While in many ways, this book is the antithesis of Mistborn, it still feels so much like Mistborn in a way that I didn't realize I had missed from Sanderson's writing style. The stakes and story are just as epic with this being part of the Cosmere, but it feels much more self-contained. A really enjoyable read!
I wish I liked this more. The story is incredibly epic and there’s so many cool things going on, but there’s just something about the writing style that doesn’t quite click with me. I’m sure this is a 5-star book to many and I think it’s well worth a read, but I probably won’t be pursuing anything else from John Gwynne.
I don’t recall if the writing has always been like this and I’m just noticing it now or if something has shifted on the author’s side, but 90% of the world building and rules being offered as an aside rather than actually written into the story has gotten incredibly annoying. Combined with the current storyline now having taken two entire books and still not being complete, with the author even acknowledging how ridiculous that is in the intro, I’m just getting a little fed up. I’m still going to keep reading, but score would be way worse if it weren’t an interesting and fun read.
This series is truly a standout of the entire genre. Every book peels back the curtain just a little bit more and gives further insight into this insane world the author has created. The sheer amount going on raises questions of just how it’ll all eventually be tied up, but for now I’m just enjoying the ride.
This was good. Really good, even, but it just wasn’t what I wanted from the story. The book is heavily character-driven and damnit if I wasn’t waiting for the plot to happen the whole book. I think anyone who appreciates history and intrigue will really enjoy it, but just be aware of what you’re going into.
I don’t know if I’m misremembering the earlier books in this series or if they were the same and I just didn’t pick up on it, but the constant references, childish humor, and little “wink, wink, nudge, nudge” moments wore me down this time. I’ll probably keep reading the series because it feels almost complete, I feel dumber for having read this.
This is a nice, easy popcorn read and I loved it. If you’ve ever played any of the Doom games, you should know not to really expect anything too deep from these novels, but that’s ok. It doesn’t need to be anything more than it is. Would recommend to anyone wanting to just read something without needing to worry too much about complex situations or deep lore. What you see is what you get.
If you’ve never read Ender’s Game, I certainly wouldn’t recommend this be your first experience of the story, but it’s definitely a fun listen. All of the voices are nicely distinct so you know who’s talking and the background sounds really help with the ambiance. My only real complaint is that there were some jarring transitions. Overall, worth snagging if you’ve got nothing better to listen to and just want something relatively mindless.
Every book in this series is just such a fun treat. It’s got to be commended for having very few unnecessary plot points in a genre filled with meandering nonsense. I’ve definitely lost the thread of what makes sense when it comes to power scaling, but just a joy to read. Seems like the serious is drawing to an end and I really hope they stick the landing!
This book is needlessly long, spends way too much time on inane plot points, and is just generally drug out due to the way web serials work. That being said, it’s almost addicting to read. You’re always being drug forward and shown something new and crazy. I’ll keep reading every one until it’s all over. Truly a hallmark of the genre.
Much like the first book in this series, this is a masterclass in character work. You just feel so strongly for Fitz and Robin Hobb really draws you in with her narrative. The villains are eminently relatable to the point you’re seething right along with our protagonist. I can only hope this trilogy sticks the landing!