Borderline

This was surprisingly fascinating for a book with such a harsh, flawed main character who knows herself. It's dark and witty, and the Arcadia Project's reason for seeking out the mentally ill to recruit is super troubling, but I'll likely read the next book.

I hadn't dealt with anyone with BPD in rl until recently so the running internal explanations of how she reacts to something, and trying to remember and apply therapy, was pretty interesting. (Would have been nice if the rl acquaintances had tried even half as hard.) Millie isn't her illness, she's human, and the book makes that clear - which is tough to do well.

Dfn at 50%

The idea is interesting and I wanted to read this both because of the amputee representation and the borderline representation, but this fell apart. The characters are poorly constructed and they act without any rhyme or reason, they're a very unlikeable bunch, and there's so much casual racism in this that I have no idea how this was a nebula winner.

I LOVED this book. It had me hooked from the beginning (and from the font haha). I didn't expect the mix of mental health and fairies. This book was definitely written for me and people like me. I really related to the main character for better and for worse. Wonderful book.

First surprise: Our heroine was a personality disorder and physical disability. Talk about under-represented groups in fantasy. The story fine urban fantasy with fey and magic, but I think the portrayal of an unusual heroine is what impressed me the most.

It's fairy noir and our hard-bitten detective protagonist is mentally struggling double amputee who lost both her legs after an attempted suicide dive from seven stories up. There's lots of work throughout the book devoted to wrangling with her prosthetics, the perils of staircases, concerns over her stumps getting infected, and struggling to get out of various chairs not to mention the varied mental gymnastics she needs to perform to get through the day struggling with Borderline Personality Disorder. Honestly it's a refreshing take but it can be a bit much. To her credit, Baker handles misfits well and avoids overly sentimentalizing them. Millie Roper is a broken badass taking it one day at a time instead of a handi-capable, crime-solving inspiration - which is a good thing.

In the meantime she's been recruited to a secret agency peopled with mental outpatients tasked with managing traffic between the fairy world and ours. It's MIB Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. I enjoyed the magic systems and the slow reveal of the integration between the two realms. This is some serious world building that begs for a series of books and reads like a TV series.

4.5 rounded up. Loved the lesson on Borderline without being schooled. Mixed well with the overall fey magical story.

I feel a little unsure about Borderline. There's a pretty standard urban fantasy plot, centered around an unapologetically, no-holds-barred borderline personality disordered protagonist. And I felt towards it the way that years of being in the medical profession has drilled me to react to borderline personality disorder: man, it's kind of fascinating, but best observed at arm's length. The portrayal of borderline personality disorder is eerily accurate, but also extremely sympathetic. The book has received much accolades on its portrayal of BPD, and I think a lot of that is deserved: this is clearly the best portrayal of BPD in the literature, one of the few protagonists I know of with BPD and its take is quite nuanced. However, at some point, I also felt like Millie got too much of a narrative pass for her behavior and it was pretty clear to me from the writing that the author herself had BPD (indeed, she does.) The way that this is clearest to me is that there's a sense when you're around someone with BPD that their behavior and actions are amped up to a hundred to the point that no one around them has any space, and the book completely treats Millie that way – all of the other characters are flat and under detailed. Even the plot grinds to a halt to serve Millie's internal churning. Perhaps that's part of the realistic portrayal, but it's kind of off-putting as a reader. What redeems the book for me is Baker's portrayal of Millie's inner self, her suffering and her (meager) attempts at getting better.

Overall, I found this book a fascinating insider's view on borderline personality disorder, but kind of flawed as a novel.

I'm not into Fantasy. Nor do I go for investigative mysteries. And I generally don't care much for series. So it's probably a bit of a surprise for everyone that I'd pick up a novel that has every bit of these traits. There are two reasons I did so. One, I want to venture into new reading grounds. I figured that with this wonderful cover and description, Borderline held more promise than most books in the genre. Two, as someone diagnosed with Borderline Personality Disorder, I take a particular interest in books that tackle the subject. Here, our protagonist, Millie, suffers from BPD. My curiosity was piqued.

