Nuno
Manon Lescaut is a hard book to evaluate. On the one hand, I didn’t really had a good experience with it, it was boring some times and the story just isn’t that great. Also there aren’t many memorable episodes in my opinion, the main ones sure but the rest just isn’t kind of meh. However, when it is good it really hooks you. I was the most invested when Des Grieux tried to rescue Manon while she was going to the boat, tensions were high, the anticipation was really good, but in the end nothing much happened and it was a bit disappointing honestly. I don’t really like Des Grieux as a character nor do I do as a narrator, he’s super manipulative and he’s also very annoying and stupid a lot of times. Manon is not great either, she just doesn’t get much to do honestly, and constantly seeing her through Des Grieux’s eyes gets a bit tiresome as he always keeps repeating how perfect she is and all that. The rest of the characters are pretty forgettable to be honest, Des Grieux’s father is alright, Manon’s brother is fine but his death is a little bit anticlimactic in my opinion it should’ve gotten more attention, and then the other guy that helps them is also fine as well as the characters in America. The prison stuff is solid, the escape was good too. The stuff in America was also interesting, the ending was very good until Manon’s death as I think from there it kind of derailed a bit. Prévost’s writing is good but nothing outstanding, it’s a cool idea however to have Renoncour serve as like this figure of authority. The book surely feels a bit revolutionary, due to everything about love prevailing over duty but it still doesn’t do it very interestingly. Yeah I guess in the end Manon Lescaut is just fine, not bad but kind of hard to get through some times, even if when good comes it is rewarding.
Manon Lescaut is a hard book to evaluate. On the one hand, I didn’t really had a good experience with it, it was boring some times and the story just isn’t that great. Also there aren’t many memorable episodes in my opinion, the main ones sure but the rest just isn’t kind of meh. However, when it is good it really hooks you. I was the most invested when Des Grieux tried to rescue Manon while she was going to the boat, tensions were high, the anticipation was really good, but in the end nothing much happened and it was a bit disappointing honestly. I don’t really like Des Grieux as a character nor do I do as a narrator, he’s super manipulative and he’s also very annoying and stupid a lot of times. Manon is not great either, she just doesn’t get much to do honestly, and constantly seeing her through Des Grieux’s eyes gets a bit tiresome as he always keeps repeating how perfect she is and all that. The rest of the characters are pretty forgettable to be honest, Des Grieux’s father is alright, Manon’s brother is fine but his death is a little bit anticlimactic in my opinion it should’ve gotten more attention, and then the other guy that helps them is also fine as well as the characters in America. The prison stuff is solid, the escape was good too. The stuff in America was also interesting, the ending was very good until Manon’s death as I think from there it kind of derailed a bit. Prévost’s writing is good but nothing outstanding, it’s a cool idea however to have Renoncour serve as like this figure of authority. The book surely feels a bit revolutionary, due to everything about love prevailing over duty but it still doesn’t do it very interestingly. Yeah I guess in the end Manon Lescaut is just fine, not bad but kind of hard to get through some times, even if when good comes it is rewarding.