The Searcher
2020 • 466 pages

Ratings102

Average rating3.8

15

A very slow and winding whodunit situated in rural Ireland. I enjoyed it and found the writing pleasant, but the plot was almost unbearably slow. I'd say the majority of the action happens ~75% of the way in. It also resolves rather quickly which was dissatisfying (though not enough to DNF it). The main plot ties itself into a nice bow at the end, but the sub plots are unresolved.

French is very good at leading the reader to water / showing-not-telling. That said there were several chunks where I had to push myself to keep reading despite massive confusion. French is in cahoots with the characters, and they're having a joke at your expense. The joke is that you don't know what the telltale signs of a meth lab are :)

The writing can also get repetitive, sometimes it feels intentional as our main character is a bit of a bumbling cop type who ~”analyses the world around him for threats”, “is always on high alert”, etc. except for when he's getting ambushed in his own driveway.

It wasn't so scary that I couldn't sleep after reading it before bed, but it does have an eeriness to it. French does an excellent job of giving the scenery its due. You can feel the mist.

May 14, 2025