As a complete novel, Borderline did not impress me as much as my four stars may imply. I didn't buy into Millie or her diagnosis. At the novel's opening, she is under psychiatric watch after a botched suicide attempt—not the kind of safe and careful suicide attempts that characterize much of a Borderline's life, but the final “I truly do not care anymore” attempt. We're to believe Millie has hit rock bottom. By the end of this novel, I would celebrate if Millie had done no more than drag herself out of bed and make her own breakfast. That would certainly be more believable. While I'd like that story, the average genre reader probably wouldn't. Instead, Millie picks up the pieces rather quickly—broken pieces, yes, but she gathers them nonetheless—and begins a journey of self-discovery and supernatural crime fighting.

Maybe this novel and the resulting series of books is really an allegory for the mental health journey. Maybe it's not expected to be realistic—it is Fantasy, after all. But I personally would've been in Millie's corner much more if she'd resembled a person living with BPD, not just a normal person who battles with BPD symptoms when it's convenient to the plot. And I think this is true of all the characters. I liked many of the characters and Baker does a fabulous job of creating a memorable and interesting cast. But these are people who are supposedly some of the craziest, yet they can function and most often do. In this story, I wanted to see paranormal detectives who struggled with the decision of “do I stop evil from infesting the world” or “do I pull the covers back over my head and hope my death is as pathetic as I am”?

Obviously, I had my personal qualms, but as far as Mystery-Fantasy hybrid series go, this was fairly entertaining. Now, I'd originally intended to read the whole series, but I just wasn't that into this first installment, so I don't think I will. It's just not my thing and there are so many other books I'd rather spend my days with. But as a non-reader of the style, I must say that while I didn't enjoy this book as it was intended, I also didn't dislike it. And strong dislike is my normal response to stories that start throwing around magical incantations and fairies and what not.

So my four star rating does not mean “Borderline was as wonderful as the last Toni Morrison novel I read.” There's no comparison. But it is meant to show that it is a pretty good novel for its style. With a little better characterization and some toning down of the action, I might've not stopped at four stars, but I don't want the reader of this review to think I'm growing too soft. If you're into Fantasy Mysteries, I think this is a great choice, but clearly I'm no expert.

Clearly it's a dark story from the get-go. The title Borderline refers to both the protagonist's own Borderline Personality Disorder, and the boundary between our world and Arcadia - the Fairyland of myths and legends. When we first meet Millie she's in a mental institution, trying to come to grips with her illness and her two new prosthetic legs - and failing. We don't learn much about her from the get-go, her backstory is slowly and painfully revealed through the novel. What we do learn is that she's stronger than she thinks she is, more broken than she realises, and extremely suitable for a very specific sort of job.She's recruited for a secret project liaising with Arcadia, where the Fae originate. A select few have come over here, and the twist is that the majority are Hollywood stars - either actors or directors. Each of the Fae has an Echo - the human who in other situations might be considered a Soulmate. For actors they tend to be their agent, or producer, but the book at least drops a few hints that everyone has an Echo, and that they're incomplete in some way without them.The Arcadia Project itself is not quite the ‘Men In Black' organisation you might expect from books of this type. For one reason or another the mentally ill are remarkably well suited to this line of work, and so Millie is thrown into a supremely dysfunctional shared house full of people with greater or lesser problems than her own.So if you're looking for a light-hearted romp through a world where Steven Spielberg is secretly a Wizard, and every other great director has a Fae Echo as their muse, this isn't necessarily the book for you. But that being said, it's not depressing in the least. While the majority of the characters we meet are struggling, and there is murder and mayhem surrounding them on all sides, this is not a book you need to approach carefully. It's a damn good read, the characters are extremely well-rounded and elicit sympathy as quickly as they push each other away. Mental illness is a very tricky subject to discuss at the best of times, and to take it as a defining characteristic of your cast is risky - but Baker does it in such a way that the people we meet are far from two-dimensional, never cliched. You feel that they are real people, with real problems - maybe deeper-seated than most of us but they're still very much human; this is especially true when compared to the Fae who on the surface are attractive, enthralling and seemingly perfect, but operate on a completely different moral plane.So yes, I have reviewed another book which deals with mental illness (see also [b:The Calculating Stars 33080122 The Calculating Stars (Lady Astronaut, #1) Mary Robinette Kowal https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1539850192l/33080122.SY75.jpg 53735352] which again is not preachy and takes the illness as just another facet of the character which shapes their decisions and destiny. Which if you ask me is exactly how it should be - it's not a bit of colour to throw at a person to make them ‘edgy' or ‘interesting', it's a part of the human experience and it's refreshing to see it handled so well.

