Glorious post apocalyptic optimism that is much better than The Road 

Mediocre, but I still have some fondness for it because nostalgia is one hell of a drug 

Kind of brilliant? The protagonist isn't a good person, but her actions are entirely believable because we're given her entire thought processes as she digs herself deeper and deeper into literary hell 

Really powerful, well researched nonfiction narrative, but the sections detailing sports legislation are so painfully dull 

A grandiose, cinematic, and ambitious graphic novel - perhaps it falters because of this ambition, but Jeph Loeb and Tim Sale gave it a good fucking shot 

I deeply respect this book and Le Guin but this book is a slog to get through 

Immersive, beautiful world and prose occasionally shattered by an incredibly overpowered main character who gets through every problem with his plot armor.

Concise, briskly paced, exciting narrative. It is absolutely a breath of fresh air reading this after The Stormlight Archive. 

Rather solid science fiction 

Supporting characters aren't quite as strong as the first two books

Fascinating character study thrown away for an average action climax

Rushed climax to a generic thriller 

Passable, forgettable sapphic romance. Would have a lower score because of the objectively awful main character, but I have a soft spot for LGBT romance.

This occasionally physically hurt to read. Any book that illicits such a visceral reaction from me will get my recommendation. Powerful memoir about abusive relationships and the impact it has on you.

Incredible second half, not so incredible first half. Still a very powerful work

Amazing concept; unimaginative, generic execution 

Abhorrent pacing, but the Kaladin chapters are absurdly good and elevate this novel into a worthy sequel 

Boring hetero romance with some lovely writing about yetis 

Too lost within its own pessimism to tell a good story

This would be critically and commercially panned if it was not part of the Cosmere. Dull, generic, unimaginative fantasy

A very strong work from Murakami marred by an absurd amount of incest. Despite incest related complications, Murakami still weaves a compelling narrative with some shockingly progressive views for his time.