think that level of detail is probably too much for those who are new to Bonhoeffer.
My rough evaluation of a biography is that if a biography makes me want to read more by or about a figure, then it is doing its job. After finishing Bethge's biography, I am going to read a biography of Bethge and a biography of Bishop Bell that I have. I also want to read the complete Letters and Papers from Prison. I have read portions, but not all. And the edition that I have is 614 pages compared to the earlier editions that were around 400 pages. There is the Bonhoeffer's Works edition that is 776 pages as well.
Part of what inspired me to pick up Bethge's biography now is reading Mark Nation's book on the legacy of Bonhoeffer. Nation believes that Bethge got some aspect of Bonhoeffer wrong, especially the way that Bethge frames the theological changes over time and his perspectives on pacifism. Having read Bethge after Nation, I think Nation has a point. Bethge was writing about Bonhoeffer at a time when even though there was a condemnation of Hitler and Nazism, there was still come resistance to seeing the resistance movement as an appropriate response. Nation suggests that Bonhoeffer continued to be a pacifist and wasn't involved in the actual plots to kill Hitler, only the efforts to communicate to the outside world that there was a movement to remove Hitler. I think Nation has a point, but I am not sure that the evidence is strong enough to make that point too strongly. I think Bethge does show that the initial resistance movement was attempting to stage a coupe and arrest Hitler for various human rights violations and war crimes. But once the senior military leaders who were involve in the resistance movement were removed from their positions, that option was lost. A coupe was no longer possible and assassination was the only option. I have not read Bonhoeffer the Assassin? which directly addresses this point and it is edited by Mark Nation, but it is an earlier book to Discipleship in a World Full of Nazi's so I am not sure that there will be more evidence there.
I do think that Nation is right that the main reason Bonhoeffer was arrested was because of his use of his role in the Abwehr as a means of avoiding conscription. Being a pacifist and/or refusing to fight was punished by death. As a secondary offense, Bonhoeffer helped to get some Jewish people out of Germany, which was really the excuse used by take down Admiral Canaris, the head of Abwehr as a separate military intelligence agency and to subsume it into the SS intelligence agency. Bonhoeffer was a minor figure in that, but after the discovery of several diaries that recorded – in great detail, and in Admiral Canaris’ handwriting – the activities of the anti-Nazi movement since the 1930s, Canaris, Bonhoeffer, several other members of Bonhoeffer's family and many others were executed just before the end of the war. Bethge and Nation have the same basic facts but they understand some of those facts differently. That is in part why reading multiple biographies matters because there are often different ways to evaluate what is known, especially in cases like Bonhoeffer where there is controversy.
One of the biggest weaknesses of Metaxes's biography was his lack of understanding of Germany's political and church politics. Bethge was not an outsider. He was intimately involved and has that level of detail and understanding matters to understanding the context of why Bonhoeffer continues to be an interesting and important figure today. Books like Haynes' Battle for Bonhoeffer are helpful to look at how Bonhoeffer has been misused, but reading the original biographies not just the evaluation of those biographies, is really helpful.
I also agree with Reggie William's contention in Bonhoeffer's Black Jesus, that Bethge and most other biographers do not adequately address how Bonhoeffer's theology and ecclesiology were influenced by his time in Harlem. So even at over 1000 pages, there are areas where I think this biography could be expanded. I have been listening to Homebrewed Christinaity's Rise of Bonhoeffer podcast documentary and one of the interviews mentioned that there was interest in another revision of Bethge's biography to add in details that have been discovered in the years since Bethge's death. That project did not happen, but there are holes here.
The revised version of Bethge's biography is only available in paperback. And it is expensive, $80 from the publisher and over $50 from most booksellers. There is no ebook or audiobook versions. And even at that high price, multiple book sellers I looked at did not have it available to order.
This was originally posted on my blog at https://bookwi.se/dietrich-bonhoeffer/
Originally posted at bookwi.se.