Alpha and Omega

A quick and interesting read. Religious fantasy and not a very plausible “alternative history.”

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for my open and honest review.

If given unequivocal proof that god exists, what would happen to the world's religions?

That is the question that Turtledove asks in his newest alternate world science fiction novel called Alpha and Omega. Turtledove is famous for asking the big “What if's” in alternative history. Previous stories include a second civil war (How Few Remain), third world war (American Empire series), supervolcano (Eruption) plus many more. Turtledove is a highly prolific author.

Alpha and Omega sees ancient prophecy realized in Jerusalem. All prophetic triggers for the end of days. This proves that without a doubt that God is real. But the question becomes “whose god?” What should the followers of Christianity, Judaism or Islam expect from the realized prophecies?

This was a difficult read for me. The subject matter is interesting, alternative history can be engrossing especially when you are somewhat familiar with the subject matter. This might have been my issue with this book and why it did not resonate with me. I am not overly familiar with Judaic and Islamic traditions and history. I think had I been more familiar this would have been a more engrossing read. As it stood though, I found it very dry and difficult to get into. I attempted to finish this but I ended up DNF at 80%. I could not get into the story. I just did not care about the characters enough to be interested in their plight.

If you would like to see more of my reviews, please check out my website at https://beforewegoblog.com/

3 stars, Metaphorosis Reviews

Summary:
In the heart of the Holy Land, ancient prophecies begin to come true. But whose prophecies, exactly, and to whose benefit?

Review:
I enjoy Harry Turtledove's writing, though I'm not really a fan of the alternate history niche that he's claimed as his particular specialty. Here, he's strayed from the SFF field into what's more of a religion-heavy pop thriller with supernatural overtones. It's a quick, smooth read with strong characters, but it didn't win me over.

The book is largely set in Jerusalem, and Turtledove does what I imagine he thinks is a painstaking job of presenting all viewpoints fairly. Unfortunately, he doesn't really pull it off, and the Palestinians get short shrift, coming off as only slightly rounded villains. Most writers do worse, so I suppose we should be thankful that he tried at least, but that's faint praise. Gender issues don't always fare better, and while it's possible to attribute some of these to character viewpoint, the story would have been fine without them. There's also a tendency to believe that anyone who's served in the military (especially the Israeli military) is and always will be a noble killing machine. In short, while I don't know anything at all about Turtledove's politics, the book fits comfortably in moderate right of center perspective. There's nothing wrong with that per se, but because of nature of the book, the thin presentation of the Palestinian case undermines the entire thing.

The supernatural elements come up mostly toward the end. Most of the book is taken up with an examination of the characters and the political and theological questions they face. To Turtledove's credit, he faces the political questions head on (if not with perfect balance). That makes it all the more disappointing that he avoids all the theological questions he so carefully tees up. That the end of the book is a cop-out is putting it mildly. He brings us and his characters along with the promise of revelations to come, and then ... vanishes into the air. And even then, only the three main Abrahamic religions are addressed. Atheists, Hindus, etc. aren't involved.

It's a disappointing book. Turtledove introduces interesting, engaging characters, but then does little with them. While he tries for balance, he doesn't succeed. Where he raises interesting theological questions, he avoids them in the end. If you're already to the right on Middle East issues, this book will confirm your views, and you might enjoy it. I can't really recommend it to anyone else.

I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.