There were a few interesting world building ideas here, which kept me going. The annoying offhand sex-shaming was very off putting. Overall, this felt like a writer just learning the craft, and that this should have been a trunk novel.
However, the narration was so flat and inappropriately affected that I'm not entirely sure how much of my distaste was actually his fault instead of the writers.
Enjoyable. It's only in retrospect that certain plot issues come to mind, which is fine. I'm curious to see what the authors do with the story in the next book.
Edit: I forgot to mention this thing that Amma does. She loooooves crosswords, so she spells words out. And she's infected Ethan with this highly irritating habit. I -should- deduct a star just for how much this interrupted my listening.
Freaking fantastic. This story had me hooked and emotional all over the place. Blue is a fantastic white room character and every other character was so interesting and full of nuance. I loved how certain things are just plunked down on the table and only later on do you find out just how baldly stated they'd been.
And I love a good finish and this one... the last sentence was such a great teaser. Can't wait to listen to the next one.
Speaking of listening, I normally hate Will Patton's accent when I see him in movies. And it irritated me for the first few hours, but he does really great character voices, so I forgive him. Ha.
This is definitely one of the better dystopias that I read this year. I quite enjoyed the main character and liked the way that the past was hinted at and somewhat revealed as the story progressed. That said, the entire conceit of the different factions and the way the world is set up... ridiculous. Just don't think about that and everything is good.
Or do. It's all good.
I -listened- to this. And it isn't formatted for that, at all.
I don't particularly think that the first few sections were PI, though the bit about the early settlers thinking the AmerInds were actually white under the dirt was interesting. I'll have to see if I can't corroborate that factoid.
However, as the author gets closer and closer to the now, he gets more reactionary and less ... calm? His “clearing of the air” about the Reagan legacy was a bit confusing to me. I thought it well accepted that there was increased government spending and decreased government revenue during Reagan's time in office, but, since that is what Woods claims to have actually happened. I'm confused.
Also, I'll have to ask my more conservative friends about their opinions on the Clinton scandals. I don't recall anyone being really upset about it, more a little disgusted, a little disappointed. Woods seems to have been personally angered about not only Clinton, but also the LBJ and JFK extramarital affairs.
(2 stars if I'd read it, only 1 star because I listened.)
This is the type of story that makes you wish it was in a series, just so some of the fantastic world building can be re-used, but it would dilute the magic, and so you are glad that the author is content to leave well-enough alone.
This is sort of steam/cyber-punk sci-fi. Sort of if the Red/Green/Blue Mars series crossed feelers with Vendermeer's Finch. With less mushrooms.
The World of Ice & Fire: The Untold History of Westeros and the Game of Thrones
I know I'm the oddball here, but I just didn't find anything or anyone interesting enough to make me want to put up with another few hundred thousand pages. His world is peppered with fascinating little hints of the magic that used to be commonplace, and I love that sort of thing, but ... you have to give me something in the here and now too.
If he'd stuck to fewer POV characters, I might have come to care for someone, anyone. If he'd revealed something before the last moments of the last chapter, I might want to come back for more. But he didn't and I don't.
Strange and mundane, swirled together but never quite mixed. I'm almost disappointed that the strange elements weren't just a little more magical... but then the city (and the city) wouldn't be just so unique.
I want another story with Borlu but I feel like following him any further would only serve to spoil the wonder.