I absolutely loved this!

Everything about it. I loved it from the first to the last page.

Not my usual genre or type of book, but I dug it quite a bit. I'd come back to the series and check up on the characters that I really did grow pretty attached to in future installments.

I saw this at work and I was intrigued by how weird but cool it sounded. I'd never really seen a book that combined urban fantasy, mystery, and mental illness before. I loved the author's commentary and insight on mental illness, it was really great to read a novel with a POV protagonist who has a severe mental illness and seeing her cope with it and explain it like a physical illness rather than something sappy and emotional. This is the way that mental illness should be portrayed more – it's honest and a genuine look at how mental illness isn't something a person can help. I was so happy with that aspect of this and I would definitely read more of this series if there is a sequel.

In the Philippines, we grow up hearing tales of the supernatural - and not in the same way as our Western counterparts. Oh, to be sure, we grow up hearing all the same fairytales and watching all the same Disney movies as Western children do, but alongside those stories, we hear stories of another sort. These are the stories we hear from our grandparents (if we are lucky enough to have them nearby), or from our nannies or other members of the household help (for those who are lucky to have them). Sometimes we hear them from our aunts or uncles, or from playmates and classmates who, in their turn, heard them from other people in their lives. It is from these stories that we learn to be cautious of balete trees (genus Ficus), and to say ???Tabi-tabi po??? (translated: ???Please step aside???) when passing by a termite mound or crossing a grassy field. It is from these stories that we learn to turn our shirts inside-out if we get lost, and to walk faster if we hear a crying baby while out and about alone at night. Incidentally, these beliefs do not in any way conflict with the prevailing Christian practice in the country; instead, they cohabit quite comfortably, side-by-side, in the Filipino mindset.

Things are different in the West. If one professes a belief in, say, fairies beyond a certain age, one is bound to be considered ???crazy???, with subsequent reactions depending upon whether or not that ???craziness??? is viewed with tolerable fondness or otherwise. This is not to say that belief in the supernatural is considered acceptable by all people in the Philippines, but the acceptability of such beliefs depends more upon class and social status (i.e. such beliefs are considered more ???prevalent??? in people who are from more rural areas and/or belong to a lower socio-economic class, but supposedly less so in the urbanised, Western-thinking upper class) than on a person???s mental state. In the Philippines, belief in the supernatural is considered a symptom of inadequate education and/or poor socio-economic standing; in the West, it is generally considered a reflection of a person???s mental state.

One of the things that makes Mishell Baker???s Borderline so fascinating is the play between mental states and the supernatural. It begins with the main character, Millicent ???Millie??? Roper, being invited by one Caryl Vallo to join the mysterious Arcadia Project. However, Millie isn???t what most people would consider ???normal???: after all, Caryl meets her at the Leishman Psychiatric Center, where Millie has been living for the last six months because of her attempted suicide - an attempt that might have left Millie with her life, but without both her legs. Millie also has borderline personality disorder, or BPD: a mental illness that is difficult to manage and difficult to live with. Despite all of this, though, Caryl convinces Millie that she should at least try to work with the Arcadia Project, and Millie decides to give it a shot. As it turns out, however, the Arcadia Project is not quite what it seems to be, and Millie walks right into a situation that might shatter a fragile peace, and begin an otherworldly war.

One of the things that makes this novel stand out from the many other urban fantasy novels is the way Baker has chosen to characterise Millie, and many of the other characters involved in the Arcadia Project. Keeping the supernatural a secret from the rest of the mundane world is practically a trope of urban fantasy, but the main characters of those books can still function in the mundane world without being made into pariahs for their belief in the supernatural. These characters, therefore, never have to fear being called ???crazy??? as long as their secrets remain secret; any difficulties they encounter tend to come from putting themselves between the mundane and supernatural worlds in the name of that secrecy.

