Derek
What a great book - what a challenging, compelling read. Hilary Mantel's writing is nearly flawless. Sometimes I would just wander over the page appreciating how technically precise her phrasing and pacing is. Bring Up the Bodies, same as Wolf Hall, is a masterclass in execution.
Hilary Mantel also manages to bring real weight and humanity to her characters. They are emotional and funny and show a depth of understanding that feels real - these are people with full lives and not NPCs drafted to advance the plot. It is tough work to keep everyone straight - I didn't manage to do this all the time, I'm sure - but the world feels real and rich.
One thing I found less convincing is her insight into Cromwell's motivations. Sure he is sometimes motivated by revenge or spite or petty politics - but I wondered if Mantel too often gave him the benefit of the doubt. I need to finish the series to see how her positioning holds true. Obviously I am aware of some of the general history - but I think The Mirror and the Light will be revealing in how compassionately we should consider our friend Cromwell.
What a great book - what a challenging, compelling read. Hilary Mantel's writing is nearly flawless. Sometimes I would just wander over the page appreciating how technically precise her phrasing and pacing is. Bring Up the Bodies, same as Wolf Hall, is a masterclass in execution.
Hilary Mantel also manages to bring real weight and humanity to her characters. They are emotional and funny and show a depth of understanding that feels real - these are people with full lives and not NPCs drafted to advance the plot. It is tough work to keep everyone straight - I didn't manage to do this all the time, I'm sure - but the world feels real and rich.
One thing I found less convincing is her insight into Cromwell's motivations. Sure he is sometimes motivated by revenge or spite or petty politics - but I wondered if Mantel too often gave him the benefit of the doubt. I need to finish the series to see how her positioning holds true. Obviously I am aware of some of the general history - but I think The Mirror and the Light will be revealing in how compassionately we should consider our friend Cromwell.