Jamie Revell
Unlike the first release in the series, this really is what the blurb says it is: three separate hour-long stories. As before, all are set before the Doctor is travelling with Rose and, this time, we have one each for a contemporary, historical, and futuristic setting. But here, the stories are much more like what we got in most of the Ninth Doctor's TV run, rather than something more in the style of Moffat, as the first volume was. Eccleston is great in the role, really getting back into it, and bringing out the character's love of life.
Girl, Deconstructed – The contemporary story (which is to say, it's set around 2005) sees the Doctor responding to a distress call after dozens of teenagers have simultaneously vanished from Dundee. There isn't much mystery as to where they've gone, since that's revealed in the opening teaser, and the Doctor is able to work out the why almost instantly (although it takes him a while to explain it), leaving the story more focused on how to get them back again. Which basically consists of a lot of running about confusing people and building gadgets.
Arguably, not much happens in the story, and there isn't a real sense of threat, either. It's largely conversational, although this does result in a good portrayal of the relationship between a single parent and his teenage daughter – through whose eyes we see the disappearance, although supposedly many others are also involved. The companion surrogate is a police officer whose main role is to be alternately puzzled and exasperated by the Doctor; she's a necessary part of the story from a plot perspective but doesn't bring anything very notable. There are a few callbacks to the classic series, and a foreshadowing of an event in one of Nine's own TV episodes. Unfortunately, though, it's evident from early on where it's going and, the Doctor's chirpy eccentricity aside, not much happens on the way there. 3.5 stars.
Fright Motif – The second story is a more traditional “monster” story, although the monster is based on sound, rather than anything visible, and thus not the sort you're likely to see on TV. It's the historical one of this set, taking place in Paris in 1946, a city just recovering from a long occupation. There isn't a clear companion surrogate in this one, but the three guest characters are all worthwhile and bring out some of the themes of the era. Perhaps most notable is the concierge of the hotel where the story begins, who starts out just being obnoxious but is revealed to have greater depth as the story unfolds.
The result is a good Doctor Who story, with the monster chasing the characters across Paris, and bringing in modern themes as well as a feel for the burgeoning jazz scene of the time. (Some listeners may, however, be put off by the British-actor-doing-an-American accent thing; I'm not in the best position to judge that – although at least nobody's trying to pretend to be French). Like the TV era on which it is modelled, there are some humorous lines here and there, and a good mix of wackiness and seriousness from the Doctor that keeps it effective and enjoyable. 4 stars.
Planet of the End – Once again answering a distress call, the Doctor arrives on an uninhabited world used as a planet-sized graveyard. It's not the first time that particular concept has been used on the show, but here, it's a peaceful place, full of nature, rather than the spookier vibe that such settings normally go for. The story, of course, concerns the nature of the distress call and it's interesting to note that there isn't a monster in this one, with the villains instead being provided by sinister corporate types that appear in the opening teaser, but whose connection to events takes a while to become apparent.
The journey to getting there is, however, enjoyable, partly due to the commentary on it provided by the plant's automated caretaker, who effectively takes the companion role in this story despite initially distrusting the Doctor's motives. The changing scenery and the evolving nature of the threat keep things moving along more swiftly than they might otherwise. True, the villains are rather one-note and prone to expressing everything in corporate-speak, but the clever use of the caretaker offsets that and the story is overall an enjoyable one that manages to balance a sense of peril with the Doctor's positive outlook – without relying quite so much on the craziness. 4.5 stars.
Unlike the first release in the series, this really is what the blurb says it is: three separate hour-long stories. As before, all are set before the Doctor is travelling with Rose and, this time, we have one each for a contemporary, historical, and futuristic setting. But here, the stories are much more like what we got in most of the Ninth Doctor's TV run, rather than something more in the style of Moffat, as the first volume was. Eccleston is great in the role, really getting back into it, and bringing out the character's love of life.
Girl, Deconstructed – The contemporary story (which is to say, it's set around 2005) sees the Doctor responding to a distress call after dozens of teenagers have simultaneously vanished from Dundee. There isn't much mystery as to where they've gone, since that's revealed in the opening teaser, and the Doctor is able to work out the why almost instantly (although it takes him a while to explain it), leaving the story more focused on how to get them back again. Which basically consists of a lot of running about confusing people and building gadgets.
Arguably, not much happens in the story, and there isn't a real sense of threat, either. It's largely conversational, although this does result in a good portrayal of the relationship between a single parent and his teenage daughter – through whose eyes we see the disappearance, although supposedly many others are also involved. The companion surrogate is a police officer whose main role is to be alternately puzzled and exasperated by the Doctor; she's a necessary part of the story from a plot perspective but doesn't bring anything very notable. There are a few callbacks to the classic series, and a foreshadowing of an event in one of Nine's own TV episodes. Unfortunately, though, it's evident from early on where it's going and, the Doctor's chirpy eccentricity aside, not much happens on the way there. 3.5 stars.
Fright Motif – The second story is a more traditional “monster” story, although the monster is based on sound, rather than anything visible, and thus not the sort you're likely to see on TV. It's the historical one of this set, taking place in Paris in 1946, a city just recovering from a long occupation. There isn't a clear companion surrogate in this one, but the three guest characters are all worthwhile and bring out some of the themes of the era. Perhaps most notable is the concierge of the hotel where the story begins, who starts out just being obnoxious but is revealed to have greater depth as the story unfolds.
The result is a good Doctor Who story, with the monster chasing the characters across Paris, and bringing in modern themes as well as a feel for the burgeoning jazz scene of the time. (Some listeners may, however, be put off by the British-actor-doing-an-American accent thing; I'm not in the best position to judge that – although at least nobody's trying to pretend to be French). Like the TV era on which it is modelled, there are some humorous lines here and there, and a good mix of wackiness and seriousness from the Doctor that keeps it effective and enjoyable. 4 stars.
Planet of the End – Once again answering a distress call, the Doctor arrives on an uninhabited world used as a planet-sized graveyard. It's not the first time that particular concept has been used on the show, but here, it's a peaceful place, full of nature, rather than the spookier vibe that such settings normally go for. The story, of course, concerns the nature of the distress call and it's interesting to note that there isn't a monster in this one, with the villains instead being provided by sinister corporate types that appear in the opening teaser, but whose connection to events takes a while to become apparent.
The journey to getting there is, however, enjoyable, partly due to the commentary on it provided by the plant's automated caretaker, who effectively takes the companion role in this story despite initially distrusting the Doctor's motives. The changing scenery and the evolving nature of the threat keep things moving along more swiftly than they might otherwise. True, the villains are rather one-note and prone to expressing everything in corporate-speak, but the clever use of the caretaker offsets that and the story is overall an enjoyable one that manages to balance a sense of peril with the Doctor's positive outlook – without relying quite so much on the craziness. 4.5 stars.