Millie, however, is different. Her BPD means that living a normal life is difficult, as she points out throughout the novel. Take this excerpt, for example:

One of the fun bits about BPD is a phenomenon shrinks like to call ???splitting.??? When under stress, Borderlines forgets the existence of gray. Life is a beautiful miracle, or a cesspool of despair. The film you???re making is a Best Picture candidate, or it???s garbage. People are either saints, or they???re scheming to destroy you.

Or this:

When you???re Borderline and want to survive, you learn to shrink from guilt, because it can spiral out of control and leave you staring down a bottomless void. People throw around the term ???self-loathing??? without really knowing what it means. I wouldn???t wish it on my worst enemy.

Or this:

Borderlines are not good at patiently earning things; we tend to take ???no??? as a personal insult and feel driven to turn it into a ???yes??? on the spot.

There are several more of these explanations about what it is like to live with BPD, and it is made quite clear to the reader that even Millie herself has a hard time managing it. And yet, despite this, when she is thrown headlong into an assignment for the Arcadia Project, with very little explanation about what is going on and what she can and cannot do, she still manages to handle the situation with some aplomb. A part of it can be attributed to BPD:

But that???s a weird side effect of BPD; your perfection of truth shifts so often in the normal course of daily life that crazy talk doesn???t automatically trigger your bullshit reflex.

This ability to keep her ???bullshit reflex??? from going off proves crucial to Millie???s ability to think through some otherwise absurd situations - and is, therefore, crucial to being able to work in the Arcadia Project at all:

I stared at the shimmering swirls on the paper; they moved as though they were alive. I???d misplaced the speech center of my brain again. When I found it, I said a little drunkenly, ???What kind of glasses are these???????It???s like an advanced version of the fairy ointment from the stories,??? he said. ???One side of the lens shows you what kind of magic a thing has; the other side shows you things as they really are.???I waited for my rational mind to put up a fight, but it rolled over and showed its belly.

This characterisation stands in direct contrast to the way other urban fantasy protagonists are portrayed, many of whom are either aware from childhood that the supernatural exists (and why it needs to be kept secret), or learn about it but manage to accept its existence with an admirable (and in some cases slightly unrealistic) calm. Millie???s BPD is far from glamorous, and Baker does not ever once portray it as such, but it does offer a plausible explanation as to why she can so readily roll with the punches thrown at her worldview throughout the novel.

Another thing about the way Millie has been characterised is that she does not use her mental illness as an excuse when she???s behaved poorly. While she often acknowledges that her BPD can and often does lead her to do and say very ill-considered things, she does not use it to excuse any poor behaviour on her part. Though she has a hard time apologising (partly because of who she is, and partly because of her BPD), she does acknowledge it when she realises that she has done something wrong (even if it takes her a while to do so), and tries her best to make amends. I personally find this very refreshing, having had to deal with a former friend who used her own mental issues (not BPD, as far as I know) to excuse hurtful behaviour, and I am glad Baker has been careful to depict this particular line between what the mentally ill do because they???re sick, and what they do because they are who they are.

What makes Millie stand out even more as a character and narrator is the world she inhabits, and the story that plays out. Like many urban fantasy worlds, there is nothing significantly different between the reader???s reality and the reality in the book, save for the addition of supernatural elements; the plot is also quite similar to other plots in other urban fantasy novels. This means, therefore, that Borderline is similar to many other urban fantasy novels out there. However, that works to the advantage of character-building: since the overall set dressing and plot isn???t really all that different from many other novels in the same genre, the reader can focus on reading how the characters grow and develop. This is a novel that is very much driven by its protagonist, after all, and though Baker does bring the setting of Hollywood to life, in all its contrasts, contradictions, and neuroses, the focus remains on Millie, and how she sees the world, what she thinks of it, and how she grows into the character she is at the end of the novel.

