I must be getting too old for Mr Pratchett's Discworld. I barely crack a smile while reading his books, including this one.

I loved the twist on the life of an Egyptian Pharaoh, the Afterlife, and the Guilds as usual especially the final exam.

I liked the organization of the stories by state and although I don't normally like short stories, which each state seems to be with a mix of personal stories and factoids across time related to the main topic.

Well worth the read.

All the elements of a good story for me: plot moves along nicely, complex enough to keep the mystery a mystery for 70% of the story, the characters have personalities and there aren't too many to keep track of.

It's a quick read as well.

So depressing it's like sandpaper on the skin, nails on a chalkboard, hydrogen peroxide on an open wound.

Not sure what it was but I read the words, the words were in my native language and yet, the words chosen were vague in some way. Or maybe made allusions to topics I'm not familiar with. The result being that the sentences were not understandable and therefore the subject was not understandable.

The plot, when not sidetracked by the love triangle and ‘does he love me', angst is good. Too much of the sidetrack for my taste.

I'm sure someone will enjoy this sub-genre and give a better assessment of what to expect than I can. This is not a topic I seek out for myself.

I couldn't make it to the end with this one. Yes, it seems to be in the same universe as the Foundation series but it's missing the fascinating characters that draw you into the storyline or an intriguing plot.

Too much politics and in-fighting for my taste.

The author chooses fantastic words to describe the country, the people are wonderfully built out, and the experiences created for them are interesting and varied.

I'm not sure there's a sequel but I'd be interested to hear it.

It was nice to come back to Earthsea for awhile.