The Hidden Influence of the World's Most Powerful Consulting Firm
Ratings21
Average rating3.7
NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER • An explosive, deeply reported exposé of McKinsey & Company, the international consulting firm that advises corporations and governments, that highlights the often drastic impact of its work on employees and citizens around the world "Meticulously reported, and ultimately devastating, this is an important book." —Patrick Radden Keefe, New York Times bestselling author of Empire of Pain and Say Nothing McKinsey & Company is the most prestigious consulting company in the world, earning billions of dollars in fees from major corporations and governments who turn to it to maximize their profits and enhance efficiency. McKinsey's vaunted statement of values asserts that its role is to make the world a better place, and its reputation for excellence and discretion attracts top talent from universities around the world. But what does it actually do? In When McKinsey Comes to Town, two prizewinning investigative journalists have written a portrait of the company sharply at odds with its public image. Often McKinsey's advice boils down to major cost-cutting, including layoffs and maintenance reductions, to drive up short-term profits, thereby boosting a company's stock price and the wealth of its executives who hire it, at the expense of workers and safety measures. McKinsey collects millions of dollars advising government agencies that also regulate McKinsey's corporate clients. And the firm frequently advises competitors in the same industries, but denies that this presents any conflict of interest. In one telling example, McKinsey advised a Chinese engineering company allied with the communist government which constructed artificial islands, now used as staging grounds for the Chinese Navy—while at the same time taking tens of millions of dollars from the Pentagon, whose chief aim is to counter Chinese aggression. Shielded by NDAs, McKinsey has escaped public scrutiny despite its role in advising tobacco and vaping companies, purveyors of opioids, repressive governments, and oil companies. McKinsey helped insurance companies' boost their profits by making it incredibly difficult for accident victims to get payments; worked its U.S. government contacts to let Wall Street firms evade scrutiny; enabled corruption in developing countries such as South Africa; undermined health-care programs in states across the country. And much more. Bogdanich and Forsythe have penetrated the veil of secrecy surrounding McKinsey by conducting hundreds of interviews, obtaining tens of thousands of revelatory documents, and following rule #1 of investigative reporting: Follow the money. When McKinsey Comes to Town is a landmark work of investigative reporting that amounts to a devastating portrait of a firm whose work has often made the world more unequal, more corrupt, and more dangerous.
Reviews with the most likes.
This was an interesting look at McKinsey. Few thoughts on it bulleted below. I don't think we can blame everything on McKinsey, even though the book feels like projecting that view. There are faults on both sides of aisle.
1. Ethics: a company will need to decide whether it values its ethics and values and has the want and courage to uphold them. Book's message is that McKinsey does not respect those internally on a consistent basis. The company has a lot of conflicting positions and grey areas.
2. Buyers responsibility: Governments and companies need to understand what they are buying. The book has classic cases where consultants recommend something they've been asked to recommend. It could stop there. However, companies go to great lengths in implementing, many times poorly, suggestions done on slide decks that are on theoretical level. Practical implementation is a few degrees off from PowerPoint visualizations. Also in this day and age many issues mentioned in the book would be avoided if the buyer would also have strong ethics values in the buying process and follow strictly ESG screening when buying these types of services. Sure, idealistic thinking, however if we want to stand for something both sides would need to improve a lot.
I can't even count how many times my jaw hit the floor reading this book. Just when you think you have some understanding of how corrupt people/companies can be, something like this just slaps you in the face with it. It's honestly horrendous and amazing all at the same time how many pies McKinsey has been able to stick their grubby thumbs into. Worth a read if you feel like being filled with horror and a healthy dose of righteous indignation.