Not over-the-top ridiculous and kept me guessing until the end. Holahan walked the fine line of making characters understandable and sometimes likeable, while giving everyone valid motives for murder. I'll definitely be reading more of her books in the future.

Contains spoilers

One of my all time favorites.

A decent enough mystery/thriller. I would have liked it if we'd been able to spend more time on the mystery of who is telling the truth and what is going on with the other guests. Personally I felt it was a bit over the top once the titular mystery was revealed. That being said, I did enjoy it.

This has been my favorite fantasy world since I first read it, and it stands up to rereads. 4.5 stars only because the latter two in the series are better.