Clara
vampires 🤝 female rage
A beautifully written gothic with some of my favourite things (vampires, sapphic relationships, beautiful people in old houses in scenic backdrops).
I only wished that Lenore spent more time taunting and wreaking havoc on Henry in the end. But still a satisfyingly violent and well-deserved end.
Loved this retelling of Carmilla and the clear nods to other works like Dracula. Keen to read other stories that inspired Kat Dunn, and come back to this with fresher eyes and a better appreciation of the story.
vampires 🤝 female rage
A beautifully written gothic with some of my favourite things (vampires, sapphic relationships, beautiful people in old houses in scenic backdrops).
I only wished that Lenore spent more time taunting and wreaking havoc on Henry in the end. But still a satisfyingly violent and well-deserved end.
Loved this retelling of Carmilla and the clear nods to other works like Dracula. Keen to read other stories that inspired Kat Dunn, and come back to this with fresher eyes and a better appreciation of the story.
vampires 🤝 female rage
A beautifully written gothic with some of my favourite things (vampires, sapphic relationships, beautiful people in old houses in scenic backdrops).
I only wished that Lenore spent more time taunting and wreaking havoc on Henry in the end. But still a satisfyingly violent and well-deserved end.
Loved this retelling of Carmilla and the clear nods to other works like Dracula. Keen to read other works that inspired Kat Dunn, and come back to this with fresher eyes and a better appreciation of the story.
vampires 🤝 female rage
A beautifully written gothic with some of my favourite things (vampires, sapphic relationships, beautiful people in old houses in scenic backdrops).
I only wished that Lenore spent more time taunting and wreaking havoc on Henry in the end. But still a satisfyingly violent and well-deserved end.
Loved this retelling of Carmilla and the clear nods to other works like Dracula. Keen to read other works that inspired Kat Dunn, and come back to this with fresher eyes and a better appreciation of the story.
This book is perfect and exactly what my heart needed.
This book is perfect and exactly what my heart needed.
Pros
- Filipino and bisexual representation—always here for it.
- Loved the female rage and the FMC protecting her people and home
- Clearly a lot of research went into building a world reflective of Spanish-era Philippines. I especially appreciated the blend of Catholicism with native Filipino religions, which have been so overshadowed and erased by colonisation. I didn’t care much for most of the characters, but I’ll always root for people (bonus if led by matriarchs) taking vengeance on their oppressors.
Cons
- The use of Filipino words and phrases often felt off. I kept wondering if the author actually spoke Tagalog or had lived in the Philippines—not because you have to, but this is where more research would’ve helped. ‘Tabi-tabi po’ to a bakunawa/dragon? Huh? And ‘giving’ someone a ‘Mano po’ felt so awkward. It started to feel like cultural appropriation—using Filipino language without context or accuracy to give ‘Filipino vibes’ that might seem authentic to outsiders but fall flat for actual Filipinos. It fell flat for me anyway.
- I forgot Dante Basco was the male narrator, so hearing Prince Zuko’s voice was a pleasant surprise—but ultimately not the best execution. His Tagalog pronunciation was rough, which really pulled me out of some scenes. Alon’s “Punong puno na ako sa’yo!” was a bit cringe. I wanted to laugh in this scene but all I could think of was Dante struggling with the line.
- Loved the bi rep in this (weak) love triangle, but hated how the female love interest Cat was written compared to the male MC Alon. Alon gets all the depth and character and I actually found myself giggling at scenes with him and Lunurin (PS. that name? Booo). Meanwhile, Cat is just a flat, abusive ex who creates drama and establishes Alon’s brand as hot gentle boyfriend. Of course I wanted to see her fall, but it would’ve hit harder if she were actually complex and not another caricature like the Lakan and the Spanish villains.
I respect that the book didn’t shy away from the brutal stuff that happens to Inez early on—a real reflection of the violence Filipinos endured. But I honestly thought this was YA because of the cover and the writing style (why so many all-caps and exclamation marks??), so those dark scenes felt jarring and a bit out of place.
I do appreciate this book’s premise and some of the world-building. A lot of my issues might just come down to this being a debut, and I’m hopeful the next one will build on what did work in this book.
Pros
- Filipino and bisexual representation—always here for it.
- Loved the female rage and the FMC protecting her people and home
- Clearly a lot of research went into building a world reflective of Spanish-era Philippines. I especially appreciated the blend of Catholicism with native Filipino religions, which have been so overshadowed and erased by colonisation. I didn’t care much for most of the characters, but I’ll always root for people (bonus if led by matriarchs) taking vengeance on their oppressors.
Cons
- The use of Filipino words and phrases often felt off. I kept wondering if the author actually spoke Tagalog or had lived in the Philippines—not because you have to, but this is where more research would’ve helped. ‘Tabi-tabi po’ to a bakunawa/dragon? Huh? And ‘giving’ someone a ‘Mano po’ felt so awkward. It started to feel like cultural appropriation—using Filipino language without context or accuracy to give ‘Filipino vibes’ that might seem authentic to outsiders but fall flat for actual Filipinos. It fell flat for me anyway.
- I forgot Dante Basco was the male narrator, so hearing Prince Zuko’s voice was a pleasant surprise—but ultimately not the best execution. His Tagalog pronunciation was rough, which really pulled me out of some scenes. Alon’s “Punong puno na ako sa’yo!” was a bit cringe. I wanted to laugh in this scene but all I could think of was Dante struggling with the line.
- Loved the bi rep in this (weak) love triangle, but hated how the female love interest Cat was written compared to the male MC Alon. Alon gets all the depth and character and I actually found myself giggling at scenes with him and Lunurin (PS. that name? Booo). Meanwhile, Cat is just a flat, abusive ex who creates drama and establishes Alon’s brand as hot gentle boyfriend. Of course I wanted to see her fall, but it would’ve hit harder if she were actually complex and not another caricature like the Lakan and the Spanish villains.
I respect that the book didn’t shy away from the brutal stuff that happens to Inez early on—a real reflection of the violence Filipinos endured. But I honestly thought this was YA because of the cover and the writing style (why so many all-caps and exclamation marks??), so those dark scenes felt jarring and a bit out of place.
I do appreciate this book’s premise and some of the world-building. A lot of my issues might just come down to this being a debut, and I’m hopeful the next one will build on what did work in this book.