Aiding all of this is Baker???s writing. I enjoy characters that have distinctive voices, especially when they are the ones narrating the story, and there is no denying that Millie is definitely one of those characters. Take this excerpt, for example:

At eighteen, I drove two thousand miles west toward the siren call of Hollywood, hoping it would drown out the cruel voice in my head that I thought was my father???s. By the time I found out that the cruel voice in my head was my own, my father was two years dead and I???d already let the voice talk me off the roof of Hendrick Hall. Whoops,

There is a hard-bitten edge to Millie???s narrative voice, and a touch of sarcasm that I find enjoyable to read. To be sure, there are many other urban fantasy protagonists that try to come off just as hard-bitten and sarcastic, but very few of them make it come off as naturally, as believably, as Millie. Again, I attribute this to Baker???s skill as a writer, that she can make a character???s personality come through so well in the written word. Indeed, it makes me wonder if there is an audiobook of this book already out, because I think it would be interesting to actually hear Millie???s story, told in her ???own??? voice by an expert narrator.

Overall, Borderline is one of those novels that definitely lives up to the hype surrounding it. Millie is an interesting and atypical urban fantasy protagonist, who portrays what it is like to live with disability and mental illness in a way that I think is respectful to those who must deal with such conditions in their own daily lives. Even better, Baker does not glamourise or victimise Millie???s problems, showing instead how they can be both help and hindrance in a world where the supernatural exists, but needs to be kept as secret as possible. I now look forward to reading the next book, which, in my opinion, cannot come soon enough.

This would be a five-star book (I devoured it in less than a day, staying up until 2am to finish) except the treatment of mental illness bugged me a LOT.

There is no such thing as “Borderlines”– people with BPD have a range of symptoms and the narrative treats it like a monolithic experience that is Special and Unique. This wouldn't have been a problem if there had been other perspectives on mental illness (the consistent judgement of therapy and therapists as “mediocre” bugs me hugely as a mentally ill person who has found therapy exceedingly helpful). I hope this will be remedied in the next books– which I fully intend to read– but in THIS book, it's hard to escape the assumption that people with mental illness (or at least BPD) are some sort of weird monolith who all have the same symptoms with the same severity.

Also, the treatment of Gloria is super super shitty, yo.

Pros: fascinating protagonist, thought-provoking, interesting mystery

Cons:

Millicent Roper, director and UCLA student, is in an institute for borderline personality disorder and an attempted suicide that left her with two prosthetic limbs and a lot of physical and emotional scars. When Caryl Vallo approaches her with a job offer, she's intrigued by the secrecy surrounding it. The Arcadia Project regulates travel between our world and Arcadia, and one of their nobles hasn't returned as scheduled.

I picked this book up because the protagonist has several physical and mental disabilities. I kept reading because the writing is so damn good.

I was a little afraid that I wouldn't like the protagonist, as she's introduced as bitter and sarcastic. But as the story's told from her point of view, the reader's included in her thought process - why she acts the way she acts, and therefore gets to see the disconnect between her thoughts and feelings and her actions. In other words, she's not a particularly nice person from the outside, but from the inside you really sympathize with her. Much of the division between what she feels vs what she does comes from her borderline personality disorder, but there's also an element of ‘I've been hurt before so I'll keep others away so I can't be hurt again'.

I'm not qualified to judge the accuracy of Baker's depictions of prosthetics, wheelchair use, and mental disorders, so I'd be interested in hearing from those who are. It was wonderful to see a protagonist deal with physical and mental disabilities - especially referencing the psychiatric treatments that help her deal with the borderline personality disorder.

The book is interesting because Millie works with several other damaged people, who aren't very polite towards her but are likely just as sympathetic, if you saw inside them. It's understood that they've all got issues of some sort - like Millie, but she's not always told what their issues are. On the one hand, I understood that as a privacy issue it should be left to the individual to decide if they want to tell their story. On the other hand, I suspect some of the personality clashes in the book could have been resolved if everyone understood what everyone else is going through / what their diagnoses are - so they could avoid triggering negative reactions in each other.

One of my favourite things in the book was the calling out of unintentional/unconscious insults/racism. These include things she does and things she notices others doing to her.

You're slowly introduced to what the Arcadia Project does and it's quite interesting. The world expands a little at a time with each revelation to Millie about what's really going on. And she's a very clever protagonist, seeing minor clues and putting things together in ways I didn't catch. The mystery was really interesting, with several twists I didn't see coming. The world is soundly built, with rules - quite specific ones - and lots of room to expand.

This is an excellent urban fantasy novel that doesn't follow the trends. There's no romance, no ass kicking, just damaged people trying to get by in a damaged world.