Contains spoilers

Contains spoilers

Contains spoilers

This book will always be a bittersweet 5-star for me - partially because I know what comes next. Loved seeing snippets of Fred and George being successful I've never forgiven Rowling for what she does in book 7 and I'm not sure i ever will iykyk

3.5 stars only because it took me FOREVERRRRRR to get through!!! I def enjoyed this plot more than Caraval but for whatever reason it was slower than MOLASSES

While TellaxDante will NEVER top JulianxScar, I wholeheartedly approve
And the backstories!

♥️ a childhood favorite - it really is so good though!! And I love how similar the movie adaptation is to this book

I honestly forgot just HOW GOOD this book was

I forgot how much I LOVE this series!!! Honestly, I think I like this series overall more than PJO...

Now I want to re-watch The Breakfast Club....

Anyways, this was really fun to read cause I only figured out the killer a few pages before it was revealed. I was definitely not expecting this level of complexity in the setup

And may I just say the CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT ❤️‍

I was kinda amused by the names he chose - I wonder if Robert planned the names because of this pun, or if he just picked names and then realized he could add a pun

I FORGOT HOW GOOD THIS BOOK WAS!!! Depth is added to a few characters, pasts are being introduced, and there's nothing like good ol' jealousy to add to the chaos

If you're looking for a super fluffy add-on to the series, this book isn't it. It's not bad, it just doesn't have the same intensity or as many fluffy moments as the others. but it was nice to see a little more of everyone's past....

This book will spin you around so fast until you don't know which way is up - the plot twists

Glad we got to learn more about the other Naturals, but Dean specifically... I just wanted to give him a big hug this entire book

I never noticed the dark humor that's in this one ... and I feel like everyone knows people who are like Thidwick's “guests”

5 stars bc of my love of Sirius + Lupin + Buckbeak!!! I can't even express how much i love them
- Not to mention the fact that Lupin was one of the BEST DADA professors Hogwarts had while Harry, Hermione, Ron were there

And we can't forget about Fred + George + the Marauder's Map!

Justice4Buckbeak!!