As Good As Dead
Ratings302
Average rating4
4.5/5
I knew I was never mentally ready coming into this. But still, who would've thought that I'll be up all night - flying through the pages like my life depended on it?
This book legit had some moments that creeped the beejezus out of me. There were moments when I was clutching my pillow, staring into my Kindle, like it could save me from the words on the page. Holly Jackson doesn't pull any punches with the creep factor!
And then there's Pip. She's not playing games anymore. She really said “I AM THE FUCKING LAW” and it's a wild ride to see her teeter on the edge of reason. This book makes you want to join Pip in her crusade against the messed up justice system.
Now, the ending. GODDAMIT. What kind of sadist would put a cliffhanger on the final book? That had me staring blankly at the wall, just processing, until my brain went offline.
Bottomline: As Good As Dead takes the cake for a heart-stopping, jaw-dropping finale. Holly Jackson I love you!
Better than the second but not entirely happy with the choices made by the main characters
Been sitting on this review for a few days and I can conclusively say; this was my favourite book of the entire series! The twist halfway through got me so good and honestly Pip did what needed be done, slay girl
“As Good As Dead” by Holly Jackson concludes the series with unexpected twists that kept me hooked. Initially unsure of the direction in the beginning of the third book, the moment Pip realizes she has a stalker becomes a riveting turning point, making it impossible to put the book down.
The justice served in the story felt satisfying, a stark contrast to the shortcomings often seen in the real world. Pip, with her intelligence and courage, emerges as a likable and admirable character. Sweet Ravi adds charm to their dynamic duo, and their teamwork is truly enjoyable. The theme of friendships and found family throughout the series is heartwarming and adds depth to the narrative.
The ending, while confusing, doesn't diminish the overall enjoyment. The decision to cut everyone out of Pip's life felt unnecessary given the lack of evidence against her. Regardless, the book is a compelling read, and the series as a whole is a testament to Jackson's storytelling prowess. I look forward to Holly Jackson's future projects.
20/01/24 reread:
that last page still making me suicidal
(also the amount of ppl shocked over how this book went makes me laugh so bad bc how did a ya series go over your head that bad lmao)
This was so different than the other two, but I had a great time listening to this. Or maybe a great time isn't the right word. This was darker, scarier, and more unhinged than the past two. This was a great finale to the series. Solid. I listened to all of them as audiobooks and I'm so glad I did. The podcast experience came to live through this format.
PS: The ending made me scream! iykyk
rounded off from 3.5
This book Knive's Outs at 50% mark, and I lowkey enjoyed it. Compared to the other two in this trilogy, the plot struggled for the first 30%. Pip's character felt too unbearable in parts, and the story felt all over the place. The whole “full-circle” theme started piecing together 60% onwards and ended in a satisfactory way. I am glad I pushed through and finished what i started a very long long time ago. I still don't think Pip's action and personality align in this whole book. The person she was last two books and this one just doesn't make sense. And her “penance” did not match the crime iykyk.
Estoy muy triste porque oficialmente he acabado la trilogía Asesinato para principiantes. Este libro me ha encantado, no me esperaba ese cambio de trama tan heavy que tiene hacia la mitad del libro, pero lo he disfrutado igual. Que ganas de que salga la adaptación la verdad.
this book gave me what ive been looking for!!!! trauma actually affecting the mc and losing their minds after shit goes down!! ugh so good
So I just wanna say that this book was not amazing. The second book is a gazillion times better. Honestly halfway through this book I found myself getting so bored. But i'm giving it 5 stars because I'm so connected to the characters and the series as a whole and I love them.
Was not expecting that too happen but I love it! Such a good series, highly recommend!
This book is more thriller, than mystery compared to the rest of the books in the series and definitely a different vibe. My heart hurt a lot more reading this one and it sucked reading about her addiction and I wish we got more clarity on that. Maybe I'm the only one who assumed addiction but I don't think we really got closure on her PTSD and what she's doing about that going forward or even if she is going to continue doing more podcasts.
I absolutely love all the characters in this book the side characters are fantastic, Ravi he's an absolute sweetheart, 10 out of 10 all the green flags 100% love him. And Pippa? What a personal journey. The last chapter, plus the what I consider epilogue had me tearing up. Seriously, The last page of the book is what made a tear fall for me
Asesinato para principiantes: Excelente.
Desaparición para expertos: Muy Bueno.
Venganza para víctimas; aceptable.
Was this book ghost written? These are not the same characters, the plot twist is predictable, the character morals shift with no notice. It's all awful and I'm angry
4.5 stars
I get why this is a controversial book, but it worked for me.
The darkness made sense considering everything Pip went through (and was still going through).
I loved this story, the over-the-top storyline, the emotions, the characters, and the mystery.
The mystery was easily guessed, but everything afterward made it worth it.
I'm obsessed with the last line! Loved it!
Wow! This was an intricately plotted trilogy finale - I don't think I can recall how many plot twists there were throughout the book and I only finished it less than an hour ago. I've never read a book where the author was able to successfully interweave the rest of their series into their concluding book and come to a satisfying and fulfilling conclusion - both in plot and characterisation.
Holly Jackson has really left us with a remarkable piece of work. Every event, character and detail that wasn't resolved in the previous books really tied together to not only contribute to the thrilling plot, but also reinforce the theme Jackson introduced in her second novel: that the truth isn't all black and white and it doesn't lie in the procedures that are considered right in the society (the law system etc.)
As someone who has recently read a lot of young adult crime novels, it was really a pleasant surprise to see that the author further characterised the protagonist: Pip, and through the use of repetition, was able to enhance the connection we had with Pip. Pip was no longer just the perfect A grade student using her knowledge to solve a case, the circumstances were now linked to her and the people around her. I have yet to to see a young adult crime author successfully explore the concept of trauma and overcoming such trauma. Jackson was able to subtly depict the changing character and mental state of Pip, interweaving this appropriately with the events and plot twists that occurred throughout the book.
I really enjoyed this book over the others in the trilogy, as the plot twists and action occurred from the start of the novel, even though it is the one with the largest number of pages. I was hooked from the beginning to the very end. Although, I must admit I was slightly disappointed of the absence of detection; this book basically became a sole thriller rather than an amateur sleuth mystery. However, regardless of the change of genre, it still served to be a captivating read.
Most book/series endings are often unfulfilling, incomplete and just poorly written. But this one was definitely a memorable and satisfying one.
Five stars for excellent plot, characterisation, writing and conclusion.
Ik vond dit het minst leuke boek van de 3 in de triologie. De eerste helft was echt mega goed en mega spannend. Toen we halverwege te weten kwamen hoe alles zat en wie degene was die pip aan het bedreigen was, was het heel erg goed. Toen pip daarna Jason vermoorde werd het voor mijn idee erg slecht. Ik denk dat het boek een betere wending had gekregen als pip was weggelopen en had geprobeerd Jason te ontmaskeren als DT-killer. Overall vond ik het daardoor een prima boek, vandaar de 3 sterren.
It was pretty good. I liked how it linked up with references from the first two books, and I liked how Pip's character continued to develop to depict her rage, sadness, numbness, fear, and loneliness. I think the pace was a little inconsistent - it got a little dry at times and then picked up again at others. I did really fall in love with Pip, Ravi, and Nat's characters. Overall, it was a good series and I think I would read it again.